diff --git a/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md b/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md index 22ee4182..49c5cbf6 100644 --- a/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md +++ b/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md @@ -79,8 +79,8 @@ 정량 evidence와 익명 품질 평가를 결합하되 원본 수치와 해석을 분리한다. -- [ ] [objective-validation] 각 결과의 build/serve, desktop·mobile screenshot, 이미지·asset, console 오류, 요구사항·반응형·접근성 gate와 최종 workspace 상태를 자동 검증한다. -- [ ] [quality-scoring] 익명화된 9개 결과에 요구사항 25, 시각 완성도 25, 반응형·접근성 15, 이미지·디테일 10, 안정성 10, 코드 품질 10, 자체 검증 5의 동일 100점 rubric으로 Codex가 점수를 기록한다. +- [ ] [objective-validation] 복구 후 새 C01-C09 full run의 각 결과에 build/serve, desktop·mobile screenshot, 이미지·asset, console 오류, 요구사항·반응형·접근성 gate와 최종 workspace 상태를 자동 검증한다. 생성물 존재·정적 안전·asset·render hard gate는 모두 통과해야 하며 품질 gate 실패는 익명 채점의 감점 evidence로 전달한다. +- [ ] [quality-scoring] 익명화된 9개 결과 모두에 요구사항 25, 시각 완성도 25, 반응형·접근성 15, 이미지·디테일 10, 안정성 10, 코드 품질 10, 자체 검증 5의 동일 100점 rubric으로 Codex가 점수를 기록한다. 완료 집계는 `scored=9`, `unscored=0`, `scoring_failed=0`, `blocked=0`이어야 한다. - [ ] [performance-usage] 첫 output·첫 file write·model 호출별·tool·queue·전체 finish/idle 시간, 호출 횟수와 model/stage별 input/output/reasoning/cached/total token을 clock/source·미제공 여부와 함께 비교하고 중첩 구간이나 미관측 overhead를 임의 산술 분해하지 않는다. - [ ] [benchmark-report] 9개 결과의 속도·품질·token 표, 실행 조건·버전·실패·한계·raw evidence 링크를 포함한 날짜별 Markdown 보고서를 `agent-test/dev/`에 남긴다. @@ -105,7 +105,7 @@ - 관련 경로: `agent-test/dev/`, `agent-test/runs/`, `../iop-s2` - 표준선: preflight는 scored attempt와 분리하고, scored 실행이 시작된 뒤의 실패는 결과로 보존하며 재실행이 필요하면 새 attempt로 기록한다. - 표준선: IOP credential/model route가 없으면 안전한 등록을 요청하고, alias/effort를 임의 대체하지 않는다. -- 현재 차단: packet 14의 fresh 5-cell direct 진단과 배포 qualification 진행 중. retained direct run은 `unresolved=0`인 terminal evidence지만 all-success는 아니며 기존 run을 resume/retry/수정하지 않는다. 새 qualification은 fresh `ready=5`, 정확히 5개 attempt, 모든 controller/product/harness/process/web-validation terminal evidence와 exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block 없음으로 판정하고 제품 실패·provider rejection·timeout은 benchmark 결과로 보존한다. 이 진단이 통과하면 fresh C01-C09 `ready=9`를 확인하고, 후속 packet에서 기존 run과 다른 identity로 repetitions=1 scored run을 한 번 실행한다. 비교 Task 체크 상태는 scored evidence가 생길 때까지 변경하지 않는다. +- 현재 차단: 보존 run `run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c`은 2개 scored/7개 unscored이므로 완료 근거가 아니다. Claude/agy caller·IOP route와 scoring eligibility를 복구하고 짧은 route별 smoke를 통과한 뒤, 기존 run과 다른 identity의 새 C01-C09 full run을 실행해 9개 모두 success/hard-gate-pass/scored가 되어야 한다. 이전 run과 attempt는 resume/retry/수정하지 않는다. - 실행 순서와 차단 관계: [전역 마일스톤 실행 순서](../../../priority-queue.md) - 관련 Milestone: [[bench-01] Agent 비교 벤치마크 파이프라인 준비](agent-comparison-benchmark-pipeline.md), [[route-02] IOP 단일 요청 Agent 실행](../../../archive/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-owned-single-request-agent-execution.md) - 확인 필요: 없음 diff --git a/agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md b/agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md index 290a312b..de22385d 100644 --- a/agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md +++ b/agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md @@ -27,6 +27,8 @@ - [x] [D11] 공식 `agy 1.1.12`는 Gemini API-key provider의 route별 `GOOGLE_GEMINI_BASE_URL`을 IOP Edge로 지정하고 `GEMINI_API_KEY`에는 upstream key가 아닌 IOP principal token을 넣는다. `--effort`와 비공식 custom model은 사용하지 않고 high effort는 IOP effective binding으로 검증한다. - [x] [D12] marked hybrid preset은 dev managed credential plane의 fresh projection, 고정 stage authorization과 sealed provider lease가 준비된 뒤에만 실행하며 legacy credential fallback을 허용하지 않는다. - [x] [D13] 배포 qualification의 5-cell direct 진단은 all-success가 아니라 terminal-evidence completeness를 판정한다. fresh `ready=5`, 정확히 5개의 fresh attempt, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, 모든 slot의 controller/product/harness/process/web-validation terminal evidence와 exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block 없음이 필요하다. 제품 실패·provider rejection·caller failure 뒤 generated-missing·timeout은 보존할 benchmark 결과이며 암묵 재시도하지 않는다. Edge pre-ingress incompatibility 또는 exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block만 qualification을 막는다. 이 unscored 진단은 D06/D10의 유일한 새 scored C01-C09 run identity를 소비하지 않는다. + - [x] [D14] Milestone 완료에는 복구 후 승인된 새 C01-C09 full run에서 9개 cell 모두 `product=succeeded`, `harness=passed`, `process=exited/0`, 신뢰 가능한 생성물과 viewport screenshot을 남기고 익명 rubric 결과가 `scored=9`, `unscored=0`, `scoring_failed=0`, `blocked=0`이어야 한다. terminal failure를 보존했다는 사실만으로 Milestone이나 최종 벤치 task를 완료하지 않는다. + - [x] [D15] 생성 파일·정적 안전·asset·render처럼 evaluator 입력의 존재와 신뢰성을 보장하는 gate는 hard eligibility로 유지한다. console·responsive·accessibility처럼 생성물의 품질을 평가하는 gate 실패는 신뢰 가능한 페이지가 존재하면 unscored 사유가 아니라 익명 rubric의 감점 evidence로 전달한다. ## 문제 / 비목표 @@ -60,8 +62,8 @@ | `ready` | fixture와 C01-C09 immutable manifest 확정 | `running`, `cancelled` | manifest/fixture/rubric digest | | `running` | seed 순서에 따라 각 cell에 사용자 작업 1회 제출 | `validating`, `failed`, `timed_out`, `cancelled` | cell/attempt event timeline | | `validating` | cell finish/complete 후 idle 확정 | `scoring`, `failed` | workspace, build/render/test evidence | -| `scoring` | C01-C09 결과 identity 제거 완료 | `analyzing`, `failed` | blind mapping과 rubric worksheet | -| `analyzing` | 자동 gate·시간·usage·score 완비 | `reported`, `failed` | comparison table과 limitation notes | +| `scoring` | C01-C09 결과 identity 제거 완료 | `analyzing`, `failed` | 9개 blind mapping과 rubric worksheet | +| `analyzing` | 자동 gate·시간·usage와 9개 score 완비 | `reported`, `failed` | `scored=9`, `unscored=0`, `scoring_failed=0`, `blocked=0` 및 comparison table | | `reported` | Markdown과 raw evidence 포인터 생성 | 종료 | report path와 digest | | `failed` | cell 실행·검증·채점·보고 실패 | `analyzing`, 종료 | 보존된 실패 attempt; 누락 없는 matrix | | `timed_out` | cell timeout | `analyzing`, 종료 | timeout/cancel/cleanup evidence | @@ -76,6 +78,8 @@ State invariant: - model/tool 호출 횟수는 제약이 아니라 측정 대상이며 finish event 뒤 idle까지가 wall-clock terminal이다. - 실패 cell도 report matrix에 남고 재실행 결과는 원래 attempt를 대체하지 않는다. - 배포 qualification의 5-cell direct 진단은 scored C01-C09 run과 별개다. terminal evidence가 완결된 제품 실패·provider rejection·timeout을 acceptance failure로 재해석하지 않고, Edge pre-ingress incompatibility 또는 최대 renderer 재시도 뒤 browser/CDP infrastructure block만 다음 단계 진입을 막는다. +- 복구 후 final full run은 9개 cell 모두 성공 산출물과 익명 점수를 가져야 한다. 어느 한 cell이라도 product/harness/process/hard artifact gate가 실패하거나 `unscored`, `scoring_failed`, `blocked`이면 보고서는 진단 산출물로 보존하되 Milestone 완료로 판정하지 않는다. +- 품질 gate 실패는 hard trust gate와 분리한다. 생성물이 신뢰 가능하면 console·responsive·accessibility 실패도 evaluator에 전달해 해당 rubric 항목에서 감점한다. ## Interface Contract @@ -112,8 +116,8 @@ State invariant: | S06 | `gpt-standalone` | C04-C05 clean workspace | Claude Code와 Codex 사용자 작업을 각각 1회 제출 | 두 caller 모두 IOP→GPT xhigh 결과와 caller별 timing/usage를 남긴다. | | S07 | `gemini-hybrid` | C06-C07 clean workspace | Claude Code와 agy 사용자 작업을 각각 1회 제출 | IOP Gemini plan→ornith work→Gemini review/repair의 stage evidence와 최종 결과를 남긴다. | | S08 | `gpt-hybrid` | C08-C09 clean workspace | Claude Code와 Codex 사용자 작업을 각각 1회 제출 | IOP GPT plan→ornith work→GPT review/repair의 stage evidence와 최종 결과를 남긴다. | -| S09 | `objective-validation` | C01-C09 성공·실패 workspace | 자동 웹 검증 | 각 cell의 동일 gate 결과, screenshot과 실패 이유가 누락 없이 생성된다. | -| S10 | `quality-scoring` | identity가 제거된 9개 결과 | Codex rubric 평가 | 항목별 점수/근거와 총점이 자동 gate와 분리되어 기록된다. | +| S09 | `objective-validation` | 복구 후 C01-C09 성공 workspace | 자동 웹 검증 | 각 cell의 동일 hard trust gate, 품질 gate와 desktop/mobile screenshot이 누락 없이 생성되며 hard gate는 모두 통과한다. | +| S10 | `quality-scoring` | identity가 제거된 9개 신뢰 가능 결과 | Codex rubric 평가 | 9개 모두 항목별 점수/근거와 총점이 기록되고 `scored=9`, `unscored=0`, `scoring_failed=0`, `blocked=0`이다. 품질 gate 실패는 해당 항목의 감점 evidence다. | | S11 | `performance-usage` | 모든 attempt timeline/usage | 비교 집계 | 첫 output·첫 write·model/tool/queue/total 시간의 clock/source·overlap, 호출 수와 token/source가 cell·stage별 표가 된다. | | S12 | `benchmark-report` | S01-S11 evidence | 보고서 생성 | 조건·버전·9개 결과·속도·token·품질·실패·한계와 raw evidence 링크가 Markdown에 남는다. | | S13 | `agy-iop-compatibility` | official `agy 1.1.12`와 dev Edge | direct·hybrid route별 Gemini base URL로 실제 API-key 호출 | 두 호출 모두 `x-goog-api-key` IOP principal auth, Gemini-native request/tool/SSE, official `stream-json` finish/exit와 config-owned effective binding evidence를 남기고 upstream key 직접 호출이나 합성 event에 의존하지 않는다. | @@ -138,7 +142,7 @@ State invariant: | S13 | official agy request-shape capture, Edge Gemini bridge tests, direct·hybrid live preflight와 sanitized lifecycle/usage | `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/06+05_comparison_runs/` | `agy-iop-compatibility` official 1.1.12 IOP transport evidence | | S14 | dev config check, TLS/workload identity, projection generation, slot-route/lease attribution과 post-revoke no-fallback smoke | `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/06+05_comparison_runs/` | `managed-credential-dev` secure composition and hybrid admission evidence | -공통 완료 검증은 C01-C09 모두가 success/failure/blocked 중 하나의 terminal evidence를 가지고, 성공 결과의 자동 gate·screenshot·blind score와 모든 attempt의 timing/usage source가 보고서에 연결되는지 확인한다. 필수 credential/model이 없으면 raw secret을 요구하거나 기록하지 않고 운영 절차로 등록을 요청한다. +공통 완료 검증은 복구 후 승인된 새 C01-C09 full run에서 9개 모두 success terminal evidence, hard trust gate 통과, desktop/mobile screenshot, blind score와 timing/usage source를 가지며 최종 집계가 `scored=9`, `unscored=0`, `scoring_failed=0`, `blocked=0`인지 확인한다. 이전 실패 run은 원인·한계 evidence로 보존하지만 완료 근거를 대체하지 않는다. 필수 credential/model이 없으면 raw secret을 요구하거나 기록하지 않고 운영 절차로 등록을 요청한다. ## Cross-repo Dependencies @@ -157,6 +161,7 @@ State invariant: - 2026-08-12: 공식 `agy 1.1.12` API-key provider의 실제 Gemini-native 요청과 `stream-json` event를 확인했고, 사용자의 provider 직접 설정 지시에 따라 upstream key와 IOP principal token을 분리하며 dev managed credential plane까지 구성하는 D11-D12를 기술 보강했다. - 2026-08-13: 사용자가 terminal outcome과 dispatcher 환경 보완 뒤 다음 벤치까지 계속 실행하도록 승인했다. 이에 기존 실패 run을 보존하고 resume/retry하지 않은 채, 동일 immutable C01-C09 manifest로 repetitions=1인 새 scored run identity를 한 번 생성하는 D06/D10 경계를 확정했다. - 2026-08-13: 승인된 후속 packet에 따라 direct 배포 qualification을 terminal-evidence admission으로 분리했다. 제품 실패·provider rejection·timeout은 측정 결과로 보존하고, Edge pre-ingress incompatibility와 exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block만 qualification을 막는 D13을 추가했다. D06/D10의 scored-run uniqueness는 유지한다. +- 2026-08-13: 사용자가 2개 scored/7개 unscored 상태에서 종료하지 말고 9개 모두 측정되도록 원인을 해소하라고 명시했다. 이에 기존 실패 run은 보존하되 완료 조건을 복구 후 새 full run의 `9/9 scored`로 강화하고, 품질 gate와 hard trust gate를 분리하는 D14-D15를 추가했다. ## 작업 컨텍스트 diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G08_2.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G08_2.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..48b19e5f --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G08_2.log @@ -0,0 +1,320 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - REVIEW_API + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST] Filling in this file is the mandatory final step of implementation.** +> The task is NOT complete until every implementation-owned section below is filled in. +> Complete the `Implementation Checklist`; the final checklist item is mandatory before saving. +> Fill implementation-owned sections, then stop with active files in place and report ready for review. +> Execute the plan's selected root cause, scope, files, and dependency decisions as written. Do not choose another owner, narrow/expand the write boundary, or replace a fix with another verification attempt. +> If implementation is blocked, record the exact blocker, attempted commands/output, and resume condition only in implementation-owned evidence fields. +> Do not ask the user directly, present choices, call user-input tools, create control-plane stop files, or classify the next state. +> Finalization (`Code Review Result`, log rename, `complete.log`, archive moves, `Review-Only Checklist`) is review-agent-only, even after compaction/resume. +> Follow the ownership table at the bottom of this file for which sections you own. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-13 +task=m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission, plan=2, tag=REVIEW_API + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Prior plan: `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G10_1.log`. +- Prior review: `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log`, verdict `FAIL`, Required R1 only, Suggested/Nit none. +- Resolved authorization: `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/user_review_0.log`; the authorization enables new verification and is not terminal PASS evidence. +- Failed immutable qualification: `run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e`, `artifact_blocked=1`, `reason=cdp_socket_closed`. +- Retained immutable run: `run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa`, 5,489 regular files, digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. + +## For the Review Agent + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** The finalization steps below are review-agent only. Implementing agents must not execute this section. + +Compare implementation evidence against the plan and immutable run state. Rerun applicable read-only verification and record fresh output. Completion requires one and only one newly authorized direct run, no exhausted browser/CDP block, prior-run immutability, and no release/runtime mutation by this packet. + +1. Append verdict and `review_rework_count` / `evidence_integrity_failure` routing signals. +2. Archive `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` to `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log` and `PLAN-cloud-G08.md` to `plan_cloud_G08_2.log`. +3. If PASS, write `complete.log` and move this subtask to `agent-task/archive/YYYY/MM/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/`. If WARN/FAIL, materialize the required next state. +4. If PASS, preserve `milestone-task=agy-iop-compatibility,route-readiness,objective-validation` for runtime aggregation without updating the roadmap directly. + +--- + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| REVIEW_API-4 — Frozen completed release/runtime identity | [x] | +| REVIEW_API-5 — Bounded Chromium/CDP admission | [x] | +| REVIEW_API-6 — One authorized direct qualification | [x] | +| REVIEW_API-7 — Terminal and immutable evidence audit | [x] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] [REVIEW_API-4] Prove `dev-974` is finished and freeze one clean release/artifact/runtime/provider identity without mutating shared runtime state. +- [x] [REVIEW_API-5] Pass one bounded Chromium/CDP renderer integration preflight before any new benchmark allocation. +- [x] [REVIEW_API-6] Through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`, invoke exactly one fresh direct CLI `preflight` and exactly one fresh direct CLI `run`, with no resume/retry or alternate caller path. +- [x] [REVIEW_API-7] Audit the issued run for exactly five attempts, complete terminal axes, `artifact_blocked=0`, and audit both prior runs for immutability. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` with actual commands and output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** This checklist is used only by the review agent. +> Implementing agents must not modify or check this section. + +- [x] Append one verdict of `PASS`, `WARN`, or `FAIL` and verified `review_rework_count`, `evidence_integrity_failure` to `Code Review Result`. +- [x] Verify that verdict, dimension assessment, and Required/Suggested/Nit classifications match. +- [x] Run applicable required verification and record fresh output. +- [x] For every Required/Suggested finding, close evidence, root cause, selected fix, ownership, and acceptance commands before follow-up. +- [x] Archive this review to `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log`. +- [x] Archive its plan to `plan_cloud_G08_2.log`. +- [x] Verify generated task artifacts are not ignored. +- [x] If PASS, write `complete.log`, archive the task directory, preserve milestone metadata, and report completion metadata. +- [ ] If WARN/FAIL, write the next filesystem state and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +- The Control Plane status endpoint now requires HTTPS. The planned read-only status check returned HTTP 400 with `Client sent an HTTP request to an HTTPS server.`; the same exact runner-local endpoint was then queried with `curl -ksS https://127.0.0.1:18001/...`, returning health/readiness HTTP 200 and the redacted Edge status. No certificate, runtime, config, or process state was changed. +- The four binaries retain build metadata for candidate commit `2fcc1093c7629ab94b460d083520ffd9c8064815`, while the finished tag peels to merge commit `fd41adac777f7c7faea0cdd27acbe2817890abf8` and the clean runner is at post-finish `dev` commit `019500a5d65117bfd115e0c33601ceef3461ee52`. All three commits resolve to the identical tree `d46c7e3057bafbeedc1ddb10d2619feb3c6eb2db`, so the planned source/tag/artifact tree invariant is satisfied without rebuilding or altering the release. + +## Key Design Decisions + +- Treated authoritative remote refs plus Git tree identity as the freeze boundary: `refs/heads/release/dev-974` was absent, `dev-974` existed, and tag, clean checkout, and candidate artifact source shared one tree. +- Kept the authorization count closed: one BrowserRenderer integration test, one direct CLI `preflight`, one direct CLI `run`, and no `resume`, retry flag, alternate caller, or provider invocation. +- Preserved product failures and timeout as terminal benchmark outcomes. Admission was judged only by complete five-slot evidence and `artifact_blocked=0`, per SDD D13/S02. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- [x] Confirm `dev-974` is fully finished before any benchmark allocation and every observed artifact/runtime identity agrees. +- [x] Confirm this packet did not mutate `dev-974`, shared runtime configuration, credentials, subscriptions, manifests, routes, or old runs. +- [x] Confirm the actual BrowserRenderer integration test passed once before the direct preflight/run. +- [x] Confirm exactly one new direct run was issued, with no resume, retry, second run, or ad-hoc caller/provider invocation. +- [x] Confirm all five slots have controller/product/harness/process/web terminal evidence and `artifact_blocked=0`. +- [x] Confirm product failures/timeouts remain measured outcomes rather than acceptance failures or implicit retry triggers. +- [x] Confirm retained and failed prior run roots are unchanged. + +## Verification Results + +### REVIEW_API-4 release/runtime freeze + +```bash +git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main refs/heads/dev refs/heads/release/dev-974 refs/tags/dev-974 'refs/tags/dev-974^{}' +ssh toki@toki-labs.com '/bin/zsh -lc '\''cd /Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev && git status --short --branch && git rev-parse HEAD && for f in build/dev-runtime/bin/edge build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-linux-arm64 build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-windows-amd64.exe; do go version -m "$f" | sed -n "/vcs.revision/p;/vcs.modified/p"; done'\''' +``` + +```text +command: git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main refs/heads/dev refs/heads/release/dev-974 refs/tags/dev-974 'refs/tags/dev-974^{}' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +019500a5d65117bfd115e0c33601ceef3461ee52 refs/heads/dev +fd41adac777f7c7faea0cdd27acbe2817890abf8 refs/heads/main +4d2596e3779027ba88457c44fcc9bc91134cf5e9 refs/tags/dev-974 +fd41adac777f7c7faea0cdd27acbe2817890abf8 refs/tags/dev-974^{} +stderr: (none) + +interpretation: `refs/heads/release/dev-974` is absent and the annotated tag exists. + +command: read-only remote checkout, tag, candidate, artifact, process, and listener audit +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +- checkout: `## dev...origin/dev`, HEAD `019500a5d65117bfd115e0c33601ceef3461ee52`, tree `d46c7e3057bafbeedc1ddb10d2619feb3c6eb2db` +- peeled tag commit: `fd41adac777f7c7faea0cdd27acbe2817890abf8`, tree `d46c7e3057bafbeedc1ddb10d2619feb3c6eb2db` +- candidate artifact commit: `2fcc1093c7629ab94b460d083520ffd9c8064815`, tree `d46c7e3057bafbeedc1ddb10d2619feb3c6eb2db` +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/edge`: `vcs.revision=2fcc1093c7629ab94b460d083520ffd9c8064815`, `vcs.modified=false` +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node`: same revision, `vcs.modified=false` +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-linux-arm64`: same revision, `vcs.modified=false` +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-windows-amd64.exe`: same revision, `vcs.modified=false` +- listeners: `18082=1`, `18083=1`, `18084=1`, `19093=1`, `19101=1` +- live runner processes: Edge PID 26756 and mac Node PID 26895 execute the audited `build/dev-runtime/bin/*` paths; config arguments were redacted. +stderr: (none) + +command: curl -ksS https://127.0.0.1:18001/healthz, /readyz, and /edges/edge-toki-labs-dev/status +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +- healthz: `ok`, HTTP 200 +- readyz: `ready`, HTTP 200 +- Nodes: `mac-codex-node`, `gx10-vllm-node`, `onexplayer-lemonade-node`, `rtx5090-lemonade-node`; all `connected=true` +- `mac-gemini-api 1/0/0 healthy`; `mac-mlx-vllm 2/0/0 healthy`; `glm-coding 1/0/0 healthy`; `anthropic-api 1/0/0 healthy`; `openai-api 1/0/0 healthy` +- `gx10-vllm 4/0/0 healthy`; `onexplayer-lemonade 3/0/0 healthy`; `rtx5090-lemonade 1/0/0 healthy` +stderr: (none) + +provider tuple order above is `capacity/in_flight/queued`. No release ref, artifact, config, credential, process, or runtime state was mutated. +``` + +### REVIEW_API-5 Chromium/CDP admission + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test.BrowserIntegrationTest.test_valid_page_emits_complete_two_viewport_observations +``` + +```text +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test.BrowserIntegrationTest.test_valid_page_emits_complete_two_viewport_observations +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +. +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 1 test in 2.584s + +OK +stderr: (none) + +command count: 1. This completed before either benchmark CLI command. +``` + +### REVIEW_API-6 one direct preflight/run + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +``` + +```text +command: /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: preflight run_id=run-20260813T064206Z-07771a1afcbe status=ready ready=5 registration_required=0 implementation_gap=0 +stderr: (none) + +command: /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: run run_id=run-20260813T064211Z-212a8e1c4b9f executed=5 unresolved=0 completed=4 timed_out=1 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=2 product_failed=2 product_unknown=1 harness_passed=4 harness_failed=1 process_exited=4 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=1 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=1 artifact_failed=4 artifact_blocked=0 artifact_not_run=0 +stderr: (none) + +counts: direct preflight=1, direct run=1, resume=0, retry=0, alternate caller/provider invocation=0. Issued qualification run ID: `run-20260813T064211Z-212a8e1c4b9f`. +``` + +### REVIEW_API-7 exact status and immutability + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id +``` + +```text +command: /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id run-20260813T064211Z-212a8e1c4b9f +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: status run_id=run-20260813T064211Z-212a8e1c4b9f unresolved=0 completed=4 timed_out=1 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=2 product_failed=2 product_unknown=1 harness_passed=4 harness_failed=1 process_exited=4 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=1 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=1 artifact_failed=4 artifact_blocked=0 artifact_not_run=0 +stderr: (none) + +file audit: exactly 5 `attempt.json` and exactly 5 `web-validation.json` files, one `attempt-000001` for each manifest cell. + +terminal summaries: +- `agy-gemini-direct`: controller `completed`; product `failed/caller_error`; harness `passed/success`, ordered terminal and cleanup complete; process `exited/1`; web `failed/generated_missing`. +- `claude-gemini-direct`: controller `completed`; product `succeeded/caller_success`; harness `passed/success`, ordered terminal and cleanup complete; process `exited/0`; browser observed with 2 screenshots, 2 viewports, 11 requests; web `failed/image_evidence_failed` (accessibility also failed). +- `claude-gpt-direct`: controller `completed`; product `failed/caller_error`; harness `passed/success`, ordered terminal and cleanup complete; process `exited/1`; web `failed/generated_missing`. +- `claude-sonnet-direct`: controller `timed_out`; product `unknown/unavailable`; harness `failed/timed_out`, cleanup complete; process `timed_out/143`; web `failed/generated_missing`. +- `codex-gpt-direct`: controller `completed`; product `succeeded/caller_success`; harness `passed/success`, ordered terminal and cleanup complete; process `exited/0`; browser observed with 2 screenshots, 2 viewports, 12 requests; all seven web gates passed and web status is `passed`. + +browser/CDP admission: no web record is blocked, aggregate `artifact_blocked=0`, and the previously affected Codex cell has a complete two-viewport browser record. No Gemini rejection observation was present in the closed non-secret run evidence, so no live rejection origin is inferred. + +command: failed prior run status and closed CDP record audit +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +- `run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e`: `unresolved=0 completed=3 timed_out=2 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=1 product_failed=2 product_unknown=2 harness_passed=3 harness_failed=2 process_exited=3 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=2 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=0 artifact_failed=4 artifact_blocked=1 artifact_not_run=0` +- Codex web record remains `status=blocked`, `reason=cdp_socket_closed`, `browser_status=not_observed`, screenshots=0, viewports=0. +- exactly 5 `attempt.json` and 5 `web-validation.json`; regular files=5,497; sorted full-path SHA-256 stream digest=`14711f384e2b577d26a4897c67d88e56b8766a892e735048fa8ad7d55ad444c1`. +stderr: (none) + +command: retained prior run regular-file count and sorted full-path SHA-256 stream digest +exit_code: 0 +stdout: `run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa files=5489 digest=d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd` +stderr: (none) + +The retained digest exactly matches the frozen baseline. Both prior run trees were read only; no run was resumed, retried, or edited. +``` + +### Final verification + +```bash +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +```text +command: git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (none) +stderr: (none) + +command: git status --short --branch +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +## feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison...origin/feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison +?? agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/ +stderr: (none) + +Only the active task evidence tree is untracked; there are no tracked product, benchmark, manifest, runtime, release, credential, or subscription changes. +``` + +### Reviewer fresh verification + +```text +command: /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id run-20260813T064211Z-212a8e1c4b9f +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: status run_id=run-20260813T064211Z-212a8e1c4b9f unresolved=0 completed=4 timed_out=1 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=2 product_failed=2 product_unknown=1 harness_passed=4 harness_failed=1 process_exited=4 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=1 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=1 artifact_failed=4 artifact_blocked=0 artifact_not_run=0 +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test.BrowserIntegrationTest.test_valid_page_emits_complete_two_viewport_observations +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 1 test in 2.022s; OK +stderr: (none) + +new-run file audit: attempt.json=5, web-validation.json=5. Every slot is terminal; Codex has browser observed, two screenshots, two viewports, and web status passed. The remaining generated-missing, image-evidence, and timeout outcomes are terminal product/artifact results, not infrastructure blocks. + +immutable audit: run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e files=5497 digest=14711f384e2b577d26a4897c67d88e56b8766a892e735048fa8ad7d55ad444c1; run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa files=5489 digest=d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd. + +release/runtime audit: remote release/dev-974 absent; dev-974 peels to fd41adac777f7c7faea0cdd27acbe2817890abf8; clean checkout, tag, and candidate artifacts share tree d46c7e3057bafbeedc1ddb10d2619feb3c6eb2db. Four artifacts report vcs.revision=2fcc1093c7629ab94b460d083520ffd9c8064815 and vcs.modified=false. Listeners 18082/18083/18084/19093/19101 are open; health/readiness return 200; four Nodes are connected; eight provider snapshots are healthy with in_flight=0 and queued=0. + +command: git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (none) +stderr: (none) +``` + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING] Have you filled in every implementation-owned section?** +> If anything is blank, go back and fill it in before saving this file. +> Leave review-agent-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | Note | +|---|---|---| +| Header, Overview, Review Agent instructions | Fixed at stub creation | Implementer must not change finalization protocol. | +| Archive Evidence Snapshot | Fixed at stub creation | Read only the exact linked evidence when needed. | +| Implementation Item Completion | Implementing agent | Change only `[ ]` to `[x]`. | +| Implementation Checklist | Implementing agent | Change only `[ ]` to `[x]`. | +| Review-Only Checklist | Review agent only | Implementer must not modify it. | +| Deviations from Plan, Key Design Decisions | Implementing agent | Replace placeholders with actual content. | +| Reviewer Checkpoints | Fixed at stub creation | Reviewer checks these. | +| Verification Results | Implementing agent, then reviewer | Record actual output; reviewer reruns applicable checks. | +| Code Review Result | Review agent | Appended during official review. | + +## Code Review Result + +### Overall Verdict + +PASS + +### Dimension Assessment + +| Dimension | Result | Evidence | +|---|---|---| +| Correctness | Pass | The authorized replacement qualification has five terminal slots and `artifact_blocked=0`; product failures and timeout remain independent measured outcomes. | +| Completeness | Pass | REVIEW_API-4 through REVIEW_API-7 are complete, including frozen runtime identity, bounded renderer admission, exactly one replacement run, exact status, and both immutable audits. | +| Test coverage | Pass | The reviewer reran the real Chromium/CDP two-viewport integration test and inspected all five `attempt.json` and `web-validation.json` records. | +| API contract | Pass | The public benchmark CLI produced the required closed status without resume/retry or an alternate caller/provider path. | +| Code quality | Pass | This packet changed only task evidence; `git diff --check` passes and no product or harness source change was introduced. | +| Implementation deviation | Pass | HTTPS status probing and commit-vs-tree identity handling preserve the planned read-only boundary and are justified by the deployed environment. | +| Verification trust | Pass | Fresh reviewer status, renderer, run-file, release/runtime, and digest audits reproduce the implementation evidence. | +| Spec conformance | Pass | SDD D13/S02 is satisfied: fresh `ready=5`, exactly five attempts, complete terminal axes, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, and no exhausted browser/CDP block. | + +### Findings + +None. + +### Routing Signals + +- `review_rework_count=2` +- `evidence_integrity_failure=false` + +### Next Step + +Archive the PASS pair, write `complete.log`, move the task artifacts to the monthly archive, and emit Milestone completion-event metadata without modifying the roadmap. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G09_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G09_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..bdb8825a --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G09_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,352 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - API + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST]** Filling in this file is the mandatory final implementation step. Execute the plan's selected fixes and write boundary exactly. Do not choose a different protocol design, mutate old runs, ask the user, create stop files, archive task artifacts, or write `complete.log`. Final verdict/finalization is review-agent-only. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-13 +task=m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission, plan=0, tag=API + +status=blocked + +resume condition: An authorized release owner reconciles and removes the stale remote `release/dev-936` branch without moving or deleting tag `dev-936`; then refetch `origin/dev`, `origin/main`, and the exact feature tip, require no other release branch, merge the feature into clean `dev`, and start the newly computed `dev-` release. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Satisfied predecessor: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/13+12_scored_benchmark_result/complete.log`. +- Retained direct result: `agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight/run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa/`; preserve it byte-for-byte. +- Selected fixes are Gemini tool-call ID/tool-result normalization, safe rejection origin, bounded CDP recovery, terminal-evidence admission, clean dev deployment, and one new unscored diagnostic. + +## For the Review Agent + +Independently inspect every changed source file, rerun deterministic verification, validate source/deployment identity and the exact fresh direct run. Product failures/timeouts are outcomes, while incomplete evidence, pre-ingress incompatibility, or exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure blocking are Required findings. On PASS, append the verdict, archive this pair, write `complete.log` with first-line milestone metadata, move the task directory to the dated archive, and report the completion event. On WARN/FAIL follow the code-review skill; do not invent a worker investigation task. + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| API-1 Gemini tool identity | [x] | +| API-2 Safe rejection origin | [x] | +| API-3 Bounded CDP recovery | [x] | +| API-4 Admission contract | [x] | +| API-5 Publish and deploy | [ ] BLOCKED after feature publish, before dev merge | +| API-6 Direct diagnostic | [ ] NOT RUN because API-5 release prerequisite is blocked | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] [API-1] Preserve and validate Gemini function-call IDs through request and streaming response conversion, remove the non-standard tool-result field, and add same-name/out-of-order/duplicate/missing-ID regression tests. +- [x] [API-2] Add classification-only Gemini and Anthropic Chat rejection observations with tests proving no request, response, credential, route, prompt, or provider-message content is logged. +- [x] [API-3] Add at most three total fresh Chromium/CDP attempts for closed transient infrastructure errors, with per-attempt cleanup and tests for retry, exhaustion, non-transient no-retry, screenshot cleanup, and process reaping. +- [x] [API-4] Update benchmark skill/spec/SDD/Milestone/dev guide so direct qualification gates on readiness and terminal evidence rather than all-success, while exhausted infrastructure blocks and scored-run uniqueness remain fail-closed. +- [ ] [API-5] Run fresh local tests, commit/push the feature branch, merge its exact tip into clean `dev`, execute the full dev-runtime release/deploy procedure, and prove all Edge/Node binaries and health observations use the same released source. +- [ ] [API-6] Through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`, run one fresh direct preflight and one fresh unscored direct run; accept product failures/timeouts as results but require five terminal slots, `unresolved=0`, and no infrastructure-only browser/CDP block. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify this section. + +- [x] Append one verdict and verified `review_rework_count` / `evidence_integrity_failure` signals. +- [x] Verify dimensions and Required/Suggested/Nit classifications. +- [x] Rerun applicable tests and inspect exact live evidence; repair reviewer-reconstructable evidence gaps. +- [x] For every Required/Suggested finding record evidence, exact root cause, selected fix, files/symbols/tests, and acceptance commands before a follow-up plan. +- [x] Archive plan/review to correctly numbered `.log` files. +- [x] Verify the Agent-Ops `.gitignore` managed block. +- [ ] On PASS write `complete.log`, preserve milestone metadata, move the active directory to the dated archive, and leave no active `.md` files. +- [x] On WARN/FAIL write the exact next filesystem state and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +API-5 stopped at the mandated release precheck. A fresh fetch confirmed remote `release/dev-936` still exists at `fb23f3e83759373caffbb2ab6d2076218b402311` while completed tag `dev-936` exists and peels to `bc5b326140c809d6d3685ca35d7311e31a180d7c`. Neither ref is an ancestor of the other. Current `origin/dev` is `841511472a62ec20d79eac5f800180d1de34b541` with commit count 962, so the next release candidate would be `dev-962`, not a resumable `dev-936`. The plan and `dev-runtime-deploy` skill classify this other existing release branch as a hard blocker and prohibit automatic deletion/reset. Therefore exact feature tip `28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2` was published, but it was not merged into `dev`; no release branch, tag, binary, process, or runtime state was changed. API-6 was not invoked because the plan prohibits accepting a diagnostic against an unreleased/stale runtime. + +## Key Design Decisions + +- Gemini explicit call IDs use a closed 128-character token grammar. Pending calls are indexed by ID and name; explicit responses exact-match ID and name in any order, while ID-less responses retain FIFO only for calls whose native request omitted the ID. Duplicate, invalid, mismatched, and missing-required IDs fail closed. Tool-result projection contains only `role`, `tool_call_id`, and `content`. +- Gemini streaming retains a stable provider `delta.tool_calls[].id`, rejects changes/duplicates, and includes it in the native `functionCall`; thought signatures remain on their existing path. +- Rejection observations contain exactly `surface`, `bridge`, `rejection_class`, and `http_status`. Gemini uses closed `pre_ingress`/`provider_http`; Anthropic Chat bridge uses `provider_http`. Tests assert exact field count and secret-marker absence. +- `BrowserRenderer.render` performs input/binary/collision preflight once, then delegates to one-attempt rendering. Only the closed start/handshake/socket-loss set retries, for three total fresh profiles/processes. Existing one-attempt cleanup reaps the process group and removes screenshots; the wrapper defensively removes partial screenshots before retry. +- Direct qualification now admits complete terminal measurement rather than all-success: fresh `ready=5`, exactly five fresh attempts, zero unresolved/running/interrupted, terminal evidence for all axes, and no exhausted browser/CDP block. Product failure/provider rejection/timeout remain results; Edge pre-ingress incompatibility and exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure remain blockers. D06/D10 scored-run uniqueness is unchanged. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Explicit Gemini IDs survive response→history→tool-result conversion; ID-less inputs retain deterministic fallback. +- No raw request/provider error material is logged or copied into task evidence. +- CDP retry is exactly a three-attempt maximum for the closed transient set and reaps every failed process. +- Policy sources agree that terminal failure is a result, not an incomplete run. +- Feature, dev merge, release tag/tree, four binaries, and live processes share the recorded source. +- Fresh direct run has exactly five terminal slots and no infrastructure-only artifact block; old runs are unchanged. + +## Verification Results + +### API-1 / API-2 Edge bridge tests + +```text +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini|Anthropic.*Bridge|Rejection' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 0.109s +stderr: (none) + +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 8.653s +stderr: (none) +``` + +### API-3 Browser tests + +```text +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test scripts.agent_benchmark.web_validation_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 25 tests in 42.934s / OK +stderr: (none) +``` + +### API-4 Contract tests + +```text +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 54 tests in 2.149s / OK +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Skill is valid! +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy +exit_code: 1 +stderr: Unexpected key(s) in SKILL.md frontmatter: version. Allowed properties are: allowed-tools, description, license, metadata, name + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) +``` + +### API-5 Publication and deployment + +```text +feature commit: 28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2 +feature push: origin/feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison = 28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2 +commit command exit_code: 0 +push command exit_code: 0 + +remote release precheck after fetch: +- origin/dev = 841511472a62ec20d79eac5f800180d1de34b541 +- origin/dev commit count = 962 (next candidate version after merge must be recomputed; current baseline is dev-962) +- origin/main = bc5b326140c809d6d3685ca35d7311e31a180d7c +- origin/feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison = 28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2 +- origin/main ancestor of origin/dev: yes +- origin/dev and feature tip ancestry: diverged; merge base = 8f00606c0339e1e9ace5f7c8d019582ba6843513 +- existing remote release branch: release/dev-936 = fb23f3e83759373caffbb2ab6d2076218b402311 +- existing tag: dev-936; peeled commit = bc5b326140c809d6d3685ca35d7311e31a180d7c +- release/dev-936 and peeled tag ancestry: neither is an ancestor of the other + +blocker: existing release/dev-936 is a plan/skill hard stop. No dev merge, release start/resume, build, deployment, process restart, capacity smoke, release finish, or tag/ref mutation was performed. +resume condition: authorized release ownership reconciles and removes only remote release/dev-936 without moving/deleting dev-936; a subsequent fetch sees no release branch, preserves the recorded tag, and passes clean dev/main/feature prechecks before merge and a newly computed release. +``` + +### API-6 Direct diagnostic + +```text +fresh direct preflight command count: 0 +fresh direct run command count: 0 +reason: API-5 did not deploy the candidate; running against stale runtime is prohibited. + +retained old run audit before any new diagnostic: +- path: agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight/run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa/ +- regular files: 5489 +- aggregate sorted file SHA-256 stream digest: d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd +- mutation/resume/retry: none + +safe rejection origin live observation: not available because candidate deployment did not occur. Unit tests cover classification-only fields; no provider body was copied into tracked evidence. +``` + +### Final verification + +```text +command: python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 458 tests in 154.741s / OK +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) + +command: git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (none) +stderr: (none) + +final local source status: feature HEAD and origin feature both 28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2; only the active task pair remains untracked for official review/finalization. +``` + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING]** Fill every implementation-owned section and check every implemented row/item. Leave review-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | +|---|---| +| Header, Overview, Archive Snapshot, item names, checkpoints | Fixed at stub creation | +| Implementation checklist statuses, deviations, decisions, initial verification | Implementing agent | +| Review-only checklist, verdict, archive/finalization | Official review agent | + +## Reviewer Fresh Verification + +```text +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini|Anthropic.*Bridge|Rejection' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 0.084s +stderr: (none) + +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 8.641s +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test scripts.agent_benchmark.web_validation_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 25 tests in 43.688s / OK +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 54 tests in 3.304s / OK +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 458 tests in 160.614s / OK +stderr: (none) + +command: while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package" || exit; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +first_exit_code: 1 +first_failure: apps/node/internal/workspace TestCommandExecutorCancelKillsProcessGroup read an empty child PID file; three immediate focused reruns passed. +second_exit_code: 0 +second_stdout: every listed package passed sequentially, including apps/node/internal/workspace and apps/edge/internal/openai. + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Skill is valid! +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) + +command: git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (none) +stderr: (none) + +retained run audit: +- regular files: 5489 +- aggregate sorted file SHA-256 stream digest: d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd +- result: unchanged from implementation evidence +``` + +Focused reviewer reproducers were added temporarily, run, and removed before finalization: + +```text +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'ReviewReproducerGemini(InternalDispatchErrorIsProviderHTTP|AuthRejectionIsUnobserved)' -v +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +=== RUN TestReviewReproducerGeminiInternalDispatchErrorIsProviderHTTP +--- PASS: TestReviewReproducerGeminiInternalDispatchErrorIsProviderHTTP (0.00s) +=== RUN TestReviewReproducerGeminiAuthRejectionIsUnobserved +--- PASS: TestReviewReproducerGeminiAuthRejectionIsUnobserved (0.00s) +PASS +ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 0.058s +stderr: (none) +meaning: the first reproducer proves an Edge-local SubmitRun failure is mislabeled provider_http; the second proves a Gemini authentication rejection emits no pre_ingress observation. +``` + +External read-only preflight: + +```text +runner: toki@toki-labs.com:/Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev +host: Darwin arm64 +checkout: branch=dev, HEAD=fd32abb4b6b15037c24be01821b430a960afd967, dirty=no, behind origin/dev by 3 +origin/dev: 841511472a62ec20d79eac5f800180d1de34b541 +origin/main: bc5b326140c809d6d3685ca35d7311e31a180d7c +feature: 28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2 +authoritative git ls-remote release branches: none +stale runner remote-tracking refs: origin/release/dev-781, origin/release/dev-936 +tag dev-936 peeled commit: bc5b326140c809d6d3685ca35d7311e31a180d7c +git-flow: 1.12.3 AVH; master=main; develop=dev; release prefix=release/ +Go: /opt/homebrew/bin/go, go1.26.3 darwin/arm64 +artifacts: all four declared dev-runtime binaries present +config: build/dev-runtime/edge.yaml present +runtime: Edge PID 81496 listens on 18082, 18083, 18084, and 19093 +setup conclusion: the original remote release branch is gone; git fetch --prune must remove stale tracking refs before a clean dev sync and new release. +``` + +The exact API-5 command in the active plan and `dev-runtime-deploy` skill is not runnable in this checkout: + +```text +command: while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package" || exit; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./cmd/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +exit_code: 1 +stderr: pattern ./cmd/...: lstat ./cmd/: no such file or directory +``` + +## Code Review Result + +### Overall Verdict + +FAIL + +### Dimension Assessment + +| Dimension | Result | Evidence | +|---|---|---| +| Correctness | Fail | Gemini rejection origin is derived from the final internal bridge status, so an Edge-local dispatch failure is reported as `provider_http`; auth rejection is unobserved. | +| Completeness | Fail | API-5 deployment and API-6 fresh direct qualification were not executed. | +| Test coverage | Fail | Existing observation tests omit auth pre-ingress and Edge-local error provenance negatives. | +| API contract | Fail | The closed `pre_ingress` versus `provider_http` operational contract does not reflect the real error owner. | +| Code quality | Pass | The reviewed tool-ID and bounded-CDP implementations contain no debug residue, dead code, or unrelated source changes. | +| Implementation deviation | Fail | The required dev merge/release/deploy/direct-run sequence stopped before its acceptance evidence, and its recorded release blocker is no longer an authoritative remote branch. | +| Verification trust | Pass | Fresh focused and broad checks reproduce the implementation's passing claims; the implementation accurately recorded that API-5/API-6 were not run. | +| Spec conformance | Fail | SDD S02/S13 cannot close without a correctly classified live boundary and fresh five-slot direct evidence. | + +### Findings + +- **Required R1 — Gemini rejection observations do not identify the actual rejection owner.** + - **Evidence:** The focused reviewer command above passes while asserting both bad states. At `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go:87-90`, every status `>=400` produced by the internal Chat handler is labeled `provider_http`; a normalized `SubmitRun` failure therefore becomes a false provider rejection. At `apps/edge/internal/openai/routes.go:35-45,58-72`, authentication and managed caller-credential rejection return before the Gemini handler and call `writeGeminiError` directly, so those pre-ingress failures emit no observation. `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go:321-357` covers malformed body plus a real provider 400 but neither negative provenance variant. + - **Root Cause:** `geminiBridgeResponseWriter.Status()` carries only the final caller-facing status and has no actual provider `RESPONSE_START` provenance. The handler infers ownership from that lossy value, while the shared auth wrapper bypasses `writeGeminiPreIngressError`. + - **Selected Fix:** In `apps/edge/internal/openai/routes.go`, route Gemini authentication and managed caller-provider-credential failures through `Server.writeGeminiPreIngressError`. In `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go`, remove blanket post-handler status classification and construct the bridge with a bounded provider-rejection callback. In `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_bridge.go`, implement a private, once-only provider-status observer that emits only for actual status `>=400`. In `apps/edge/internal/openai/stream_gate_release_sink.go`, notify that observer only at raw provider-tunnel response-start/error-response status write points, never for normalized/internal terminal errors. Extend `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go` to prove auth and managed pre-ingress classification, actual tunnel 400 classification, Edge-local `SubmitRun` failure non-classification as provider HTTP, exact four-field logging, and secret absence. + - **Disposition:** `direct-fix`. + - **Acceptance Commands:** `go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini.*Rejection|GeminiIngressRejectsAuthentication'`; `go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai`. + +- **Required R2 — Required release/deployment and fresh direct qualification are incomplete, and the release procedure contains a deterministic command defect.** + - **Evidence:** API-5 and API-6 remain unchecked with direct command counts `0`. Fresh `git ls-remote --heads` reports no remote release branch, while the runner still holds stale `refs/remotes/origin/release/dev-781` and `dev-936`; the original external blocker has therefore changed into a normal prune/sync prerequisite. Separately, the exact skill/plan Go-test command fails before running tests because this repository has no `./cmd/` directory. No released source identity, four-binary identity, connected-node/capacity smoke, or fresh five-slot terminal evidence exists. + - **Root Cause:** The implementation treated a stale remote-tracking ref as an authoritative remote release branch. `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md` fetches without an explicit prune/authoritative `ls-remote` check and lists the nonexistent `./cmd/...` package root, so the mandated procedure cannot reliably advance even after the remote branch disappears. + - **Selected Fix:** Update `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md` to remove the unsupported `version` frontmatter key, prune remote refs, distinguish authoritative remote release heads from stale local tracking refs, and remove `./cmd/...` from both sequential test contracts. Add deterministic assertions to `scripts/agent_benchmark/skill_contract_test.py` for valid project-skill frontmatter and the prune/authoritative-ref/package-list wording, then run skill validation. Then commit/push the corrected feature tip, clean-sync the authorized runner, merge that exact tip into `dev`, execute the complete release procedure with four rebuilt binaries, health/identity/4-node/capacity evidence and atomic finish, and only then invoke one fresh direct preflight and run through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`. Preserve the retained run byte-for-byte and accept terminal product failures without retry, while requiring five terminal slots, zero unresolved/running/interrupted, and no exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block. + - **Disposition:** `direct-fix`. + - **Acceptance Commands:** `python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test`; `python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy`; the corrected sequential Go command without `./cmd/...`; every build/deploy/capacity check in `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md`; `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json`; `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json`. + +### Routing Signals + +- `review_rework_count=1` +- `evidence_integrity_failure=false` + +### Next Step + +Run the plan skill in `prepare-follow-up` mode with R1 and R2 as closed `direct-fix` findings, archive this pair, and materialize the routed `REVIEW_API` follow-up pair. No user-review gate applies because the declared SSH runner is authorized and the authoritative remote release branch is already absent. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f738e073 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log @@ -0,0 +1,453 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - REVIEW_API + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST] Filling in this file is the mandatory final step of implementation.** +> The task is NOT complete until every implementation-owned section below is filled in. +> Complete the `Implementation Checklist`; the final checklist item is mandatory before saving. +> Fill implementation-owned sections, then stop with active files in place and report ready for review. +> Execute the plan's selected root cause, scope, files, and dependency decisions as written. Do not choose another owner, narrow/expand the write boundary, or replace a fix with another verification attempt. +> If implementation is blocked, record the exact blocker, attempted commands/output, and resume condition only in implementation-owned evidence fields. +> Do not ask the user directly, present choices, call user-input tools, create control-plane stop files, or classify the next state. +> Finalization (`Code Review Result`, log rename, `complete.log`, archive moves, `Review-Only Checklist`) is review-agent-only, even after compaction/resume. +> Follow the ownership table at the bottom of this file for which sections you own. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-13 +task=m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission, plan=1, tag=REVIEW_API + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G09_0.log` and `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log` preserve the first loop. Verdict: `FAIL`; Required R1/R2; Suggested/Nit: none. +- R1 evidence: an Edge-local normalized `SubmitRun` failure is logged as `provider_http`; Gemini auth rejection emits no `pre_ingress` observation. Direct-fix targets are the Gemini/auth bridge, tunnel release provenance hook, and regression tests. +- R2 evidence: API-5/API-6 were not run. Authoritative origin has no release branch, while the runner has stale remote-tracking release refs. The deploy skill contains unsupported `version` frontmatter and its sequential Go command fails on nonexistent `./cmd/...`. +- Published feature evidence starts at `28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2`; the implementing agent must publish a new corrected exact tip before merging it into `dev`. +- The retained run `agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight/run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa/` remains immutable: 5,489 files and aggregate digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. + +## For the Review Agent + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** The finalization steps below are review-agent only. Implementing agents must not execute this section. + +Compare implementation of each item against source files. Run the applicable verification commands directly and record fresh output in `Verification Results`; implementation-owned output is handoff evidence, not a substitute for reviewer verification. If implementation is present, repair missing or stale verification output instead of failing solely for insufficient recorded evidence. When verification exposes a defect, collect the necessary data, determine the exact root cause, and select one concrete fix before generating the follow-up plan; never delegate investigation or remedy selection to the worker. +Review completion means the following steps are finished: + +1. Append verdict and `review_rework_count` / `evidence_integrity_failure` routing signals. +2. Archive `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` → `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log` and `PLAN-cloud-G10.md` → `plan_cloud_G10_1.log`. +3. If PASS, write `complete.log` and move active task directory to `agent-task/archive/YYYY/MM/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/`. If WARN/FAIL, fully write the next filesystem state required by the code-review skill. +4. If PASS, preserve `milestone-task=agy-iop-compatibility,route-readiness,objective-validation` in `complete.log` and report it for runtime aggregation. Roadmap state evaluation belongs to `sync-milestone-workstate`. +5. Check applicable `Review-Only Checklist` items at the final `.log` location before reporting. + +--- + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|------|---------| +| REVIEW_API-1 Rejection provenance | [x] | +| REVIEW_API-2 Deploy contract and release | [x] | +| REVIEW_API-3 Fresh terminal qualification | [ ] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] [REVIEW_API-1] Correct Gemini pre-ingress/provider-HTTP provenance and add regression tests for auth, managed credential rejection, actual tunnel error, Edge-local failure, exact fields, and secret absence. +- [x] [REVIEW_API-2] Repair and validate the dev-runtime deployment skill, publish the corrected feature tip, merge that exact tip into clean `dev`, and complete the full release/deploy/identity/connectivity/capacity procedure. +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-3] Through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`, run one fresh direct preflight and one fresh unscored five-cell run, record terminal-evidence admission, and prove the retained run is unchanged. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** This checklist is used only by the review agent. +> Implementing agents must not modify or check this section. + +- [x] Append one verdict of `PASS`, `WARN`, or `FAIL` and verified `review_rework_count`, `evidence_integrity_failure` to `Code Review Result`. +- [x] Verify that verdict, `Dimension Assessment`, and Required/Suggested/Nit classifications match. +- [x] Run applicable required verification and record fresh command/output; repair reviewer-reconstructable evidence gaps instead of forwarding them to another plan. +- [x] For every Required/Suggested finding, record reviewer-collected `Evidence`, exact `Root Cause`, and one `Selected Fix` with affected files/symbols/tests and acceptance commands before creating a follow-up plan. +- [x] Archive active `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md` to `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log`. +- [x] Archive active `PLAN-*-G??.md` to `plan_cloud_G10_1.log`. +- [x] Verify that the Agent-Ops managed block in `.gitignore` unignores `agent-task/**/*.md` and `agent-task/**/*.log` and ignores `agent-roadmap/current.md`. +- [ ] If PASS, write `complete.log` based on `agent-ops/skills/common/code-review/templates/complete-log-template.md` and leave no active `.md` files. +- [ ] If PASS, move active task directory to `agent-task/archive/YYYY/MM/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/` and update this checklist at the final archive path. +- [ ] If PASS, preserve and report `milestone-task` metadata for runtime aggregation, without modifying roadmap or directly calling `update-roadmap`. +- [ ] If PASS for split work, remove empty active parent or verify it was kept due to remaining siblings/files. +- [x] If WARN/FAIL, write the next filesystem state matching code-review verdict and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +- `git fetch --prune origin dev main --tags`만으로 stale explicit release tracking ref가 지워지지 않는 것을 runner preflight에서 확인했다. 따라서 선택된 skill fix에 `git remote prune origin`을 추가하고 contract test를 보강한 뒤 새 exact feature tip을 다시 게시했다. 이 절차로 `origin/release/dev-781`, `origin/release/dev-936`을 cleanup evidence로 제거했고 authoritative `git ls-remote --heads`는 release head 0개였다. +- local `/tmp`가 noexec라서 빌드된 `/tmp/iop-inventory-query` 실행은 `permission denied`였다. 같은 source의 `go run ./scripts/inventory-query --env dev`로 inventory validation을 수행했다. Go test/build 결과에는 영향이 없었다. +- runner에서 첫 capacity 요청은 dev CA가 curl trust store에 없어서 요청 admission 전에 curl 60으로 종료됐다. 이후 runtime CA를 `SSL_CERT_FILE`로 명시했다. Ornith aggregate 시도는 5/5 HTTP 성공, queue 2, healthy/0/0 복구였지만 RTX provider가 선택되지 않아 peak 3/4였으므로 acceptance evidence로 사용하지 않았다. 문서 기준의 단일 Laguna pool로 두 endpoint를 다시 측정해 각각 peak 4/4, queue 1, failures 0, healthy/0/0을 충족했다. +- mac runner의 기존 active binary path가 backup보다 먼저 새 artifact로 교체된 상태여서 원본 byte-for-byte rollback 파일을 보존하지 못했다. 이전 source `cb18d7bba4f39b159466adfd76b738e6cd655ef5` worktree에서 rollback용 edge/node를 별도 생성해 SHA-256을 남겼지만 sibling `go.work` 빌드 제약 때문에 해당 두 artifact의 `go version -m` VCS revision은 비어 있다. rollback은 필요하지 않았고 candidate identity/health/capacity는 모두 검증됐다. +- REVIEW_API-3의 계획된 direct preflight 1회와 run 1회는 실행했고 5개 slot 모두 terminal evidence를 남겼다. 그러나 `codex-gpt-direct` web-validation이 `blocked/cdp_socket_closed`였다. `BrowserRenderer.render`가 이 transient class를 fresh profile로 최대 3회 시도한 후 마지막 오류를 재전파하므로 이는 exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block이다. 계획의 재시도 금지에 따라 resume/retry/새 run을 실행하지 않았으며 REVIEW_API-3 admission과 체크박스는 미완료로 남겼다. 재개 조건은 별도 승인된 후속 qualification에서 CDP socket 안정성을 먼저 복구하고 새로운 fresh preflight/run을 할 수 있는 상태다. + +## Key Design Decisions + +- Gemini auth 및 managed caller-credential 거절은 기존 Gemini pre-ingress writer를 통해 관측한다. endpoint error body는 바꾸지 않았다. +- `provider_http`는 최종 내부 Chat status로 추론하지 않는다. Gemini bridge의 private once-only observer를 raw provider tunnel sink의 실제 provider status commit 지점에만 연결했고, normalized/admission/internal terminal writer에는 연결하지 않았다. +- rejection observation은 `level`, `event`, `origin`, `status` 네 필드만 유지한다. 테스트는 fixture secret과 request/provider body, route, prompt, model, error message가 포함되지 않음을 확인한다. +- 배포 source는 feature tip `884273310301888aa9f200270066956603f8d439`을 두 번째 parent로 포함하는 release commit `003398a149c1433cb21bc8aa2720bde272b87373`으로 고정했다. 네 artifact와 실행 중 node 복사본은 이 release source 및 recorded SHA-256으로 검증했다. +- capacity qualification은 model-group 선택이 명확하고 단일 provider capacity가 4인 `laguna-s:2.1`/`gx10-vllm`을 사용했다. endpoint별 5개 요청으로 saturation, queue, 회복을 독립 관측한 뒤에만 release finish를 실행했다. +- direct result의 product failure, timeout, generated-missing, accessibility failure는 측정 결과로 그대로 보존했다. CDP exhaustion만 admission blocker로 분리했고 old/fresh run 어느 쪽도 재시도하거나 수정하지 않았다. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Gemini authentication and managed credential rejection emit only `pre_ingress`; an actual provider-tunnel 4xx emits exactly one `provider_http`; normalized/internal failures never do. +- Rejection observations retain exactly four closed safe fields and contain no request/provider body, credential, route, prompt, model, or error-message data. +- Deploy skill frontmatter validates; initial prune plus authoritative release-head check cannot mistake a stale tracking ref for a remote branch; sequential package roots all exist. +- Feature tip, dev merge, release head/tag tree, four binary module identities, and live processes all name the exact released source. +- Four nodes are connected and both OpenAI-compatible capacity+1 smokes show saturation, queueing, and return to zero before release finish. +- Exactly one fresh five-cell direct preflight/run is invoked through the CLI wrapper; all five slots are terminal, no CDP/browser infrastructure exhaustion remains, and product failures are preserved without retry. +- The retained run remains exactly 5,489 files with digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. + +## Verification Results + +Record actual stdout/stderr and exit codes. If output is long, save it outside the repository and record the exact path and command. Do not print secrets. + +### REVIEW_API-1 + +```text +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini.*Rejection|GeminiIngressRejectsAuthentication' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 0.045s +stderr: (none) + +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 8.603s +stderr: (none) +``` + +### REVIEW_API-2 + +```text +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 55 tests in 2.103s / OK +stderr: (55 progress dots only) + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Skill is valid! +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Skill is valid! +stderr: (none) + +command: while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package" || exit; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +exit_code: 0 +stdout: 49 packages passed sequentially; final package `ok iop/scripts/inventory-query 0.053s`; full output `/tmp/iop-g10-final-go-sequential.log` +stderr: (none) + +command: git ls-remote --heads origin 'refs/heads/release/*' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (empty before `release/dev-971` start; empty again after atomic finish) +stderr: (none) + +feature/dev/release refs and tree: +- published exact feature tip: `884273310301888aa9f200270066956603f8d439` (local and origin equal) +- clean dev feature merge/release source: `003398a149c1433cb21bc8aa2720bde272b87373`; parents `9449aa4ac48fe6672fb743b421a7e5bcb7311760` and exact feature tip `8842733...` +- release tree: `6c3095e497efb44d2da51f48471b0b5cf4f06c9e`; version from post-merge dev count: `dev-971` +- finish refs: origin main `0c1e9e6a3f181eaebe59f888043fadc37385741d`, origin dev `eaf8fbaf2199333dd30082cfd0f0b41cbb801e5b`, peeled tag `dev-971=0c1e9e6...`, tag tree `6c3095e...`; release heads 0 + +pre-build tests: +- correctly quoted runner sequential command: 49 packages passed, `PRE_BUILD_TESTS=PASS` +- post-build repeat: the same 49 packages passed +- Windows release-built credentiallease test executable passed on OneXPlayer; Windows ownership tests passed and Unix-only test skipped as expected + +four artifact paths/SHA-256/go-version-m source: +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/edge`: `e46573e95452d46dba5f20f17583aa15f5a461b6ec269501c2a5129c8a10a9c4` +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node`: `5b07284870975d20b06c76ec739c34451777610be4cece1f9e7bf3809126fe5c` +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-linux-arm64`: `1eae087c99e47fc04cd5cf7b125432e5ae345ab3d43c8ba553291a46502bcfe9` +- `build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-windows-amd64.exe`: `dbc39c94fff2f646e03bfc076ba84e0bc3f8a52d9a168acb43f74232fdc41153` +- all four: `vcs.revision=003398a149c1433cb21bc8aa2720bde272b87373`, `vcs.modified=false` + +config/refresh checks: +- candidate `config check`: pass +- `config refresh --help`: subcommand/options present +- `config refresh --mode dry-run`: `status=applied`, no changed or restart-required paths +- authenticated `/v1/models`: HTTP 200, 9 models, required `laguna-s:2.1` and `ornith:35b` present + +process/listener/runtime identity: +- runner Edge PID 94139; mac node PID 94279; Edge listeners `*:18082,*:18083,*:18084,127.0.0.1:19093` +- GX10 PID 791049, command `./iop-node --config ./node.yaml serve`, Linux artifact hash exact, established 18084 connection 1 +- OneXPlayer PID 35640, `Win32_Process.Create`-owned release command, Windows artifact hash exact, established 18084 connection 1 +- RTX5090 PID 31332, `Win32_Process.Create`-owned release command, Windows artifact hash exact, established 18084 connection 1; no Startup/Run/Task/Service owner was created + +four connected nodes/provider snapshots: +- `mac-codex-node=true`: `mac-gemini-api 1/0/0 healthy`, `mac-mlx-vllm 2/0/0 healthy`, `glm-coding 1/0/0 healthy`, `anthropic-api 1/0/0 healthy`, `openai-api 1/0/0 healthy` +- `gx10-vllm-node=true`: `gx10-vllm 4/0/0 healthy` +- `onexplayer-lemonade-node=true`: `onexplayer-lemonade 3/0/0 healthy` +- `rtx5090-lemonade-node=true`: `rtx5090-lemonade 1/0/0 healthy` + +responses capacity+1 evidence: +- `laguna-s:2.1`, requests 5, expected capacity 4, `max_in_flight=4`, `max_queued=1`, `max_by_provider={gx10-vllm:4}`, failures 0, final `gx10-vllm 0/0 healthy` + +chat-completions capacity+1 evidence: +- `laguna-s:2.1`, requests 5, expected capacity 4, `max_in_flight=4`, `max_queued=1`, `max_by_provider={gx10-vllm:4}`, failures 0, final `gx10-vllm 0/0 healthy` + +release finish/tag/atomic push/cleanup: +- finish preflight preserved origin dev `003398a...`, origin main `bc5b326140c809d6d3685ca35d7311e31a180d7c`, release HEAD `003398a...`, no `dev-971` tag +- `git flow release finish --keepremote -m "Release dev-971" dev-971` succeeded; local tag tree equaled deployed tree +- one atomic push updated main/dev/tag and deleted `release/dev-971`; runner fetch/prune, clean `dev` sync, and local release cleanup succeeded +``` + +### REVIEW_API-3 + +```text +Authorization/runtime state: `blocked` — the single permitted fresh run exhausted all 3 fresh CDP browser/profile attempts for `codex-gpt-direct`; the plan and benchmark skill prohibit an implicit retry. +Resume condition: An explicitly authorized follow-up qualification may start after CDP socket stability is restored and can execute one new fresh preflight/run without resuming, retrying, or modifying either retained run. + +command: /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: preflight run_id=run-20260813T020750Z-69a263acc2c2 status=ready ready=5 registration_required=0 implementation_gap=0 +stderr: (none) + +command: /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: run run_id=run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e executed=5 unresolved=0 completed=3 timed_out=2 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=1 product_failed=2 product_unknown=2 harness_passed=3 harness_failed=2 process_exited=3 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=2 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=0 artifact_failed=4 artifact_blocked=1 artifact_not_run=0 +stderr: (none) + +preflight command count and fresh observation id: +- direct preflight command count: 1 +- fresh observation run id: `run-20260813T020750Z-69a263acc2c2`; `ready=5` + +run command count, run id, attempt ids: +- direct run command count: 1; resume/retry count: 0 +- run id: `run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e` +- exactly five `attempt-000001`: `agy-gemini-direct`, `claude-gemini-direct`, `claude-gpt-direct`, `claude-sonnet-direct`, `codex-gpt-direct` (all repetition 0001) + +five controller/product/harness/process/web-validation terminals: +- `agy-gemini-direct`: controller completed; product failed/caller_error; harness passed/success/ordered terminal/cleanup complete; process exited 1; web failed/generated_missing +- `claude-gemini-direct`: controller completed; product succeeded/caller_success; harness passed/success/ordered terminal/cleanup complete; process exited 0; web failed/accessibility_failed with Chrome observed, 2 screenshots and 2 viewports +- `claude-gpt-direct`: controller completed; product failed/caller_error; harness passed/success/ordered terminal/cleanup complete; process exited 1; web failed/generated_missing +- `claude-sonnet-direct`: controller timed_out; product unknown/unavailable; harness failed/timed_out/cleanup complete; process timed_out 143; web failed/generated_missing +- `codex-gpt-direct`: controller timed_out; product unknown/unavailable; harness failed/timed_out/cleanup complete; process timed_out signal 15; generated files regular; web blocked/cdp_socket_closed + +unresolved/running/interrupted summary: +- `executed=5`, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`; controller `completed=3`, `timed_out=2`; five `attempt.json` and five `web-validation.json` files present + +safe rejection origin and CDP/browser result: +- fresh AGY attempt is a caller error; candidate Edge stdout/stderr contained no closed four-field Gemini rejection observation for this attempt, so no live `origin` is inferred or claimed. Unit regression evidence proves auth/managed=`pre_ingress`, raw tunnel 4xx=`provider_http` once, normalized SubmitRun failure=no `provider_http`, and exactly four secret-free fields. +- Codex web validation has `status=blocked`, `reason=cdp_socket_closed`, browser not observed. The renderer's closed transient loop makes at most 3 fresh browser/profile attempts and rethrows the third `CDP socket closed`, so the required no-exhaustion admission gate failed. No retry/resume/new run was invoked. + +retained-run file count/digest after new run: +- path `agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight/run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa/` +- regular files 5,489; aggregate sorted full-path file SHA-256 stream digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`; unchanged +``` + +### Final Verification + +```text +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 8.603s +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 55 tests in 2.103s / OK +stderr: (55 progress dots only) + +command: python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 459 tests in 155.914s / OK +stderr: (459 progress dots only) + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Skill is valid! +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Skill is valid! +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) + +command: while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package" || exit; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +exit_code: 0 +stdout: 49 packages passed sequentially; full output `/tmp/iop-g10-final-go-sequential.log` +stderr: (none) + +command: git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (none; executed before writing this untracked implementation-evidence file) +stderr: (none) + +command: git status --short --branch +exit_code: 0 +stdout: `## feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison...origin/feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison` and `?? agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/`; source worktree has no tracked modifications, active plan/review evidence remains untracked as required for review handoff +stderr: (none) +``` + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING] Have you filled in every implementation-owned section?** +> If anything is blank, go back and fill it in before saving this file. +> Leave review-agent-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | Note | +|---------|-------|------| +| Header comment, Overview, Review Agent Instructions | Fixed at stub creation | Implementing agent must not modify or execute these (archive, complete.log, and task-directory archive move are review-agent only) | +| Archive Evidence Snapshot | Fixed at stub creation from plan when present | Implementing agent uses it as default prior-loop context; read only the specific archive files cited there when more detail is required | +| Implementation Item Completion (item names) | Fixed at stub creation | Implementing agent checks `[ ]` → `[x]` only | +| Implementation Checklist (item text/order) | Fixed at stub creation from plan | Implementing agent checks `[ ]` → `[x]` only | +| Review-Only Checklist | Review agent only | Implementing agent must not modify or check this section | +| Deviations from Plan, Key Design Decisions | Implementing agent | Replace placeholder text with actual content | +| Reviewer Checkpoints | Fixed at stub creation | Pre-filled from plan | +| Verification Results (section headings + commands) | Implementing agent, then review agent | Implementing agent records initial output; review agent reruns applicable commands and may fill, replace, or append fresh verified output before verdict. Implementing-agent command changes require a `Deviations from Plan` entry | +| Code Review Result | Review agent appends | Not included in stub | + +## Reviewer Fresh Verification + +### Deterministic source and contract checks + +```text +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini.*Rejection|GeminiIngressRejectsAuthentication' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 0.059s +stderr: (none) + +command: go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok iop/apps/edge/internal/openai 8.865s +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 55 tests in 3.017s / OK +stderr: (55 progress dots only) + +command: python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test scripts.agent_benchmark.web_validation_test +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 25 tests in 42.993s / OK +stderr: (25 progress dots only) + +command: python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Ran 459 tests in 167.011s / OK +stderr: (459 progress dots only) + +command: python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy && python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark +exit_code: 0 +stdout: Skill is valid! / Skill is valid! +stderr: (none) + +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json && python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: manifest is valid / ok: manifest is valid +stderr: (none) + +command: while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package" || exit; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +exit_code: 0 +stdout: 49 packages passed sequentially; final package `ok iop/scripts/inventory-query 0.012s` +stderr: (none) + +command: git diff --check 28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2..884273310301888aa9f200270066956603f8d439 +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (none) +stderr: (none) +``` + +### Release identity and immutable evidence audit + +```text +command: git ls-remote --heads origin 'refs/heads/release/*' +exit_code: 0 +stdout: (empty at review time before a later independent release was started) +stderr: (none) + +command: git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main refs/heads/dev refs/heads/feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison refs/tags/dev-971 refs/tags/dev-971^{} +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +- origin feature = 884273310301888aa9f200270066956603f8d439 +- origin main = 0c1e9e6a3f181eaebe59f888043fadc37385741d +- peeled dev-971 tag = 0c1e9e6a3f181eaebe59f888043fadc37385741d +- origin dev at the first reviewer query = eaf8fbaf2199333dd30082cfd0f0b41cbb801e5b +stderr: (none) + +command: local ancestry/tree audit for feature 8842733, release source 003398a, main 0c1e9e6, dev eaf8fba, and tag dev-971 +exit_code: 0 +stdout: +- feature 8842733 is an ancestor of release source 003398a +- release source 003398a is an ancestor of both released main and dev +- release source, released main, released dev, and peeled tag share tree 6c3095e497efb44d2da51f48471b0b5cf4f06c9e +stderr: (none) + +command: retained run regular-file count and sorted full-path SHA-256 stream digest +exit_code: 0 +stdout: files=5489 / digest=d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd +stderr: (none) + +note: A later independent deployment had moved the declared runner to clean `release/dev-974` by the final read-only runner audit. Therefore the reviewer did not reinterpret the current live binaries as dev-971 evidence; the immutable dev-971 refs/tree and the implementation-time redacted deployment evidence remain the applicable historical release proof. +``` + +### Fresh direct qualification admission audit + +```text +command: python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e +exit_code: 0 +stdout: ok: status run_id=run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e unresolved=0 completed=3 timed_out=2 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=1 product_failed=2 product_unknown=2 harness_passed=3 harness_failed=2 process_exited=3 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=2 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=0 artifact_failed=4 artifact_blocked=1 artifact_not_run=0 +stderr: (none) + +artifact: agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight/run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e/cells/codex-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json +verified fields: status=blocked, reason=cdp_socket_closed, browser.status=not_observed, screenshots=0, viewports=0 + +command: BrowserRenderer.render against the immutable codex-gpt-direct workspace with a separate /tmp output root and the manifest desktop/mobile viewport sizes +exit_code: 0 +stdout: render=pass / browser=Chrome/151.0.7922.34 / requests=12 / viewports=2 +stderr: (none) + +interpretation: Current source and browser can render the same generated workspace, so no deterministic repository defect was reproduced. The immutable qualification run nevertheless exhausted its three permitted fresh Chromium/CDP attempts and remains an infrastructure-blocked admission failure. The plan and benchmark contract prohibit silently retrying or replacing that run. +``` + +## Code Review Result + +### Overall Verdict + +FAIL + +### Dimension Assessment + +| Dimension | Result | Evidence | +|---|---|---| +| Correctness | Pass | The Gemini rejection owner is now attached only to actual provider HTTP commit points; auth and managed caller-credential failures are `pre_ingress`, and normalized Edge-local failure is negative-covered. | +| Completeness | Fail | `REVIEW_API-3` and its implementation checklist remain incomplete because the only permitted fresh qualification contains one exhausted CDP infrastructure block. | +| Test coverage | Pass | Focused Edge tests, the complete OpenAI package, browser/web-validation tests, 459 benchmark tests, and the corrected 49-package sequential suite pass freshly. | +| API contract | Pass | Rejection observations retain the closed four-field safe projection, release refs/tree preserve one exact source identity, and no public error body contract changed. | +| Code quality | Pass | The reviewed changes are bounded to the selected provenance and deployment-contract seams and contain no debug residue or unrelated source mutation. | +| Implementation deviation | Pass | The implementation correctly did not resume or retry the blocked qualification and accurately left `REVIEW_API-3` unchecked. | +| Verification trust | Pass | Fresh deterministic checks reproduce the passing claims, ref/tree evidence corroborates dev-971, and the implementation accurately reports the CDP exhaustion instead of claiming admission. | +| Spec conformance | Fail | SDD D13/S02 requires no exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block; `artifact_blocked=1` and `reason=cdp_socket_closed` violate that mandatory condition. | + +### Findings + +- **Required R1 — The fresh five-cell qualification did not satisfy the no-infrastructure-exhaustion admission gate.** + - **Evidence:** The reviewer-run status command for `run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e` returns `unresolved=0` but also `artifact_blocked=1`. Its immutable `codex-gpt-direct/.../web-validation.json` is `status=blocked`, `reason=cdp_socket_closed`, with no browser, screenshot, or viewport observation. `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp.py:609-630` permits three fresh attempts for this closed transient class and rethrows the third failure. A reviewer-only render of the same immutable workspace to a separate `/tmp` output root now succeeds with Chrome 151 and both viewports, confirming that the stored run is a transient infrastructure exhaustion rather than an unresolved deterministic source defect. SDD D13/S02 and `REVIEW_API-3` explicitly require no such exhausted block. + - **Root Cause:** During the single authorized qualification run, all three fresh Chromium/profile attempts for the Codex slot lost the CDP socket before a browser observation could be committed. Because run artifacts are immutable and the benchmark contract forbids an implicit retry, later renderer recovery cannot retrofit the missing terminal web evidence into that run. + - **Selected Fix:** Do not change repository source based on this non-reproducing transient. After explicit authorization for one new unscored qualification identity, first confirm the declared Chromium/CDP runner can render through the bounded renderer, then invoke exactly one new direct `preflight` and exactly one new direct `run` through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`. Do not `resume`, use `--retry-failed`, modify either existing run, or invoke any caller outside the benchmark CLI. Accept only `ready=5`, exactly five new attempts, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, five terminal web records, and `artifact_blocked=0`; then recompute the retained-run count/digest. + - **Disposition:** external-execution user-review gate; user authorization is required before allocating the new run identity. + - **Acceptance Commands:** `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json`; `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json`; `python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id `; retained-run count/digest audit. + +### Routing Signals + +- `review_rework_count=2` +- `evidence_integrity_failure=false` + +### Next Step + +Archive the current pair and write `USER_REVIEW.md` with the `external-execution` gate. Do not create a follow-up plan or `complete.log` until the user explicitly authorizes one new unscored qualification and the resulting evidence resolves this stop state. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c6159183 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ + + +# Complete - m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission + +## 완료 일시 + +2026-08-13 + +## 요약 + +두 차례 FAIL과 사용자 승인 정지를 거친 뒤, 승인된 replacement qualification이 SDD D13/S02의 terminal-evidence admission을 충족하여 최종 PASS했다. + +## 루프 이력 + +| Plan | Review | Verdict | 메모 | +|------|--------|---------|------| +| `plan_cloud_G09_0.log` | `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log` | FAIL | Gemini rejection provenance와 dev release/qualification 증거 보완이 필요했다. | +| `plan_cloud_G10_1.log` | `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log` | FAIL | 첫 qualification에서 Chromium/CDP 시도 소진으로 `artifact_blocked=1`이 발생했다. | +| `user_review_0.log` | replacement unscored qualification 승인 | RESOLVED | 기존 실패 run을 보존하고 새 qualification identity 한 건을 허용했다. | +| `plan_cloud_G08_2.log` | `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log` | PASS | 새 run이 5개 terminal slot, `unresolved=0`, `artifact_blocked=0`을 충족했다. | + +## 구현/정리 내용 + +- `dev-974` release/tag/artifact/runtime/provider identity를 read-only로 동결 확인했다. +- bounded Chromium/CDP admission 뒤 direct preflight 1회와 replacement run 1회만 실행했다. +- 새 run의 five-slot terminal evidence와 이전 두 run의 immutable count/digest를 검증했다. + +## 최종 검증 + +- `python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test.BrowserIntegrationTest.test_valid_page_emits_complete_two_viewport_observations` - PASS; 실제 Chromium/CDP 두 viewport 통합 테스트 1건 통과. +- `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id run-20260813T064211Z-212a8e1c4b9f` - PASS; `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, `artifact_blocked=0`. +- exact run file audit - PASS; `attempt.json=5`, `web-validation.json=5`, 모든 slot terminal. +- immutable prior-run audit - PASS; failed run 5,497 files/digest `14711f384e2b577d26a4897c67d88e56b8766a892e735048fa8ad7d55ad444c1`, retained run 5,489 files/digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. +- `git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**'` - PASS. + +## 잔여 Nit + +- 없음 + +## 후속 작업 + +- 없음 diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G08_2.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G08_2.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..32b3e356 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G08_2.log @@ -0,0 +1,225 @@ + + +# Complete the authorized terminal-evidence qualification + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Execute only the authorized verification packet below. Do not modify product, benchmark, manifest, runtime, release, credential, or subscription configuration; do not finish `dev-974` on behalf of another task. Run every verification command, fill the implementation-owned sections of `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` with actual output, keep both active files in place, and report ready for review. If a prerequisite is not met, record the exact blocker and resume condition without allocating a benchmark run or asking the user. + +## Background + +The prior implementation and deterministic review passed, but the one authorized qualification exhausted all three Chromium/CDP attempts for one cell. The user has now explicitly authorized one replacement unscored qualification identity. An independent `iop-s1` rollout subsequently placed the shared dev runtime on candidate SHA `2fcc1093c7629ab94b460d083520ffd9c8064815`; this packet must wait until that release finishes, then verify and freeze the resulting identity before any caller is invoked. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Prior plan: `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G10_1.log`. +- Prior review: `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log`, verdict `FAIL`, Required R1 only, Suggested/Nit none. +- Resolved authorization: `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/user_review_0.log`; the authorization enables new verification and is not terminal PASS evidence. +- Failed immutable qualification: `run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e`, `unresolved=0`, `artifact_blocked=1`, `reason=cdp_socket_closed` for `codex-gpt-direct`. +- Retained immutable run: `agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight/run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa/`, 5,489 regular files and digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. + +## Finding Resolution Map + +| Finding | Reviewer evidence | Exact root cause | Selected fix | Mode | Changed precondition | Acceptance commands | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| Required R1 | The prior fresh run has one immutable `blocked/cdp_socket_closed` record after the renderer's three bounded attempts, while a later isolated render of the same workspace passed. | A transient Chromium/CDP socket loss exhausted the run-owned renderer attempts; immutable evidence cannot be repaired or retried in place. | After the independent `dev-974` release is finished and frozen, pass one bounded renderer preflight, then execute exactly one new direct CLI `preflight` and exactly one new direct CLI `run`; accept only complete terminal evidence with `artifact_blocked=0`. | direct-fix | The user explicitly authorized one new unscored qualification identity, and the renderer must pass before allocation. | Browser integration test; benchmark `preflight`; one benchmark `run`; exact-run `status`; retained-run digest audit. | + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/plan/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/code-review/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/finalize-task-routing/SKILL.md` +- `agent-test/local/rules.md` +- `agent-test/dev/rules.md` +- `agent-test/inventory-dev.yaml` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp_test.py` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md` +- the three exact archive evidence paths listed above + +### SDD Criteria + +- SDD status is approved and unlocked. +- Preserved `milestone-task`: `agy-iop-compatibility,route-readiness,objective-validation`. +- D13/S02 require fresh `ready=5`, exactly five attempts, all controller/product/harness/process/web-validation terminals, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, and no exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block. +- Product failure, caller failure, provider rejection, generated-missing, and timeout remain measured terminal outcomes and must not be retried or reinterpreted. + +### Verification Context + +- Authorized runner/workdir: `/config/workspace/iop-s0`, wrapper `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`. +- Shared runtime: remote runner `toki@toki-labs.com`, checkout `/Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev`, Edge ports `18082/18083/18084/19093/19101`. +- Latest read-only observation: checkout, four build artifacts, and live processes use source `2fcc1093c7629ab94b460d083520ffd9c8064815`; all four Nodes are connected and all relevant providers are healthy/idle. The release was not yet finished at plan creation: remote `release/dev-974` existed and tag `dev-974` did not. +- Execution prerequisite: wait for the other task to finish `dev-974`. Require remote tag `dev-974`, no remote `release/dev-974`, the tag tree to equal the deployed source tree, four artifact VCS revisions to equal the frozen source commit, required listeners open, four connected Nodes, and healthy/idle provider snapshots. Do not mutate refs, binaries, config, or processes in this packet. +- Benchmark-only Codex API-key injection remains scoped to the wrapper/manifest path; normal Codex subscription configuration is not modified. Workspaces remain under the validated run root; `../iop-s2` is read-only testbed provenance, not the HTML editing workspace. +- Confidence is high for the deterministic harness and low only for live external outcome quality, which is intentionally measured rather than assumed. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- Deterministic renderer tests prove Chromium/CDP availability but cannot replace a fresh run-owned browser observation. +- Runtime identity and provider health are external temporal state and must be rechecked immediately before allocation. +- No source fix is justified because the same immutable generated workspace later rendered successfully. + +### Symbol References + +None; this packet changes no source symbols. + +### Split Judgment + +Keep one compact verification packet. Runtime freeze, bounded renderer admission, one CLI allocation, exact terminal audit, and retained-run immutability form one acceptance transaction; splitting would allow the shared runtime or browser state to change between admission and execution. + +### Scope Rationale + +- In scope: read-only release/runtime identity checks, one bounded renderer integration test, exactly one direct preflight, exactly one direct run, exact status/evidence audit, retained-run immutability audit, and review evidence. +- Out of scope: product/harness source changes, `dev-974` finish or rollback, `iop-s1` task changes, manifests, credentials, subscriptions, route/model/effort changes, resume/retry, ad-hoc caller/provider invocation, scored C01-C09 execution, and old-run mutation. + +### Final Routing + +- `evaluation_mode=isolated-reassessment`; all build/review closure fields are true and no capability gap remains. +- Finalizer: `finalize-task-policy.sh pair`. +- Build scores: scope 1, state 2, blast 1, evidence 2, verification 2 = G08; base `local-fit`, `review_rework_count=2`, `evidence_integrity_failure=false`, so route basis `recovery-boundary`, lane `cloud`, catalog `worker/cloud/G08`, filename `PLAN-cloud-G08.md`. +- Review scores: 1/2/1/2/2 = G08; route `official-review`, lane `cloud`, catalog `review/cloud/G08`, filename `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`. +- `large_indivisible_context=false`; matched loop-risk signatures are `temporal_state`, `boundary_contract`, and `variant_product` (3). + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-4] Prove `dev-974` is finished and freeze one clean release/artifact/runtime/provider identity without mutating shared runtime state. +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-5] Pass one bounded Chromium/CDP renderer integration preflight before any new benchmark allocation. +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-6] Through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`, invoke exactly one fresh direct CLI `preflight` and exactly one fresh direct CLI `run`, with no resume/retry or alternate caller path. +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-7] Audit the issued run for exactly five attempts, complete terminal axes, `artifact_blocked=0`, and audit both prior runs for immutability. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` with actual commands and output. + +### [REVIEW_API-4] Freeze the completed release and live runtime + +#### Problem + +The shared runtime was changed by another task after the prior qualification. Starting a new run while its release branch is unfinished would make the benchmark source identity unstable. + +#### Solution + +Perform read-only local/remote ref, tree, artifact, listener, Node, and provider checks. Continue only after `dev-974` is fully finished and its deployed source is one frozen identity. Do not finish, merge, reset, redeploy, restart, or edit the other task. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`: record only redacted ref/tree/artifact/listener/Node/provider identity evidence. + +#### Test Strategy + +This is a read-only temporal gate. Any missing tag, surviving release branch, identity mismatch, disconnected Node, unhealthy provider, or nonzero in-flight/queue blocks allocation. + +#### Verification + +```bash +git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main refs/heads/dev refs/heads/release/dev-974 refs/tags/dev-974 'refs/tags/dev-974^{}' +ssh toki@toki-labs.com '/bin/zsh -lc '\''cd /Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev && git status --short --branch && git rev-parse HEAD && for f in build/dev-runtime/bin/edge build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-linux-arm64 build/dev-runtime/bin/iop-node-windows-amd64.exe; do go version -m "$f" | sed -n "/vcs.revision/p;/vcs.modified/p"; done'\''' +``` + +Expected: tag exists, remote release branch is absent, checkout is clean, source/tag/artifact trees agree, all required listeners are open, all four Nodes are connected, and providers are healthy with `in_flight=0`, `queued=0`. + +### [REVIEW_API-5] Bound Chromium/CDP admission + +#### Problem + +The prior run exhausted all renderer attempts for one cell even though the same workspace later rendered successfully. + +#### Solution + +Run the repository's bounded two-viewport BrowserRenderer integration test once immediately before benchmark preflight. It uses a temporary isolated workspace/profile and exercises actual Chromium/CDP startup, navigation, screenshots, image facts, and cleanup. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`: record the exact test output. + +#### Test Strategy + +No mock is accepted for this gate. Failure stops before benchmark preflight/run; do not loop the test. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test.BrowserIntegrationTest.test_valid_page_emits_complete_two_viewport_observations +``` + +Expected: one test passes with no lingering browser process owned by the test. + +### [REVIEW_API-6] Allocate one authorized direct qualification + +#### Problem + +Authorization now exists, but no replacement qualification evidence exists. + +#### Solution + +After REVIEW_API-4/5 pass, invoke one public CLI preflight and one public CLI run through the protected wrapper. Capture the CLI-issued run ID. Do not run `resume`, `--retry-failed`, another `run`, or any caller/provider command outside the benchmark CLI. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`: record exact stdout/stderr, exit codes, command counts, and issued run ID without secrets. + +#### Test Strategy + +The live test is outcome-neutral. Product/harness/process/artifact failures remain recorded; only preflight blocking, incomplete terminal evidence, Edge pre-ingress incompatibility, or exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure blocks admission. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +``` + +Expected: `ready=5`; exactly one new run ID; five attempt slots; `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, and `artifact_blocked=0`. + +### [REVIEW_API-7] Audit terminal and immutable evidence + +#### Problem + +CLI completion alone does not prove five complete web records or prior-run immutability. + +#### Solution + +Query the exact new run through the public status command, inspect only closed non-secret evidence fields, and recompute prior-run counts/digests. Do not edit any run tree. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`: record exact status, five terminal summaries, safe rejection origin when present, CDP result, and immutable-run audits. + +#### Test Strategy + +Require five `attempt.json` and five terminal `web-validation.json` files. A terminal product failure is acceptable; an exhausted browser block is not. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id +``` + +Expected: exactly five terminal slots and `artifact_blocked=0`; `run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e` remains unchanged; retained run remains 5,489 files with digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` | REVIEW_API-4, REVIEW_API-5, REVIEW_API-6, REVIEW_API-7 | + +## Dependencies and Execution Order + +1. Wait for the independent `dev-974` release to finish; do not launch the benchmark while its remote release branch exists or its tag is absent. +2. Pass REVIEW_API-4, then REVIEW_API-5. +3. Execute REVIEW_API-6 exactly once. +4. Complete REVIEW_API-7 without mutating any run. + +## Final Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test.BrowserIntegrationTest.test_valid_page_emits_complete_two_viewport_observations +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Expected: released runtime identity is frozen, browser integration passes, the one authorized run has five complete terminal slots and no infrastructure block, prior runs are immutable, and only task evidence changed. Cached browser output is not accepted. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G09_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G09_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ff8983f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G09_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,245 @@ + + +# Direct runtime compatibility and terminal-evidence admission + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Implement the selected fixes exactly, verify them, commit and push the current feature branch, merge that feature ref into clean `dev`, and deploy it with the project `dev-runtime-deploy` procedure. The user explicitly requested dispatcher execution and approved continuous work through the final benchmark; this packet may therefore use the dispatcher as the task-loop owner, but every live benchmark caller must still be invoked only by `scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py`. Do not resume or mutate an old run, invoke a caller/provider ad hoc, expose credentials, substitute a model/route/effort, or turn a product failure into a harness pass. Fill every implementation-owned section of the paired review file with actual output and leave finalization to official review. + +## Background + +The retained direct run `run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa` is terminal (`unresolved=0`) but is not all-success: Codex→GPT passed, Claude→Gemini produced files but browser validation lost its CDP socket, agy→Gemini and Claude→GPT received HTTP 400, and Claude→Sonnet timed out after active work. Task 13 correctly stopped under the old 5/5 admission rule, but that rule conflated benchmark outcomes with incomplete measurement and caused repeated pre-benchmark cycles. This packet removes that conflation while repairing two identified measurement/runtime compatibility defects: Gemini tool-call identity is not round-tripped and transient CDP loss has no bounded renderer restart. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/13+12_scored_benchmark_result/complete.log` is the satisfied predecessor. It records the one direct run, complete five-slot terminal evidence, and zero C01-C09 allocations. +- The exact retained run above and every older run are immutable evidence. Never resume, retry, edit, delete, or select them as the new diagnostic result. +- Its agy cell reached the Gemini bridge for the initial and continuation requests; the continuation returned 400. Current source synthesizes Chat tool IDs, discards upstream `delta.tool_calls[].id`, and emits a non-standard `tool_name` field on the tool result. +- Its Claude→GPT cell returned a first-turn provider HTTP 400. No raw provider body may be copied into tracked evidence. A sanitized origin/status observation is required so a provider rejection is not misclassified as an Edge ingress warning. +- Its Claude→Gemini artifact is `blocked/cdp_socket_closed`; Codex→GPT later rendered successfully on the same host. This is a transient validation-infrastructure class, not a product-quality result. + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `agent-ops/rules/project/domain/edge/rules.md` +- `agent-ops/rules/project/domain/testing/rules.md` +- `agent-test/local/rules.md` +- `agent-test/dev/rules.md` +- `agent-test/dev/testing-smoke.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark/SKILL.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md` +- `agent-spec/testing/agent-comparison-benchmark.md` +- `docs/agent-comparison-benchmark-dev-guide.md` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_types.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_bridge.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_handler.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_bridge.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_stream.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_bridge_test.go` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp_test.py` +- the predecessor `complete.log` and its directly linked plan/review logs + +### Selected Root Causes and Fixes + +1. Gemini native continuation loses the provider-issued function-call ID. `geminiFunctionCall`/`geminiFunctionResponse` have no `id`; response streaming ignores OpenAI `delta.tool_calls[].id`; request conversion always synthesizes a positional ID and emits `tool_name` on the OpenAI tool message. Preserve a bounded valid ID end-to-end, match explicit response IDs to the pending same-name call, keep the positional/FIFO path only when the native request omitted IDs, reject duplicates/mismatches, and emit only standard `role`, `tool_call_id`, and `content` for tool-result messages. +2. The browser renderer owns one Chromium process and immediately converts a recoverable start/handshake/socket loss into `artifact=blocked`. Split the current body into one-attempt rendering and a wrapper that performs at most three total fresh browser/profile attempts only for the closed transient classes. Every failed attempt must reap its process group and delete partial screenshots before the next attempt. Source/product validation is never retried. +3. HTTP 400 origin is opaque. Add secret-safe observations for Gemini pre-ingress rejection versus upstream provider rejection and Anthropic→Chat upstream provider rejection. Log only surface/bridge, a closed rejection class, and HTTP status; never log request/response bodies, headers, routes, credentials, model prompts, or provider error messages. +4. Direct admission currently requires product, harness, process, and artifact success 5/5. Replace it with a measurement-completeness gate: fresh preflight `ready=5`; exactly five fresh attempts; `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`; every slot has controller/product/harness/process/web-validation terminal evidence; and no exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block. Product failure, provider rejection, generated-missing after caller failure, and timeout remain measured outcomes and do not trigger another implementation cycle. + +### SDD and Contract Criteria + +- D06/D10 keep repetitions=1 for a scored C01-C09 run and preserve all failures. This packet is unscored diagnosis/deployment qualification, not a scored run. +- S13 requires official agy Gemini request/tool/SSE compatibility through IOP. The ID-preserving round trip and live direct observation are its acceptance evidence. +- OpenAI/Gemini/Anthropic public error bodies remain sanitized. Added logs are classification-only operational evidence. +- A direct product failure after complete terminal evidence is a benchmark result. Only an Edge pre-ingress incompatibility or exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block prevents packet acceptance. + +### Verification Context + +- Current feature baseline is pushed at `634531af`; working tree was clean before this pair was created. +- The managed benchmark wrapper `/tmp/iop-bench-13-env` is invoked via `/bin/bash`, reads the rotated token without sourcing it, and must never be printed. +- The prior deployed runtime is `dev-936` and predates this packet. Validation against it is not acceptance evidence. +- External runner is `toki@toki-labs.com:/Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev`. Follow the complete `dev-runtime-deploy` clean-sync, sequential-test, four-binary rebuild, restart, health, capacity-smoke, release-finish, and atomic-push contract. +- Before merging, push this packet's feature commit normally. On the runner fetch both refs, require clean `dev`, fast-forward/merge the exact feature tip into `dev` without force, push `dev`, then start the release from the resulting clean `origin/dev`. Existing tags/other release branches/divergence are hard blockers; do not reset or delete them. +- Confidence is high for the Gemini ID/tool-result and admission defects, and high that bounded CDP restart removes the observed one-process transient without masking product failure. Claude→GPT provider acceptance remains a live compatibility outcome; safe status-origin evidence, not speculative request mutation, closes that uncertainty. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- Unit fixtures cannot establish live provider acceptance, process identity, remote binary identity, or CDP stability under the benchmark workload. +- One fresh unscored five-cell diagnostic run after deployment is required. It is not required to be product 5/5; it is required to be evidence-complete and free of a known infrastructure-only block. + +### Symbol References + +- `geminiFunctionCall`, `geminiFunctionResponse`, `geminiContentToChat`, `geminiBridgeToolState`, `geminiBridgeStream.emitTools` +- `Server.handleGeminiStreamGenerateContent`, `Server.writeAnthropicChatBridgeResponse` +- `BrowserRenderer.render` + +### Split Judgment + +This packet owns runtime/harness compatibility, policy, deployment, and one unscored direct qualification. The dependent `15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report` owns the only new scored C01-C09 identity, blind scoring, and dated report. Predecessor 13 is satisfied by the exact archive path above; task 15 must wait for this packet's archived `complete.log`. + +### Scope Rationale + +- Include only the Gemini bridge, sanitized rejection observations, CDP renderer retry, matching tests, direct-admission documents, deployment, and one fresh direct diagnostic. +- Exclude caller adapters, manifests, matrix order, evaluator, score/report implementation, credentials, normal user configs, old run data, and any change intended merely to force every model to succeed. +- Do not implement a new Anthropic→OpenAI Responses bridge in this packet. The observed Claude→GPT 400 is provider-origin until safe evidence proves an Edge ingress defect; speculative protocol replacement would exceed the selected root cause. + +### Final Routing + +- `evaluation_mode=first-pass`; finalizer `pair` route already selected build `cloud/G09` and review `cloud/G09` with `plan=0`. +- Loop risks are live external state, protocol boundary, deployment blast radius, and variant products. Official review must independently rerun deterministic tests and inspect sanitized live evidence. + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] [API-1] Preserve and validate Gemini function-call IDs through request and streaming response conversion, remove the non-standard tool-result field, and add same-name/out-of-order/duplicate/missing-ID regression tests. +- [ ] [API-2] Add classification-only Gemini and Anthropic Chat rejection observations with tests proving no request, response, credential, route, prompt, or provider-message content is logged. +- [ ] [API-3] Add at most three total fresh Chromium/CDP attempts for closed transient infrastructure errors, with per-attempt cleanup and tests for retry, exhaustion, non-transient no-retry, screenshot cleanup, and process reaping. +- [ ] [API-4] Update benchmark skill/spec/SDD/Milestone/dev guide so direct qualification gates on readiness and terminal evidence rather than all-success, while exhausted infrastructure blocks and scored-run uniqueness remain fail-closed. +- [ ] [API-5] Run fresh local tests, commit/push the feature branch, merge its exact tip into clean `dev`, execute the full dev-runtime release/deploy procedure, and prove all Edge/Node binaries and health observations use the same released source. +- [ ] [API-6] Through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`, run one fresh direct preflight and one fresh unscored direct run; accept product failures/timeouts as results but require five terminal slots, `unresolved=0`, and no infrastructure-only browser/CDP block. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +### [API-1] Gemini tool-call identity + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_types.go`: add optional native IDs to function call/response types. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go`: validate IDs, preserve explicit IDs, exact-match responses, and emit standard Chat tool messages. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_bridge.go`: retain streamed provider ID and return it in Gemini `functionCall`. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go`: cover explicit-ID round trip, ID-less fallback, duplicate/mismatch rejection, and streamed ID projection. + +#### Verification + +```bash +go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini' +``` + +Expected: every Gemini bridge test passes; explicit IDs survive byte-level JSON projection and ID-less legacy input remains deterministic. + +### [API-2] Sanitized rejection origin + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go`: classify pre-ingress versus provider HTTP rejection without raw payloads. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go`: assert closed fields and absence of secret/body/message markers. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_stream.go`: observe Chat bridge provider status before sanitized caller projection. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_bridge_test.go`: assert provider-origin status evidence contains no raw provider body. + +#### Verification + +```bash +go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini|Anthropic.*Bridge|Rejection' +``` + +Expected: logs distinguish ingress/provider classes with status only and contain none of the fixture secrets or messages. + +### [API-3] Bounded CDP recovery + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp.py`: isolate one render attempt and retry a closed transient set for at most three total fresh processes/profiles. +- [ ] `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp_test.py`: prove retry bounds, cleanup, and non-transient behavior. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.browser_cdp_test +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.web_validation_test +``` + +Expected: transient first/second failure can recover; third fails closed; non-transient errors run once; no orphan process or partial screenshot remains. + +### [API-4] Admission contract + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark/SKILL.md`: replace direct all-success qualification with terminal-evidence admission and retain scored execution prohibitions. +- [ ] `agent-spec/testing/agent-comparison-benchmark.md`: align current implemented lifecycle/admission semantics. +- [ ] `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md`: record continuing approval, unscored diagnostic boundary, and one scored-run identity. +- [ ] `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md`: replace the obsolete blocker narrative without marking comparison tasks complete. +- [ ] `docs/agent-comparison-benchmark-dev-guide.md`: document exact direct admission, failure-as-result, and infrastructure blocker rules. +- [ ] `scripts/agent_benchmark/skill_contract_test.py`: lock public wording and stop/retry boundaries. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +``` + +Expected: policy sources agree; direct product failure is not an endless fix gate; incomplete evidence and implicit retry remain prohibited. + +### [API-5] Source publication and dev deployment + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md`: record exact feature/dev/release refs, tests, four artifact hashes, process/listener/health/capacity results, and any stop condition without secrets. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package"; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./cmd/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +``` + +Expected: all tests pass from clean published source; release procedure reports a single source identity for Edge/mac/Linux/Windows binaries and 4/4 connected Nodes with healthy providers. + +### [API-6] Fresh direct diagnostic + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md`: record command counts, fresh IDs, terminal summaries, safe rejection origin, CDP outcome, and immutable-old-run audit. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +``` + +Expected: `ready=5`; one distinct run with five attempts and web validations; `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`; no exhausted `cdp_*`/`browser_*` infrastructure block. Product/process/artifact failures remain visible and are not retried. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_types.go` | API-1 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go` | API-1, API-2 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_bridge.go` | API-1 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go` | API-1, API-2 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_stream.go` | API-2 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_bridge_test.go` | API-2 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp.py` | API-3 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/browser_cdp_test.py` | API-3 | +| `agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark/SKILL.md` | API-4 | +| `agent-spec/testing/agent-comparison-benchmark.md` | API-4 | +| `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md` | API-4 | +| `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md` | API-4 | +| `docs/agent-comparison-benchmark-dev-guide.md` | API-4 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/skill_contract_test.py` | API-4 | +| `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md` | API-5, API-6 | + +## Dependencies and Execution Order + +- Predecessor 13 is satisfied by `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/13+12_scored_benchmark_result/complete.log`. +- Execute API-1 and API-2, then API-3, API-4, API-5, and API-6. Do not run the live diagnostic against an unreleased or stale binary. +- Packet `15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report` must remain dependency-waiting until this packet has an archived PASS `complete.log`. + +## Final Verification + +```bash +go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Expected: deterministic tests and manifests pass, implementation files are committed/pushed and deployed from one released source, the only uncommitted task mutation is implementation evidence/finalization state, and the fresh direct diagnostic satisfies terminal-evidence admission without hiding product failures. After completing all code changes, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md`. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G10_1.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G10_1.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..42a5449e --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G10_1.log @@ -0,0 +1,260 @@ + + +# Rejection provenance and terminal-qualified dev release follow-up + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Implement the selected fixes exactly, run every listed verification, and fill the implementation-owned sections of `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` with actual stdout/stderr and live evidence. Keep the active pair in place and report ready for review; final verdict, archive names, `complete.log`, and task moves are review-agent-only. If blocked, record only the exact blocker, attempted commands/output, and resume condition. Do not ask the user, invoke user-input tools, create stop files, classify the next state, mutate old benchmark runs, or invoke a live caller/provider outside `scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py`. + +## Background + +The first review found that Gemini rejection origin is inferred from the final internal Chat status rather than actual provider provenance: Edge-local dispatch failures become `provider_http`, while authentication failures are not observed. It also found that the release blocker has disappeared from authoritative remote refs, but the deployment skill retains stale-ref ambiguity, an invalid project-skill frontmatter key, and a nonexistent Go package root. This follow-up fixes those closed defects, releases one exact corrected source, and runs the still-required fresh five-cell direct qualification. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G09_0.log` and `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log` preserve the first loop. Verdict: `FAIL`; Required R1/R2; Suggested/Nit: none. +- R1 evidence: an Edge-local normalized `SubmitRun` failure is logged as `provider_http`; Gemini auth rejection emits no `pre_ingress` observation. Direct-fix targets are the Gemini/auth bridge, tunnel release provenance hook, and regression tests. +- R2 evidence: API-5/API-6 were not run. Authoritative origin has no release branch, while the runner has stale remote-tracking release refs. The deploy skill contains unsupported `version` frontmatter and its sequential Go command fails on nonexistent `./cmd/...`. +- Published feature evidence starts at `28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2`; the implementing agent must publish a new corrected exact tip before merging it into `dev`. +- The retained run `agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight/run-20260812T222805Z-bec48f5fffaa/` remains immutable: 5,489 files and aggregate digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. + +## Finding Resolution Map + +| Finding | Reviewer evidence and root cause | Selected fix | Mode | Changed precondition | Acceptance commands | +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| R1 | `gemini_handler.go:87-90` labels every internal Chat `>=400` as provider HTTP; `routes.go:35-45,58-72` bypasses Gemini pre-ingress observation. Final bridge status has no actual provider `RESPONSE_START` provenance. | Route Gemini auth/managed-credential failures through the pre-ingress writer; remove blanket status inference; pass a once-only callback into the Gemini writer; notify it only where the raw tunnel sink writes an actual provider error status; add owner-negative and safe-field tests. | `direct-fix` | Actual provider status and Edge-local terminal status become distinguishable at the response-writer boundary. | `go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini.*Rejection|GeminiIngressRejectsAuthentication'`; `go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai` | +| R2 | API-5/API-6 have zero live commands. `git ls-remote` shows no remote release head, but the runner retains stale tracking refs. `dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md:3,70,95` has invalid frontmatter, no initial prune/authoritative-head rule, and nonexistent `./cmd/...`. | Correct the project skill and deterministic contract tests; publish/merge the corrected feature tip; perform the complete release/deploy/capacity procedure; then run one CLI-owned fresh five-cell direct preflight/run and preserve all terminal outcomes. | `direct-fix` | Stale tracking refs are pruned and cannot masquerade as remote heads; the mandated sequential test command becomes runnable; the deployed runtime contains R1. | `python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test`; both skill validators; corrected sequential Go tests; complete dev-runtime release evidence; fresh direct `preflight` and `run` via `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env` | + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/plan_cloud_G09_0.log` +- `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/code_review_cloud_G09_0.log` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_bridge.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/routes.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/stream_gate_release_sink.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/stream_gate_tunnel_codec.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/stream_gate_pipeline_test.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/server_test_support_test.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/identity_metering_test.go` +- `apps/edge/internal/openai/anthropic_stream.go` +- `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark/SKILL.md` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/skill_contract_test.py` +- `agent-spec/testing/agent-comparison-benchmark.md` +- `agent-contract/outer/gemini-compatible-api.md` +- `agent-contract/outer/openai-compatible-api.md` +- `agent-contract/outer/anthropic-compatible-api.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md` +- `agent-test/dev/rules.md` +- `agent-test/dev/edge-smoke.md` +- `agent-test/dev/testing-smoke.md` + +### SDD Criteria + +- SDD: `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md`; status `[승인됨]`; lock `해제`. +- Preserved `milestone-task`: `agy-iop-compatibility,route-readiness,objective-validation`. +- S02 requires a fresh `ready=5`, five terminal direct slots without infrastructure exhaustion, then route/auth/effort/terminal evidence. S09 requires uniform web-validation evidence. S13 requires official agy Gemini auth, request/tool/SSE, and live lifecycle evidence. +- Evidence Map rows S02, S09, and S13 therefore drive the provenance regression tests, released-source identity checks, five-slot direct run, web-validation terminal checks, and retained-run immutability audit below. + +### Verification Context + +- Handoff: the first review log supplies actual focused/broad outputs, R1/R2 diagnosis, selected fixes, and exclusions. Current source and remote refs were revalidated without changing external state. +- Local evidence: focused Edge tests pass; Python benchmark suite passes 458 tests; the corrected package list passes sequentially after one independently reproducible workspace-test flake passed three focused reruns and a complete rerun. +- Current authoritative refs at planning: `origin/dev=841511472a62ec20d79eac5f800180d1de34b541`, `origin/main=bc5b326140c809d6d3685ca35d7311e31a180d7c`, feature=`28ed27a575f6e3ba473a8c76c78a9e82027525f2`; no authoritative remote `release/*` head; tag `dev-936` peels to `origin/main`. +- External Verification Preflight: runner `toki@toki-labs.com`, repo `/Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev`, Darwin arm64, clean local `dev` at `fd32abb...` and behind current origin/dev by three. Stale tracking refs are `origin/release/dev-781` and `origin/release/dev-936`; use `git fetch --prune` before judging release state. Git-flow is AVH 1.12.3 with `main`/`dev`/`release/`; Go is `/opt/homebrew/bin/go`, version 1.26.3. All four binary paths and `build/dev-runtime/edge.yaml` exist; the prior Edge process listens on 18082/18083/18084/19093 but is stale and is not acceptance evidence. +- Setup: after publishing the corrected feature tip, prune and clean-sync the runner, prove authoritative remote release heads are empty, merge the exact tip into `dev`, push it, recompute `dev-` from the post-merge dev commit, and then follow the release procedure. Do not move/delete `dev-936`. +- Constraint: `/tmp/iop-bench-13-env` is invoked only through `/bin/bash`; its token material is never printed. Old runs are not resumed, retried, edited, or selected as the new result. +- Gaps: only released-runtime identity, provider capacity, and fresh caller terminal evidence remain external. The declared runner and direct node routes are authorized, so no user-review gate applies. +- Confidence: high. Focused reproducers prove R1, `ls-remote` proves the stale-ref condition, and the package/validator failures are deterministic. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- Gemini malformed-body and real provider-400 logging are covered; auth/managed pre-ingress and Edge-local error non-provider provenance are missing and must be added. +- The deploy skill has no assertion covering frontmatter validity, initial prune/authoritative release head, or package roots; extend the existing project contract test. +- Unit tests cannot prove deployed binary identity, four-node connectivity/capacity, official caller behavior, or CDP stability; the release and one fresh direct diagnostic remain required. + +### Symbol References + +- `geminiBridgeResponseWriter.Status`: only `handleGeminiStreamGenerateContent` uses it; remove both the method and its caller-side inference. +- `newGeminiBridgeResponseWriter`: only `handleGeminiStreamGenerateContent` calls it; update that call with the provider-rejection callback. +- New private provider-status observer is implemented by `geminiBridgeResponseWriter` and consumed only by `openAITunnelReleaseSink`; no public API changes. + +### Split Judgment + +Keep one plan. R1 must be in the exact feature source merged and released by R2, and S02/S13 acceptance requires the live diagnostic against that released identity. Splitting would allow no useful intermediate PASS and would sever the source→release→evidence invariant. Predecessor 13 remains satisfied by the exact archive evidence already recorded in the prior loop. + +### Scope Rationale + +- Include only Gemini rejection provenance, the tunnel observer seam, related tests, the project deploy skill/contract test, source publication, dev release, and one fresh unscored direct qualification. +- Exclude Gemini tool-call ID logic, Anthropic observation logic, browser retry implementation, benchmark scoring/reporting, caller adapters, manifests, credentials, common Agent-Ops files, old run contents, and any change intended only to force product success. +- Do not change the endpoint error bodies or add provider/request/model identifiers to logs. + +### Final Routing + +- `evaluation_mode=isolated-reassessment`; finalizer=`finalize-task-policy.sh`, mode=`pair`; status=`routed`. +- Build closures: scope/context/verification/evidence/ownership/decision all `true`; capability gap none; scores `2/2/2/2/2` => G10; base/route basis=`grade-boundary`; lane=`cloud`; catalog=`worker/cloud/G10`; filename=`PLAN-cloud-G10.md`. +- Review closures: all `true`; scores `2/2/2/2/2` => G10; basis=`official-review`; lane=`cloud`; catalog=`review/cloud/G10`; filename=`CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`. +- `large_indivisible_context=false`; positive loop risks=`temporal_state,boundary_contract,structured_interpretation,variant_product` (4); risk boundary matched but does not replace grade basis. +- Recovery signals: `review_rework_count=1`, `evidence_integrity_failure=false`; recovery boundary not matched. + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-1] Correct Gemini pre-ingress/provider-HTTP provenance and add regression tests for auth, managed credential rejection, actual tunnel error, Edge-local failure, exact fields, and secret absence. +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-2] Repair and validate the dev-runtime deployment skill, publish the corrected feature tip, merge that exact tip into clean `dev`, and complete the full release/deploy/identity/connectivity/capacity procedure. +- [ ] [REVIEW_API-3] Through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`, run one fresh direct preflight and one fresh unscored five-cell run, record terminal-evidence admission, and prove the retained run is unchanged. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +### [REVIEW_API-1] Bind rejection class to actual owner + +#### Problem + +`apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go:86-90` currently does this after all internal Chat paths: + +```go +bridge := newGeminiBridgeResponseWriter(w, callerModel) +s.handleChatCompletions(bridge, internal) +if bridge.Status() >= http.StatusBadRequest { + s.observeGeminiRejection(geminiRejectionProviderHTTP, bridge.Status()) +} +``` + +This cannot distinguish raw provider `RESPONSE_START` from Edge admission/dispatch/runtime errors. `apps/edge/internal/openai/routes.go:58-72` also writes Gemini auth-layer errors without calling `writeGeminiPreIngressError`. + +#### Solution + +Replace status inference with an explicit, private provider-status signal: + +```go +bridge := newGeminiBridgeResponseWriter(w, callerModel, func(status int) { + s.observeGeminiRejection(geminiRejectionProviderHTTP, status) +}) +s.handleChatCompletions(bridge, internal) +bridge.Finish() +``` + +Add a once-only method on `geminiBridgeResponseWriter` that invokes the callback only for `status >= 400`. In `openAITunnelReleaseSink.CommitResponseStart` and its staged provider error-response write path, notify a private response-writer observer immediately before writing an actual provider status. Never notify from normalized sinks, recovery/admission errors, compatibility errors, or generic terminal writers. Route Gemini branches in `writeAuthenticationFailure` and `writeCallerProviderCredentialRejection` through `writeGeminiPreIngressError`. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/routes.go`: observe Gemini auth and managed caller-credential rejection as `pre_ingress`. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go`: remove final-status inference and wire the bounded provider callback. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_bridge.go`: remove `Status`, add once-only actual-provider status observation. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/stream_gate_release_sink.go`: notify only at actual raw provider status commit points. +- [ ] `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go`: add all positive/negative provenance and log-safety assertions. + +#### Test Strategy + +Write regression tests in `gemini_handler_test.go`. Assert missing/invalid auth and managed caller credential are `pre_ingress`; a provider-tunnel 400 is exactly one `provider_http`; normalized `SubmitRun` failure does not produce `provider_http`; every observation has exactly four safe fields and omits fixture secrets. + +#### Verification + +```bash +go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai -run 'Gemini.*Rejection|GeminiIngressRejectsAuthentication' +go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +``` + +Expected: all tests pass; only actual provider HTTP status creates `provider_http`. + +### [REVIEW_API-2] Repair the deploy contract and release one exact source + +#### Problem + +`agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md:3` uses an unsupported `version` frontmatter key, line 70 initially fetches without prune/authoritative-head distinction, and lines 92-97 include nonexistent `./cmd/...`. API-5 has no merge, release, binary, process, node, or capacity evidence. + +#### Solution + +Remove the `version` key. Require `git fetch --prune origin dev main --tags`, use `git ls-remote --heads origin 'refs/heads/release/*'` as the authoritative release-head check, and describe stale local tracking refs as cleanup evidence rather than remote blockers. Remove `./cmd/...` from the pre/post-build sequential package list. Add exact assertions in the existing benchmark skill contract test, then validate both project skills. + +Commit only the selected source/skill/test changes plus implementation evidence as appropriate, push the exact feature tip normally, and record its SHA. On the runner, prune, require clean state and no authoritative release head, clean-sync local `main`/`dev`, merge the exact recorded feature SHA into `dev` without force, push `dev`, recompute its commit count, and execute all dev-runtime-deploy steps. Record pre/post sequential tests, four `-trimpath` builds with SHA-256 and `go version -m` source, config/refresh checks, process/listener identity, four connected Nodes, provider snapshots, both endpoint capacity+1 saturation/queue/recovery, finish preflight, tag tree, atomic push, and cleanup. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md`: fix frontmatter, authoritative prune/ref rules, and package roots. +- [ ] `scripts/agent_benchmark/skill_contract_test.py`: lock the corrected skill contract. +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`: record exact publication, runner, release, artifact, runtime, and capacity output. + +#### Test Strategy + +Extend `BenchmarkSkillContractTest` with deterministic tracked-text assertions; no new test file. Re-run the corrected sequential command locally and on the release source. Live deployment evidence is mandatory and cannot be replaced by unit tests. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy +python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark +while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package" || exit; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +git ls-remote --heads origin 'refs/heads/release/*' +``` + +Expected: validators and tests pass; authoritative release-head output is empty before the new release; the full `dev-runtime-deploy` procedure finishes with one source identity and healthy capacity evidence. + +### [REVIEW_API-3] Run the released five-cell terminal qualification + +#### Problem + +API-6 command counts are zero. SDD S02/S09/S13 still lack fresh released-runtime evidence; the retained old run is evidence-complete but cannot qualify this corrected source. + +#### Solution + +After REVIEW_API-2 finishes, invoke exactly one fresh direct preflight and one fresh direct run through the benchmark CLI and managed wrapper. Require `ready=5`, exactly five attempts, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, controller/product/harness/process/web-validation terminals for every slot, and no exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block. Preserve product failure/provider rejection/generated-missing/timeout as outcomes and do not retry. Recompute the retained-run file count/digest afterward. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`: record command counts, fresh IDs, five terminal summaries, safe rejection origin, CDP result, and retained-run audit. + +#### Test Strategy + +No harness source change is planned. The required test is the one fresh CLI-owned live diagnostic against the released source; an outcome may fail, but evidence completeness and infrastructure admission must pass. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +``` + +Expected: fresh `ready=5`; one new run with five terminal slots and no exhausted browser/CDP block; product failures remain visible and un-retried. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/routes.go` | REVIEW_API-1 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler.go` | REVIEW_API-1 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_bridge.go` | REVIEW_API-1 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/stream_gate_release_sink.go` | REVIEW_API-1 | +| `apps/edge/internal/openai/gemini_handler_test.go` | REVIEW_API-1 | +| `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md` | REVIEW_API-2 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/skill_contract_test.py` | REVIEW_API-2 | +| `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` | REVIEW_API-2, REVIEW_API-3 | + +## Dependencies and Execution Order + +1. Implement and verify REVIEW_API-1. +2. Repair/validate the deploy skill, commit and publish the resulting exact feature tip, then complete REVIEW_API-2 against that tip. +3. Run REVIEW_API-3 only after the released runtime identity is proven. Do not run against the stale process. + +## Final Verification + +```bash +go test -count=1 ./apps/edge/internal/openai +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.skill_contract_test +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy +python3 /config/.codex/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +while IFS= read -r package; do go test -count=1 "$package" || exit; done < <(go list ./apps/control-plane/... ./apps/edge/... ./apps/node/... ./packages/go/... ./scripts/... | sed '/^iop\/packages\/go\/agenttask$/d') +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Then execute every step and checklist in `agent-ops/skills/project/dev-runtime-deploy/SKILL.md`, followed by the two REVIEW_API-3 commands. Cached test output is not accepted; use `-count=1`. Expected: all deterministic checks pass, feature/dev/release/artifact/runtime identities agree, all required deploy/capacity gates pass before finish, the direct run is terminal-evidence complete, and the retained run digest is unchanged. + +After completing all code changes, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md`. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/user_review_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/user_review_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..23aaebb4 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/user_review_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,54 @@ +# User Review Required - m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission + +## Requested At + +2026-08-13 + +## Status + +RESOLVED_FOR_REPLAN + +## Reason + +- Type: external-execution +- Target: authorized benchmark runner `/config/workspace/iop-s0` with `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env`, Chromium/CDP, and the dev IOP endpoint bound by `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json` +- Current review number: 2 +- Final verdict: FAIL +- Summary: The only permitted fresh five-cell qualification exhausted all three Chromium/CDP attempts for `codex-gpt-direct`. The immutable run cannot be repaired or implicitly retried, and allocating one new unscored qualification identity requires explicit user authorization. + +## Loop History + +| Plan | Review | Verdict | Note | +|------|--------|---------|------| +| `plan_cloud_G09_0.log` | `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log` | FAIL | Gemini rejection provenance was lossy, and release/deployment plus fresh qualification had not run. | +| `plan_cloud_G10_1.log` | `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log` | FAIL | Provenance, deployment contract, deterministic tests, and dev-971 release evidence pass, but the fresh qualification has `artifact_blocked=1` from exhausted `cdp_socket_closed`. | + +## Blocking Evidence + +- Problem: SDD D13/S02 and `REVIEW_API-3` require no exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block, but `run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e` contains one immutable blocked web-validation record. +- Current archived plan: `plan_cloud_G10_1.log` +- Current archived review: `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log` +- Verification command: `python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json --run-id run-20260813T020758Z-2920dc067c4e` +- Actual output: `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, `artifact_blocked=1`; `codex-gpt-direct/.../web-validation.json` has `status=blocked`, `reason=cdp_socket_closed`, no browser observation, no screenshots, and no viewports. +- Blocking rationale: A reviewer-only render of the same immutable workspace to a separate `/tmp` output root now succeeds with Chrome 151 and both viewports, so no deterministic repository defect was reproduced. The old run remains immutable, the benchmark contract prohibits an implicit retry, and the skill requires explicit authorization before a new execution identity is allocated. + +## Required User Action + +- [x] Explicitly authorize exactly one new unscored five-cell direct qualification cycle: one fresh CLI `preflight` and one fresh CLI `run`, without `resume`, `--retry-failed`, old-run mutation, or ad-hoc caller/provider invocation. + +## Resolution + +- 2026-08-13: 사용자가 작업 종료까지 필요한 승인을 부여했고 이후에도 계속 작업하도록 지시했다. 이 승인은 새 unscored direct qualification identity 한 건을 허용하지만, 검증 완료를 뜻하지 않으므로 새 PLAN/CODE_REVIEW pair로 재개한다. + +## Resume Condition + +- Authorization is recorded, the declared runner first passes a bounded Chromium/CDP render preflight, and one new run identity is produced through `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env` with `ready=5`, exactly five new attempts, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`, five terminal web-validation records, and `artifact_blocked=0`; the retained run must remain 5,489 files with digest `d089cd4b3e9bfd4e8ebe3bfa82032a544f0625e0793ad9763b728addf62baffd`. + +## Next Execution Hint + +- Resolve this review stop for `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/USER_REVIEW.md`. After explicit authorization, route through the benchmark CLI only: `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json`, then exactly one matching `run` command. + +## Closure Rules + +- If the recorded user action and evidence resolve this stop as complete/PASS, update `USER_REVIEW.md` to the resolved state, write `complete.log` from `agent-ops/skills/common/code-review/templates/complete-log-template.md`, and move the task directory to the archive. +- If new implementation is required, the `plan` skill archives `USER_REVIEW.md` as `user_review_N.log` before writing a new `PLAN-*-G??.md` / `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md` pair. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G09_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G09_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..edd28cd9 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G09_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,112 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST]** Execute the deterministic plan exactly and fill every implementation-owned section. Do not change source/manifests, run callers outside the CLI, resume/retry caller attempts, allocate a second scored run, ask the user, create stop files, archive artifacts, or write `complete.log`. Final verdict/finalization is review-agent-only. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-13 +task=m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report, plan=0, tag=TEST + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Dependency-wait for `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log`. +- Preserve all existing direct and C01-C09 run roots. This packet owns one distinct new C01-C09 run only. +- Scoring retry is evaluator-only, explicit, append-only, and limited to three total score invocations. + +## For the Review Agent + +Reconstruct command counts and identities from durable state. Verify one scored run, nine terminal slots, no caller retry, eligible-only blind scoring, deterministic reports, and isolation. Failed/timed-out cells are valid outcomes. On PASS append verdict, archive pair, write `complete.log` with milestone metadata, and move the task directory. On WARN/FAIL follow the code-review skill with a reviewer-selected fix. + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| TEST-1 Final admission | [ ] | +| TEST-2 Single execution | [ ] | +| TEST-3 Status/scoring | [ ] | +| TEST-4 Reports/audit | [ ] | +| TEST-5 Final integrity | [ ] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] [TEST-1] Verify predecessor 14 PASS, exact released runtime/source identity, immutable manifests, protected-file modes, caller versions, 4/4 Nodes, provider health, and `ready=9` without exposing secrets. +- [ ] [TEST-2] Invoke exactly one fresh C01-C09 `run`, capture its issued ID, and require nine complete terminal slots with `unresolved=0`; preserve every product/harness/process/artifact outcome without resume or caller retry. +- [ ] [TEST-3] Query status for that exact run and score eligible artifacts blindly; use `--retry-scoring-failed` only when required and at most three total score invocations, preserving every score attempt. +- [ ] [TEST-4] Generate the deterministic run-owned report, audit identities/counts/timing/usage/links/isolation, and publish `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` with prior-run relationship, failures, limitations, and raw evidence pointers. +- [ ] [TEST-5] Rerun deterministic verification and prove old runs, testbed, normal caller subscriptions, credentials, manifests, and released runtime were not mutated by benchmark execution. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify this section. + +- [ ] Append verdict and verified routing signals. +- [ ] Verify every dimension and finding classification. +- [ ] Rerun deterministic commands and reconstruct dynamic command/run/score/report counts. +- [ ] Record evidence, exact root cause, selected fix, files/tests, and acceptance commands for every Required/Suggested finding before follow-up. +- [ ] Archive plan/review to correctly numbered logs and verify `.gitignore` managed block. +- [ ] On PASS write `complete.log`, preserve/report milestone metadata, move the task directory, and leave no active task files. +- [ ] On WARN/FAIL write the required next filesystem state and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +_Implementing agent: replace with actual deviations or `None`._ + +## Key Design Decisions + +_Implementing agent: record actual execution decisions within the fixed policy._ + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Predecessor 14 archive PASS predates every new C01-C09 attempt. +- Preflight count is one, scored run count is one, and run ID is absent from all older roots. +- Every matrix slot has exactly one caller attempt and terminal web validation; no resume/`--retry-failed` exists. +- Score command count is 1-3 only; retries correspond solely to prior `scoring_failed` and have fresh score IDs. +- Reports use the exact run ID, retain failed/unscored rows, and do not invent unavailable metrics or arbitrary ranks. +- Exact protected-value scan returns zero hits and old-run/testbed/subscription/runtime identities are unchanged. + +## Verification Results + +### TEST-1 Admission + +```text +_Implementing agent: exact commands, bounded output, identities, and exit codes._ +``` + +### TEST-2 C01-C09 run + +```text +_Implementing agent: exact single run output, ID, terminal axes, and exit._ +``` + +### TEST-3 Status and scoring + +```text +_Implementing agent: exact status/score commands, score IDs/counts, output, and exits._ +``` + +### TEST-4 Report and evidence audit + +```text +_Implementing agent: exact report output/path and bounded audit results._ +``` + +### TEST-5 Final integrity + +```text +_Implementing agent: fresh tests, immutable/isolation audit, and exits._ +``` + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING]** Fill every implementation-owned section and check every completed item. Leave review-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | +|---|---| +| Header, Overview, Archive Snapshot, item names, checkpoints | Fixed at stub creation | +| Implementation checklist statuses, deviations, decisions, initial verification | Implementing agent | +| Review-only checklist, verdict, archive/finalization | Official review agent | diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c35a494c --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_1.log @@ -0,0 +1,239 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST]** Implement the compact fixture and same-caller scoring fix, verify them, then execute only the one changed-manifest live run authorized by the plan. Fill every implementation-owned section. Do not resume/retry caller attempts, allocate another run, mutate old evidence, ask the user, create stop files, archive artifacts, or write `complete.log`; official review owns finalization. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-13 +task=m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report, plan=1, tag=TEST + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Superseded pair: `plan_cloud_G09_0.log`, `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log`. +- Diagnostic-only old run: `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T071816Z-755d136c3e2b`; preserve it and never use it as the final report source. +- Predecessor 14 PASS: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log`. + +## For the Review Agent + +Verify that the implementation task is genuinely compact and capped at 180 seconds per sequential cell, the full matrix is unchanged, and same-caller evaluator-owned Codex state no longer triggers a false producer leak without weakening cell/path/producer-only identity rejection. Reconstruct the exact new run/score/report counts from durable state. On PASS append verdict, archive pair, write `complete.log` with milestone metadata, and move the task directory. On WARN/FAIL follow the code-review skill with one evidence-backed fix packet. + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| TEST-1 Micro fixture/manifest | [x] | +| TEST-2 Same-caller scoring fix | [x] | +| TEST-3 Deterministic regression | [x] | +| TEST-4 One new live run | [x] | +| TEST-5 Scoring/report | [ ] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] [TEST-1] Replace the old seven-section prompt/reference with the compact one-card task, set the execution ceiling to 180 seconds, update fixture version/checksum and exact manifest regression assertions, and prove the full C01-C09 matrix is unchanged. +- [x] [TEST-2] Fix same-caller blind identity classification in `_identity_values` and add focused tests proving evaluator-owned Codex state is allowed only when the producer caller is also Codex while cell/path/producer-only identities still fail closed. +- [x] [TEST-3] Run focused and full deterministic verification, validate the changed manifest, and confirm no test invokes real providers. +- [x] [TEST-4] Run secret-safe live preflight and then exactly one fresh changed-manifest C01-C09 `run`; capture the new run ID and require nine terminal slots with `unresolved=0` without caller resume/retry. +- [ ] [TEST-5] Score the exact new run, use scoring-only retry solely after durable `scoring_failed` and within the three-invocation ceiling, generate the deterministic run report, publish the dated report, and audit identities/counts/links/isolation. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections below with exact evidence. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify this section. + +- [x] Append verdict and verified routing signals. +- [x] Verify every dimension and finding classification. +- [x] Rerun deterministic commands and reconstruct dynamic command/run/score/report counts. +- [x] Confirm shared-caller exemption is limited to the evaluator's own caller and all producer-specific identity guards remain closed. +- [x] Confirm prior runs/testbed/normal subscriptions/protected values were not mutated or exposed. +- [x] Archive plan/review to correctly numbered logs and verify `.gitignore` managed block. +- [ ] On PASS write `complete.log`, preserve/report milestone metadata, move the task directory, and leave no active task files. +- [x] On WARN/FAIL write the required next filesystem state and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +- The shared prompt/reference change invalidated the three tracked example manifests that reuse those inputs. Their fixture version/checksum were synchronized in `agent-comparison-benchmark-manifest.example.json`, `agent-comparison-benchmark-supported-direct.example.json`, and `agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json`; their timeout and matrices were not changed. +- TEST-5 did not complete. Three official score invocations all failed closed with exit 69 before publishing a score result. No durable `scoring_failed` existed, so `--retry-scoring-failed` was never used. The deterministic report consequently returned exit 69 and the dated report was not fabricated. + +## Key Design Decisions + +- The fixture now requires only one compact product card: a small product header, one hero, one primary CTA, both visible local images, and a keyboard-accessible status-detail toggle whose content remains readable without JavaScript. The seven-section landing-page burden was removed. +- `_identity_values` always retains the opaque cell id, attempt path, and producer-only route/model/effort identities. It omits the producer caller exact token only when `cell.caller == manifest.evaluator.caller`; this permits evaluator-owned `.codex`/Codex state without weakening other identity guards. +- Manifest allocation was deferred until focused/full deterministic checks and manifest validation passed. After live `ready=9`, exactly one new run was issued. No caller resume/retry, route/model/effort substitution, run-state edit, second run, or evidence deletion occurred. +- After run allocation, prompt/reference/manifest/scoring source was not changed. All seven failed artifact rows were retained as `unscored`; no zero or selected-success replacement was introduced. +- Spec update not needed: the benchmark lifecycle and public CLI contract remain as documented; this packet changes the benchmark input size and fixes a narrow evaluator-shared identity classification. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Prompt requires only one compact product card, one CTA, two images, and one tiny enhancement; it does not retain the seven-section landing scope. +- `timeout.run_seconds` is exactly 180 and the report calls it a per-cell ceiling, not total nine-cell wall time. +- C01-C09 callers/routes/models/efforts/repetitions and evaluator/rubric remain unchanged. +- A producer caller equal to evaluator caller is excluded only from shared exact caller tokens; cell id, attempt path, and producer-only model/route/effort leaks still fail. +- One new run ID follows the changed manifest and has exactly one attempt per slot, nine terminal web records, no caller retry/resume, and no second new run. +- Score results are durable and report rows retain all failed/unscored outcomes without zero fabrication. + +## Verification Results + +status=BLOCKED — scoring finalization did not publish a durable result within the plan-authorized three score invocations. + +### TEST-1 Micro fixture/manifest + +```text +Changed fixture: +- version=product-card-v2 +- fixture checksum=sha256:fb16198fd4c3576f880f047ed7de54dddc160b0f70c2ba55b435cf078c61828e +- run_seconds=180; idle/quiet/cleanup unchanged at 30/10/5 +- viewports remain desktop_1080 1920x1080 and mobile_375 375x812 +- repetitions=1, seed=bench-02-c01-c09-v1, evaluator/rubric and exact C01-C09 matrix unchanged + +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.manifest_test scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +exit 0; Ran 132 tests in 6.533s; OK + +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit 0; ok: manifest is valid + +Validated manifest digest for the issued run: +sha256:38e48ef35beaa6ecc1aee0460df443e0ccf101a89aa6b91ce1f4b198aa84022a +``` + +### TEST-2 Same-caller scoring fix + +```text +Focused command: +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.manifest_test scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +exit 0; Ran 132 tests in 6.533s; OK + +Regression coverage: +- Codex-produced artifact plus Codex evaluator-owned `.codex/state.txt` containing `Codex evaluator-owned state`: scored, no false leak. +- same-caller `_identity_values.exact_tokens`: only opaque `cell-sentinel`; shared caller `codex` excluded. +- opaque cell id, resolved attempt path, and producer-only `source-route`: still detected. +- existing non-shared `agy` caller integration, delimited/binary caller and cell ids, producer route/model, invalid filesystem bytes, and evaluator-visible tree scans: all retained and passing. +``` + +### TEST-3 Deterministic regression + +```text +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +exit 0; Ran 460 tests in 152.445s; OK + +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit 0; ok: manifest is valid + +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +exit 0; no output + +The deterministic suite ran without the benchmark environment wrapper. Its execution/scoring paths use fake adapters and the repository provider-deny boundary; no real provider command was invoked by these tests. +``` + +### TEST-4 One new live run + +```text +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit 0 in 6.536s +ok: preflight run_id=run-20260813T081317Z-cfa895b54397 status=ready ready=9 registration_required=0 implementation_gap=0 + +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit 0 +ok: run run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c executed=9 unresolved=0 completed=8 timed_out=1 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=3 product_failed=4 product_unknown=2 harness_passed=7 harness_failed=2 process_exited=8 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=1 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=2 artifact_failed=7 artifact_blocked=0 artifact_not_run=0 + +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +exit 0 in 0.497s; counts exactly match the run summary. + +Bounded durable-state audit: +- attempt.json=9, web-validation.json=9, attempt-measurement.json=9 +- C01-C09 each have exactly attempt-000001 +- score-eligible artifacts: C05 and C09; seven other rows retained as unscored +- no resume, caller retry, second changed-manifest run, or retry attempt +``` + +### TEST-5 Scoring/report + +```text +Score invocation 1: +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +exit 69 after about 32s; stderr: error: benchmark scoring is unavailable run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c + +Score invocations 2 and 3 used the same official command without a retry flag. +Both exited 69 in 3.278s and 3.357s with the same sanitized stderr. +No fourth invocation was made. `--retry-scoring-failed` was never used because no durable result.json/status=scoring_failed was published. + +Durable scoring audit after invocation 3: +- unscored.json=7: C01, C02, C03, C04, C06, C07, C08; their exact independent gate reasons are retained. +- C05: score-000001 allocation/input/runner exist; result.json is absent. +- C09: eligible but no score allocation was reached. +- score result.json=0, run-owned report=0. +- Read-only validation of C05 allocation, frozen input digest, runner, identity-visible tree, strict worksheet, cleanup receipt, and lifecycle all passed. The fail-closed boundary is after completed evaluator evidence and before durable result publication; the CLI intentionally suppresses the internal exception. + +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +exit 69; stderr: error: benchmark report is unavailable + +Resume condition: Official review creates or approves a follow-up source fix for interrupted scoring finalization and explicitly authorizes a further score invocation for the preserved run. + +BLOCKED follow-up details: +- Official review must create/approve a follow-up source fix for interrupted live scoring finalization and explicitly authorize any further score invocation beyond this packet's exhausted three-invocation ceiling. +- The follow-up must preserve this exact run and C05 score-000001 bytes, close the interrupted result append-only, retry only after a durable scoring_failed result, score C05/C09 without caller retry, then generate the deterministic run report and dated report. +- Until then, no final C01-C09 comparison or quality ranking is publishable. `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` is intentionally absent rather than fabricated. +``` + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING]** Fill every implementation-owned section and check every completed item. Leave review-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | +|---|---| +| Header, overview, archive snapshot, item names, checkpoints | Fixed at stub creation | +| Implementation statuses, deviations, decisions, verification | Implementing agent | +| Review-only checklist, verdict, archive/finalization | Official review agent | + +## Reviewer Fresh Verification + +```text +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.manifest_test scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +exit 0; Ran 132 tests in 6.347s; OK + +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +exit 0; Ran 460 tests in 150.648s; OK + +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +exit 0; ok: manifest is valid + +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +exit 0; unresolved=0, completed=8, timed_out=1, artifact_passed=2, artifact_failed=7; all other counts match the implementation record. + +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +exit 69; error: benchmark report is unavailable + +Durable-state audit: +- attempt.json=9, web-validation.json=9, attempt-measurement.json=9 +- unscored.json=7, score allocation=1, score result.json=0, run report=0 +- C05 score-000001 has valid allocation/input/runner, successful lifecycle, cleanup receipt, and a valid 94-point worksheet. +- `_identity_values`, frozen input, evaluator-visible identity scan, worksheet, runner, cleanup, lifecycle, and post-tree validation all pass on the retained C05 evidence; `_result_status` is None only because result.json is absent. + +Focused reproduction against the retained blind tree: +`_wait_post_cleanup_quiet(blind_root, lifecycle_validator=...)` +=> ScoringError: evaluator lifecycle publication is incomplete after 2.591s +The blind tree contains 5,378 files, primarily evaluator-owned Codex session/plugin/cache state. +``` + +## Code Review Result + +- **Overall Verdict**: FAIL +- **Dimension Assessment**: + - Correctness: Fail — a successful evaluator lifecycle and worksheet cannot reach durable score publication. + - Completeness: Fail — TEST-5, the run-owned report, and the dated report are absent. + - Test Coverage: Fail — current recovery tests use small blind trees and do not cover a large mutable evaluator session tree. + - API Contract: Fail — the public `score`/`report` lifecycle remains unavailable for the preserved terminal run, contrary to S10/S12. + - Code Quality: Pass — the compact fixture and same-caller identity change are focused and readable. + - Implementation Deviation: Fail — the declared scoring/report deliverable is incomplete, although the deviation was accurately recorded and no evidence was fabricated. + - Verification Trust: Pass — fresh deterministic checks and durable-state reconstruction agree with the implementation record. + - Spec Conformance: Fail — S04-S09 execution evidence exists, but S10 quality scoring and S12 report evidence are not complete. +- **Findings**: + - **Required R1 — Bound lifecycle quiescence to evaluator publication state and finish the preserved run.** + - **Evidence**: `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py:848-905` starts a two-second deadline and recursively snapshots all of `blind_root`; `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py:944-952` uses that scan even when lifecycle and cleanup evidence already exist. The retained C05 blind tree has 5,378 files. A reviewer-run call reproduces `ScoringError: evaluator lifecycle publication is incomplete` after 2.591s, while allocation, input, runner, cleanup, lifecycle, worksheet (94), identity scan, and post-tree checks independently pass. Public report remains exit 69 with zero score results. + - **Root Cause**: `_wait_post_cleanup_quiet` treats evaluator session/cache state as lifecycle-publication state. Traversing the large Codex session/plugin tree consumes the whole deadline before a stable interval can be observed, so `_recover_runner` raises before `_score_one` or `_complete_interrupted` can append `result.json`. + - **Selected Fix**: In `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py`, scope the quiet snapshot to the evaluator-owned `output/` publication surface while preserving strict lifecycle journal/result validation, cleanup-receipt binding, stable-digest revalidation, and socket/alias cleanup. In `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py`, add a deterministic recovery regression that continuously mutates `session/` while a stable published `output/` lifecycle is recovered; require recovery to succeed, retain the existing output-mutation and missing-publication failures, and verify no prior bytes are rewritten. After deterministic tests pass, use the preserved run only: one normal `score` invocation may close C05 score-000001 append-only and score C09; only if C05 becomes durable `scoring_failed`, use one `--retry-scoring-failed` invocation for C05. Then require `scored=2`, `unscored=7`, `scoring_failed=0`, generate the run report and dated report, and do not run/resume callers or allocate another run. +- **Routing Signals**: `review_rework_count=1`, `evidence_integrity_failure=false` +- **Next Step**: Create the mandatory routed follow-up pair from Required R1; do not write `complete.log` or update the Milestone. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_2.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_2.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..154280ff --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_2.log @@ -0,0 +1,216 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - REVIEW_TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST] Filling in this file is the mandatory final step of implementation.** +> Complete the checklist, fill every implementation-owned section, keep active files in place, and report ready for review. +> Execute Required R1 exactly as planned. Do not choose another owner or remedy, ask the user, create stop files, archive logs, write `complete.log`, run/resume callers, or allocate another run. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-13 +task=m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report, plan=2, tag=REVIEW_TEST + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Failed review: `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log`; verdict `FAIL`, Required R1 only, Suggested/Nit none. +- Closed plan: `plan_cloud_G10_1.log`; TEST-1 through TEST-4 passed, TEST-5 incomplete. +- Preserved run: `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c`; nine terminal attempts, seven unscored rows, C05 successful evaluator/94-point worksheet, zero score results and reports. +- Selected fix: bound lifecycle quiet observation to evaluator output publication, raise its fail-closed maximum deadline from 2 seconds to 300 seconds, add session-churn regression, then finish this run through the official score/report CLI only. + +## For the Review Agent + +Verify the output-scoped recovery fix preserves strict lifecycle/receipt/digest cleanup, the new regression proves session churn cannot exhaust publication wait, and all 460+ deterministic tests pass. Reconstruct the preserved run's exact C05/C09 scoring and seven unscored rows, verify no caller attempt/new run/state rewrite, and inspect both reports. Finalization remains code-review-only. + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| REVIEW_TEST-1 Bound lifecycle quiescence | [x] | +| REVIEW_TEST-2 Session-churn regression | [x] | +| REVIEW_TEST-3 Deterministic gate | [x] | +| REVIEW_TEST-4 Preserved scoring closure | [ ] Blocked: C09 retry retained `evaluator_output_leak` | +| REVIEW_TEST-5 Report publication | [ ] Not run after scoring blocker | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-1] Scope lifecycle quiescence to evaluator output publication, set the maximum wait to 300 seconds, and preserve lifecycle/receipt/digest and cleanup fail-closed checks. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-2] Add a deterministic large/mutating-session recovery regression and keep delayed, changed, and missing output cases passing. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-3] Run focused/full deterministic verification and manifest validation before any live score invocation. +- [ ] [REVIEW_TEST-4] On the preserved run only, invoke normal score once; use one retry flag only after durable `scoring_failed`; require C05/C09 scored, seven retained unscored rows, no blocked/failure result, and no caller/run allocation. +- [ ] [REVIEW_TEST-5] Generate the run-owned report, publish `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md`, and audit exact run links, failures, three-minute per-cell/sequential limitation, metrics, scores, and append-only isolation. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify this section. + +- [ ] Append one verdict and verified routing signals. +- [ ] Verify every dimension and finding classification. +- [ ] Run required verification and reconstruct dynamic score/report/run counts. +- [ ] Verify Required R1 resolution map, exact fix, and acceptance commands. +- [ ] Archive active pair to correctly numbered logs and verify `.gitignore` managed block. +- [ ] On PASS write `complete.log`, report milestone metadata, move the task directory, and leave no active files. +- [ ] On WARN/FAIL write the required next filesystem state and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +The planned normal score command durably closed C05 `score-000001` as +`scoring_failed/interrupted` and C09 `score-000001` as +`scoring_failed/evaluator_output_leak`. The conditionally authorized single +`--retry-scoring-failed` invocation then scored C05 as 93 points in +`score-000002`, but C09 `score-000002` again failed with +`evaluator_output_leak`. Per the plan and benchmark skill stop conditions, no +third score attempt, status/report command, manual state edit, caller retry, +or new run was performed. REVIEW_TEST-4 and REVIEW_TEST-5 therefore remain +incomplete. + +Resume condition: a reviewed follow-up must diagnose and resolve the repeated +C09 `evaluator_output_leak` without weakening identity isolation, pass the +deterministic gate, and explicitly authorize a new scoring retry. Only after +the preserved run reaches `scored=2 unscored=7 scoring_failed=0 blocked=0` +may report generation and dated publication proceed. + +Read-only diagnosis after the stopped retry narrowed the blocker further. Both +C09 blind workspaces contain valid worksheets (94 and 95 points), and the +producer identity is absent from the anonymous `input/` and worksheet content. +The post-evaluator whole-tree scan instead finds producer-only tokens in fresh +Codex evaluator-owned `session/.codex` state: `gpt-5.6-terra` occurs in the +bundled OpenAI model reference and the generic effort token `high` occurs in +plugin/cache files. This affects C09 because its GPT hybrid producer binding +differs from the GPT Luna evaluator binding. C05 uses the same caller and an +evaluator-shared direct GPT Luna binding, so those evaluator-owned strings are +not classified as producer-only for C05. + +The follow-up therefore needs a provenance-aware boundary between anonymous +producer evidence and evaluator-owned runtime/session state. It must retain +secret scrubbing and reject producer identity in anonymous inputs, evaluator +prompts, worksheets, and other publication evidence; merely deleting tokens, +dropping identity checks, or exempting all session state is not an acceptable +repair. This diagnosis does not authorize that repair or another score attempt +under the current plan. + +## Key Design Decisions + +- `_POST_CLEANUP_TIMEOUT_SECONDS` is 300 seconds; the existing 0.2-second + quiet interval and 0.01-second poll remain unchanged. +- All three `_recover_runner` quiet waits observe `blind_root / "output"`. + `_wait_post_cleanup_quiet` consequently resolves lifecycle journal/result + relative to that publication root. Lifecycle binding, receipt validation, + final digest comparison, socket cleanup, alias cleanup, input freeze, + identity scan, and post-tree validation were not weakened. +- The regression creates 2,048 evaluator session files and continuously + rewrites another session file while recovery validates stable output. It + asserts recovery completes inside a patched 0.4-second deadline and that + lifecycle journal/result and cleanup receipt bytes are unchanged. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- `_wait_post_cleanup_quiet` observes only the evaluator output publication surface; session/cache churn cannot consume its deadline. +- `_POST_CLEANUP_TIMEOUT_SECONDS` is 300 seconds; stable output still returns after the short quiet interval, while incomplete output fails closed at the deadline. +- Lifecycle journal/result, receipt, final digest, socket/alias cleanup, input freeze, identity scan, and post-tree validation remain strict. +- Existing delayed publication succeeds; changed output and missing publication still fail closed. +- Deterministic tests pass before score continuation. +- C05 score-000001 is closed append-only; C09 is scored; seven prior unscored rows remain unchanged. +- Final state is `scored=2 unscored=7 scoring_failed=0 blocked=0`, with exactly nine caller attempts and one run identity. +- Both reports point only to `run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c` and state per-cell versus sequential timing limitations. + +## Verification Results + +### REVIEW_TEST-1/2 Focused fix and regression + +```text +$ python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +................... +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 19 tests in 5.322s + +OK +exit 0 +``` + +### REVIEW_TEST-3 Deterministic gate + +```text +$ python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 460 tests in 152.724s + +OK +exit 0 + +$ python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +ok: manifest is valid +exit 0 + +$ git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +(no output) +exit 0 +``` + +### REVIEW_TEST-4 Preserved scoring closure + +```text +$ /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +error: benchmark scoring failed run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c scored=0 unscored=7 scoring_failed=2 blocked=0 +exit 69 + +Durable result audit after the normal command: +c05-codex-gpt-direct score-000001 status=scoring_failed reason=interrupted +c09-codex-gpt-hybrid score-000001 status=scoring_failed reason=evaluator_output_leak + +$ /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c --retry-scoring-failed +error: benchmark scoring failed run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c scored=1 unscored=7 scoring_failed=1 blocked=0 +exit 69 + +Final durable result audit: +c05-codex-gpt-direct score-000001 status=scoring_failed reason=interrupted +c05-codex-gpt-direct score-000002 status=scored worksheet.total=93 +c09-codex-gpt-hybrid score-000001 status=scoring_failed reason=evaluator_output_leak +c09-codex-gpt-hybrid score-000002 status=scoring_failed reason=evaluator_output_leak + +Before scoring: RUN_DIRS=25 ATTEMPT_DIRS=9 SCORE_RESULT_FILES=0 +After retry: RUN_DIRS=25 ATTEMPT_DIRS=9 SCORE_DIRS=4 SCORE_RESULT_FILES=4 + +No status command was run after the terminal scoring failure because the +benchmark skill requires stopping after `scoring_failed`. No caller attempt or +run identity was allocated. + +Read-only retained-tree diagnosis (no official CLI call and no state write): + +- both C09 `output/worksheet.json` files are valid and total 94/95; +- `gpt-5.6-terra` matches evaluator-owned + `session/.codex/skills/.system/openai-docs/references/latest-model.md` in + both blind trees; +- the producer effort token `high` matches evaluator-owned plugin/cache files, + including `session/.codex/.tmp/plugins/.git/index`; +- reapplying the current whole-tree identity scanner to the retained C09 blind + roots reproduces `evaluator-visible evidence leaks execution identity`. +``` + +### REVIEW_TEST-5 Reports and isolation + +```text +Not run. The preserved run remained +`scored=1 unscored=7 scoring_failed=1 blocked=0`, so deterministic report +projection and dated publication were prohibited. + +report.md exists: no +agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md exists: no + +Resume only after C09 is durably scored and the closed score summary is +`scored=2 unscored=7 scoring_failed=0 blocked=0`. +``` + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING]** Fill every implementation-owned section and check every completed item. Leave review-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | +|---|---| +| Header, overview, archive snapshot, item names, checkpoints | Fixed at stub creation | +| Implementation statuses, deviations, decisions, verification | Implementing agent | +| Review-only checklist, verdict, archive/finalization | Official review agent | diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_3.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_3.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d810bff7 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/code_review_cloud_G10_3.log @@ -0,0 +1,257 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - REVIEW_TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST]** Implement only the provenance-aware identity boundary in the paired plan, run deterministic gates before the single authorized C09 retry, fill every implementation-owned section, and leave verdict/archive/completion to official review. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-13 +task=m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report, plan=3, tag=REVIEW_TEST + +## Evidence Snapshot + +- Previous pair: `plan_cloud_G10_2.log`, `code_review_cloud_G10_2.log`. +- Preserved run: `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c`. +- Starting state: C05 scored 93, C09 failed identity isolation twice despite valid 94/95 worksheets, seven unscored rows, no report. +- Confirmed false positive: C09 producer model/effort strings occur in fresh evaluator-owned `session/.codex` documentation/cache, not anonymous input or worksheet content. + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| REVIEW_TEST-1 Provenance-aware scan | [x] | +| REVIEW_TEST-2 Regression coverage | [x] | +| REVIEW_TEST-3 Deterministic gate | [x] | +| REVIEW_TEST-4 C09 scoring closure | [x] | +| REVIEW_TEST-5 Report publication | [x] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-1] Exclude only fresh evaluator-owned session state from producer identity scanning; retain input/output/prompt/path checks. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-2] Prove evaluator session tokens pass and the same tokens in producer evidence/output fail. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-3] Pass focused/full tests, manifest validation, and diff hygiene before live score. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-4] Use the one authorized C09 scoring retry and audit final two-scored/seven-unscored state without another run or caller attempt. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-5] Generate run-owned and dated reports with contained links and timing limitations. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned evidence below. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify this section. + +- [x] Append verdict and verified routing signals. +- [x] Re-run deterministic verification and reconstruct score/run/report counts. +- [x] Confirm session exemption is provenance-limited and input/output isolation remains fail-closed. +- [x] Verify no caller retry, new run, evidence rewrite, or protected-value exposure. +- [x] On PASS archive the pair, write `complete.log`, move the task directory, and leave no active task files. +- [ ] On WARN/FAIL create the required follow-up state and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +None. + +## Key Design Decisions + +- Producer identity scanning now visits exactly the frozen anonymous `input/` + and evaluator publication `output/` roots. The controller-created fresh + evaluator `session/` is not producer provenance and is the only excluded + root. +- No identity token, model, effort, `.codex` path, or output-content exemption + was added. Prompt scanning, input materialization/freeze/digest checks, + output path/content and worksheet scans, cell/attempt/binding checks remain + fail-closed. +- Session state remains inside adapter secret scrubbing and the final whole + blind-tree digest. Lifecycle/receipt/digest validation, invalid file-type + handling, cleanup, and post-tree binding are unchanged. + +## Verification Results + +### REVIEW_TEST-1/2 Focused fix + +```text +$ python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +................... +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 19 tests in 5.322s + +OK +exit 0 +``` + +`test_evaluator_session_identity_tokens_are_accepted_but_anonymous_evidence_rejects_them` +proves that producer model/effort strings written by the evaluator under +`session/` are accepted. The same values in anonymous input, an output path, +output content, or worksheet evidence fail closed; input leakage prevents the +evaluator invocation and output leakage records `evaluator_output_leak`. + +### REVIEW_TEST-3 Deterministic gate + +All gates below passed before the authorized scoring retry: + +```text +$ python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 460 tests in 152.724s + +OK +exit 0 + +$ python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +ok: manifest is valid +exit 0 + +$ git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +(no output) +exit 0 +``` + +The deterministic tests did not invoke a live caller or provider. + +After report publication, the final deterministic rerun also passed: + +```text +$ python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 460 tests in 159.711s + +OK +exit 0 + +$ python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +ok: manifest is valid +exit 0 + +$ git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +(no output) +exit 0 +``` + +### REVIEW_TEST-4 Preserved scoring closure + +Exactly one newly authorized scoring retry was invoked; no normal score call, +producer `run`/`resume`, caller retry, or new run was invoked in this plan: + +```text +$ /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c --retry-scoring-failed +ok: score run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c scored=2 unscored=7 scoring_failed=0 blocked=0 +exit 0 + +$ /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +ok: status run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c unresolved=0 completed=8 timed_out=1 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=3 product_failed=4 product_unknown=2 harness_passed=7 harness_failed=2 process_exited=8 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=1 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=2 artifact_failed=7 artifact_blocked=0 artifact_not_run=0 +exit 0 +``` + +Append-only audit: + +- output root run identities: 25 before and after; +- preserved producer attempts: 9 before and after, one per C01-C09 slot; +- pre-retry score directories/results: 4; post-retry: 5; +- C05 terminal score remains `score-000002`, total 93, result digest + `sha256:1bee5f8266078e37dde687d0252b804516d1e7a8285bfdf3a99a11468766c0d5`; +- the only new allocation/result is C09 `score-000003`, total 93, result + digest `sha256:9302104fa76d6592e77e901bcce40f3d5188990cf1b4dbbab54e8dd43735a7c8`; +- prior C09 `score-000001` and `score-000002` failure result digests remain + `sha256:e98fdc6ef72ee34ef8cc09f3e3027a2c530da4d8b2e26f08cd53fcab94f985c3` + and + `sha256:cfd605c5af7ac34d26ff02c8f2ec86fd3ffe5d7d2be8e92907d409280c8fbf1f`; +- producer evidence remains 10,959 files with the same pre/post digest + `sha256:1a68004d9a56818ceaaa8aadca1203f7370728d1223ae178d76ecedf0dffbcf1`; + this producer-only audit excludes append-only scoring/blind/scoring-preflight + state and the derived `report.md`. + +### REVIEW_TEST-5 Reports and isolation + +```text +$ /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +ok: report run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c path=agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/report.md +exit 0 +``` + +- The deterministic report and + `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` both project + the same preserved run and all nine rows. +- Both record C05/C09 as scored 93 and retain seven unscored rows without + assigning zero or rank. +- The dated report lists source-aware per-cell timing and caller-reported + usage, leaves unavailable metrics unavailable, and states that 180 seconds + is a per-cell ceiling while the nine cells execute sequentially. +- Every dated-report raw link resolves under + `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/`; no link points + to a different run, external path, credential, or evaluator identity map. +- Link/count audit passed with 43 contained existing links, nine result rows, + two scored rows, and seven unscored rows. + +### Reviewer Fresh Verification + +The official reviewer independently reran every safe required route. The +single authorized live scoring retry had already been consumed successfully, +so it was not invoked again. + +```text +$ python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +................... +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 19 tests in 5.986s + +OK +exit 0 + +$ python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +---------------------------------------------------------------------- +Ran 460 tests in 156.203s + +OK +exit 0 + +$ python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +ok: manifest is valid +exit 0 + +$ /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +ok: status run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c unresolved=0 completed=8 timed_out=1 cancelled=0 interrupted=0 running=0 product_succeeded=3 product_failed=4 product_unknown=2 harness_passed=7 harness_failed=2 process_exited=8 process_signalled=0 process_timed_out=1 process_cancelled=0 process_not_started=0 artifact_passed=2 artifact_failed=7 artifact_blocked=0 artifact_not_run=0 +exit 0 + +$ /bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +ok: report run_id=run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c path=agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/report.md +exit 0 + +$ git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +(no output) +exit 0 +``` + +Reviewer reconstruction confirmed nine producer attempts, 25 pre-existing +run identities before and after review, five append-only score results, C05 +and C09 terminal totals of 93, seven terminal unscored rows, and 43/43 dated +report links resolving inside the preserved run. The producer projection has +10,959 regular-file/symlink records under the recorded boundary. C05 +`score-000002` and C09 `score-000001..000003` result SHA-256 values match the +implementation record. No caller, provider, score retry, resume, or new run +was invoked by the reviewer. + +--- + +## Code Review Result + +- **Overall Verdict**: PASS +- **Dimension Assessment**: + - Correctness: Pass — producer identity scanning remains fail-closed for anonymous input and evaluator output while excluding only controller-created evaluator session provenance. + - Completeness: Pass — every planned code, test, preserved scoring, and report deliverable is present and independently reconstructable. + - Test Coverage: Pass — the focused regression covers session acceptance and input/output rejection, and all 460 benchmark tests pass. + - API Contract: Pass — public validate/status/report commands succeed on the preserved run and append-only score semantics remain intact. + - Code Quality: Pass — the change is localized, documented at the provenance boundary, and contains no debug or unfinished code. + - Implementation Deviation: Pass — no unplanned behavioral deviation or unrelated current-packet change was found. + - Verification Trust: Pass — fresh reviewer commands, score-result digests, counts, and contained links agree with the implementation record. + - Spec Conformance: Pass — S04-S12 evidence is represented by the nine terminal attempts, uniform validation, two blind scores, source-aware timing/usage, and the dated report. +- **Findings**: None +- **Routing Signals**: `review_rework_count=1`, `evidence_integrity_failure=false` +- **Next Step**: Archive the PASS pair, write `complete.log`, move the split task directory, and emit Milestone completion-event metadata without modifying the roadmap. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | +|---|---| +| Header, item names, review checklist | Fixed at stub creation | +| Implementation statuses, deviations, decisions, verification | Implementing agent | +| Verdict, archive, completion | Official review agent | diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/complete.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/complete.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ccd69a1d --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/complete.log @@ -0,0 +1,44 @@ + + +# Complete - m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report + +## 완료 일시 + +2026-08-13 + +## 요약 + +4개 Plan/Review 루프를 거쳐 보존 C01-C09 run의 provenance-aware 익명 채점과 날짜별 비교 보고서를 완료했으며 최종 판정은 PASS다. + +## 루프 이력 + +| Plan | Review | Verdict | 메모 | +|------|--------|---------|------| +| `plan_cloud_G09_0.log` | `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log` | 대체됨 | 초기 큰 fixture 실행은 사용자 요청으로 compact fixture 계획에 대체되었고 진단 evidence만 보존했다. | +| `plan_cloud_G10_1.log` | `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log` | FAIL | evaluator session 규모가 lifecycle publication quiet wait를 소진하는 Required R1을 확인했다. | +| `plan_cloud_G10_2.log` | `code_review_cloud_G10_2.log` | 후속 필요 | lifecycle recovery는 복구했으나 C09 evaluator-owned session의 producer token false positive를 확인했다. | +| `plan_cloud_G10_3.log` | `code_review_cloud_G10_3.log` | PASS | provenance-aware identity boundary, 19/19 집중 테스트, 460/460 전체 테스트, 2 scored/7 unscored 및 보고서를 검증했다. | + +## 구현/정리 내용 + +- producer identity 검사를 frozen anonymous `input/`과 evaluator publication `output/`에 한정하고 fresh evaluator-owned `session/`은 provenance 검사에서 분리했다. +- input/output identity leakage, prompt/path/cell/attempt binding, secret scrubbing, lifecycle/receipt/digest, input freeze와 append-only score 경계를 유지했다. +- 보존 run `run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c`을 C05/C09 각 93점, 나머지 7개 unscored로 닫고 run-owned 및 `agent-test/dev/` 날짜별 보고서를 생성했다. + +## 최종 검증 + +- `python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test` - PASS; 19 tests. +- `python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py'` - PASS; 460 tests. +- `python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json` - PASS; manifest valid. +- `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c` - PASS; unresolved=0, attempts=9, artifact_passed=2, artifact_failed=7. +- `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c` - PASS; deterministic run report regenerated. +- `git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**'` - PASS; no output. +- report/count/digest audit - PASS; 9 result rows, 2 scored, 7 unscored, 43/43 contained links, 25 run identities, and recorded score-result digests matched. + +## 잔여 Nit + +- 없음 + +## 후속 작업 + +- 없음 diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G09_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G09_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..dac3b8ec --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G09_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,184 @@ + + +# Execute, score, and publish the final C01-C09 benchmark + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Wait for predecessor 14 to archive PASS, then execute this packet through the deterministic benchmark CLI. The user approved uninterrupted work through final benchmark completion and explicitly requested dispatcher task-loop execution. This authorizes exactly one new scored C01-C09 `run` identity with repetitions=1. It does not authorize caller-attempt retry, `resume`, `--retry-failed`, a second scored run, ad-hoc caller/provider/evaluator calls, model/route/effort substitution, manual run-state edits, deletion of evidence, or success-only selection. Scoring-only failures may use the public `--retry-scoring-failed` path for at most three total score invocations per affected run; every score attempt remains append-only. Fill the paired review evidence and leave finalization to official review. + +## Background + +Task 13 preserved a terminal direct run but never allocated C01-C09 because the former gate demanded all four direct axes 5/5. Task 14 repairs measurement/runtime compatibility, deploys the exact source, and replaces that gate with terminal-evidence admission. This packet consumes that qualified environment once, preserves all nine outcomes whether successful, failed, or timed out, blindly scores only eligible artifacts, and publishes the dated comparison report. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Required predecessor: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log`. It does not yet exist at plan creation; the dispatcher must keep this packet dependency-waiting until it does. +- Predecessor 13: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/13+12_scored_benchmark_result/complete.log` and its exact direct run remain immutable historical evidence. +- All existing `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-*` roots are prior attempts. The result for this packet must be a distinct run ID issued by its one `run` command. +- `/tmp/iop-bench-13-env` is the approved benchmark-only environment wrapper and must be invoked with `/bin/bash`; never print its environment or protected files. + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark/SKILL.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md` +- `agent-spec/testing/agent-comparison-benchmark.md` +- `agent-test/local/rules.md` +- `agent-test/dev/rules.md` +- `docs/agent-comparison-benchmark-dev-guide.md` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json` +- `scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/reporting.py` +- predecessor 13's directly linked completion/plan/review evidence + +### SDD Criteria + +- D06: one new run ID, repetitions=1, clean workspace and fresh caller session for every cell. +- D10: retain all failure/timeout evidence and never replace it with another run. A score retry is a separate evaluator attempt, not a caller rerun. +- S04-S11: the same run ID must connect lifecycle, workspace, web validation, timing/usage, blind score status, and report rows. +- S12: publish a dated Markdown report with conditions, versions, failures, limitations, and contained raw-evidence links. + +### Verification Context + +- Live admission requires predecessor 14's exact released source, `ready=5` direct qualification, terminal five-slot evidence, no exhausted browser/CDP infrastructure block, 4/4 connected Nodes, and healthy/available provider snapshots. +- C01-C09 preflight must return `ready=9` before attempt allocation. Preflight is not a scored attempt. +- The immutable manifest checksum, order seed, timeout, evaluator, rubric, fixture, route/model/effort, and repetitions must not change. +- The one `run` command succeeds operationally when all nine slots have complete terminal evidence (`unresolved=0`), even if product/harness/process/artifact axes contain failures. Those rows become `unscored` where ineligible. +- Score invocation 1 is normal. Only an explicit `scoring_failed` result permits invocations 2 and 3 with `--retry-scoring-failed`; stop after the third unresolved scoring failure for official review. Never retry an `unscored` product result. +- Confidence is high in state/report determinism after task 12/14; live model quality and timing are deliberately unknown benchmark outputs. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- Deterministic tests cannot replace nine live caller observations or fresh blind evaluation. +- The reviewer must validate the run tree structure, contained pointers, anonymous score inputs, and exact report projection, not merely trust CLI exit codes. + +### Symbol References + +None; this packet is execution/evidence publication and must not change benchmark implementation. + +### Split Judgment + +This task is indivisible after admission: one run ID must flow through status, scoring, report, and dated publication. It is split from packet 14 because source deployment/qualification must complete before the single scored allocation. Directory dependency `15+14` is authoritative. + +### Scope Rationale + +- Include only deterministic tests/preflight, one C01-C09 run, status, bounded scoring retry, run-owned report, evidence audit, and dated publication. +- Exclude product/runtime/harness source, manifests, fixtures, rubric, route configuration, credentials, normal caller configuration, old runs, and any second scored cycle. +- The dispatcher schedules/monitors because the user explicitly requested it; it is not a caller continuation path. All caller and evaluator work remains CLI-owned. + +### Final Routing + +- `evaluation_mode=first-pass`; finalizer `pair` route already selected build `cloud/G09` and review `cloud/G09` with `plan=0`. +- Loop risks are temporal external state, expensive single-run identity, variant products, and scoring availability. Official review must reconstruct counts from durable evidence. + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] [TEST-1] Verify predecessor 14 PASS, exact released runtime/source identity, immutable manifests, protected-file modes, caller versions, 4/4 Nodes, provider health, and `ready=9` without exposing secrets. +- [ ] [TEST-2] Invoke exactly one fresh C01-C09 `run`, capture its issued ID, and require nine complete terminal slots with `unresolved=0`; preserve every product/harness/process/artifact outcome without resume or caller retry. +- [ ] [TEST-3] Query status for that exact run and score eligible artifacts blindly; use `--retry-scoring-failed` only when required and at most three total score invocations, preserving every score attempt. +- [ ] [TEST-4] Generate the deterministic run-owned report, audit identities/counts/timing/usage/links/isolation, and publish `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` with prior-run relationship, failures, limitations, and raw evidence pointers. +- [ ] [TEST-5] Rerun deterministic verification and prove old runs, testbed, normal caller subscriptions, credentials, manifests, and released runtime were not mutated by benchmark execution. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +### [TEST-1] Final admission + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md`: record predecessor/source/runtime/preflight identities and secret-safe output. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +``` + +Expected: deterministic tests pass, manifest is unchanged/valid, runtime identity matches predecessor 14, and preflight reports `ready=9`. + +### [TEST-2] Single scored execution + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md`: record the single command, exit, issued ID, and all terminal axes. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +``` + +Expected: exactly one new run ID, nine attempt slots and web validations, `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`. Independent failures remain retained results and do not allocate another run. + +### [TEST-3] Status and blind scoring + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md`: record exact dynamic commands, exits, score IDs/counts, eligibility, and retry count. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +``` + +On explicit `scoring_failed` only, repeat `score` with `--retry-scoring-failed` no more than twice. Expected: every cell is closed as `scored` or `unscored`, `scoring_failed=0`, and no identity leaks into blind evaluator inputs. + +### [TEST-4] Reports and evidence audit + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md`: publish exact conditions/outcomes/metrics/scores/failures/limitations and contained raw links for the issued run. +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md`: record report command/output, run-tree audit, and protected-value hit count only. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +``` + +Expected: `agent-test/runs/bench-02//report.md` is deterministic; the dated report cites that same ID, distinguishes unscored from zero, labels unavailable metrics, and includes prior-failure relationship/limitations. + +### [TEST-5] Final integrity + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md`: record fresh test output and immutable/isolation audit. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Expected: deterministic checks pass; only the dated report and active task evidence are intentional post-release changes; old runs/testbed/subscription/credentials/manifests/runtime are unchanged. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` | TEST-4 | +| `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md` | TEST-1, TEST-2, TEST-3, TEST-4, TEST-5 | + +## Dependencies and Execution Order + +- Wait for `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log`; the active predecessor does not satisfy the dependency. +- Execute TEST-1 → TEST-2 → TEST-3 → TEST-4 → TEST-5. No later step may change the issued run ID. + +## Final Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Expected: exact run has nine terminal slots and closed scoring states, both reports point to it, no second run/caller retry exists, and isolation audits pass. After completing all code changes, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md`. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_1.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_1.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f36be23a --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_1.log @@ -0,0 +1,191 @@ + + +# Rebase the final benchmark on a three-minute micro implementation + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Replace the oversized landing-page fixture with a compact implementation task sized for roughly three minutes per execution cell, fix the confirmed same-caller blind-scoring false positive, and then produce the final C01-C09 result through the deterministic CLI. Fill every implementation-owned section in the paired review and leave finalization to official review. If blocked, record only exact evidence and the resume condition; do not ask the user, create control-plane stop files, archive the pair, or write `complete.log`. + +The user explicitly replaced plan 0 while it was running. This plan authorizes exactly one new `run` identity after the changed manifest validates and preflight is `ready=9`. Do not resume or retry caller attempts, allocate a second run, substitute caller/route/model/effort, edit run state, delete prior evidence, or select only successful results. A durable `scoring_failed` result alone may use `--retry-scoring-failed`, with at most three total score invocations for the affected run. + +## Background + +Plan 0's fixture asked every cell to build seven page sections, two-image composition, navigation, responsive behavior, accessibility, and JavaScript under a 300-second execution limit. The harness executes the nine C01-C09 slots sequentially, so that definition was not a three-minute benchmark and produced a 20-minute-class run. + +The interrupted worker preserved `run-20260813T071816Z-755d136c3e2b` with nine terminal slots and no caller retry. One eligible artifact reached a valid evaluator worksheet with total 92, but the controller could not publish a durable score result. Read-only diagnosis proved 5,370 identity-scan hits when the producer and evaluator were both Codex and zero hits when the evaluator-shared caller token `codex` was excluded. The scan correctly exempts shared evaluator route/model/effort already, but not the shared caller name. Plan 0 is diagnostic evidence only and must not be reported as the final comparison. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Superseded pair: `plan_cloud_G09_0.log` and `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log` in this task directory. It authorized and consumed one old-manifest run before the user changed scope. +- Preserved diagnostic run: `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T071816Z-755d136c3e2b`. It is immutable and must not be scored, resumed, reported, deleted, or presented as the final result. +- Required predecessor PASS: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log`. +- `/tmp/iop-bench-13-env` remains the approved benchmark-only environment wrapper and must be invoked with `/bin/bash`; never print its environment or protected values. + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `agent-ops/rules/project/domain/testing/rules.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/project/iop-agent-comparison-benchmark/SKILL.md` +- `agent-test/local/rules.md` +- `agent-test/local/testing-smoke.md` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest_test.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` + +### Acceptance and Design + +- Keep the complete C01-C09 matrix, repetitions=1, fresh sessions, isolated workspaces, two viewports, two local images, evaluator, rubric, and append-only evidence policy. +- Reduce only the implementation workload: one compact responsive product card composed of a small header, one hero area, one CTA, both visible local images, and one tiny progressive-enhancement toggle. Keep exactly `index.html`, `styles.css`, and `script.js`; remove the old feature/workflow/testimonial/pricing/footer-section burden. +- Set `timeout.run_seconds=180`. This is a per-cell execution ceiling. Because `run_slots` is intentionally sequential, do not claim the complete nine-cell wall clock is three minutes and do not add parallel scheduling in this packet. +- Change fixture version and checksum-bound reference content so new runs cannot be opened with the superseded manifest digest. Preserve the existing fixture directory and assets instead of creating a new benchmark tree. +- Treat a producer caller token as evaluator-shared when `cell.caller == manifest.evaluator.caller`, just as shared evaluator route/model/effort tokens are already exempt. The opaque cell id, producer-only routes/models/efforts, and attempt path remain prohibited everywhere in evaluator-visible evidence. +- Add a focused regression proving `.codex`/Codex evaluator-owned state is accepted for a Codex-produced artifact while the opaque producer cell id still fails closed. + +### SDD Criteria + +- D06/D10: every new slot has one fresh session and one attempt; old and failed evidence is retained without retry. +- S04-S11: the same new run ID connects lifecycle, workspace, web gates, timing/usage, blind score, and report rows. +- S12: publish a dated report with conditions, failures, limitations, and contained raw links; state the sequential nine-cell timing limitation. + +### Test Coverage + +- `manifest_test.py` locks the tracked manifest's timeout, fixture version/content mapping, checksum, viewports, matrix, and deterministic order. +- `scoring_test.py` already covers producer caller/cell leaks, evaluator-shared route/model bindings, raw filenames, append-only scoring retries, and strict worksheet publication. Add the missing same-caller case. +- The full `scripts/agent_benchmark` suite covers workspace materialization, browser/CDP gates, adapters, lifecycle, measurement, reporting, and CLI integration. + +### Symbol References + +- `_identity_values` is consumed by blind path/input/prompt and evaluator-visible tree scans inside `scoring.py`; its exact-token change must preserve all non-shared caller behavior. +- The tracked manifest constants are asserted directly in `ManifestValidationTest.test_iop_one_shot_manifest_locks_benchmark_readiness`. + +### Split Judgment + +Keep one atomic packet. Fixture duration, manifest digest/tests, scoring identity semantics, and the one final live run must agree before any result is publishable; splitting would allow an invalid intermediate benchmark contract or another wasted live run. + +### Routing Signals + +- `evaluation_mode=isolated-reassessment` +- Closures are true for build and review; `evidence_integrity_failure=true` because plan 0 produced a worksheet without a durable terminal score result. +- Positive loop risks: `temporal_state`, `boundary_contract`, `variant_product`; `large_indivisible_context=false`, `review_rework_count=0`. +- Finalizer output: build `cloud/G10`, review `cloud/G10`, files `PLAN-cloud-G10.md` and `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`. + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] [TEST-1] Replace the old seven-section prompt/reference with the compact one-card task, set the execution ceiling to 180 seconds, update fixture version/checksum and exact manifest regression assertions, and prove the full C01-C09 matrix is unchanged. +- [ ] [TEST-2] Fix same-caller blind identity classification in `_identity_values` and add focused tests proving evaluator-owned Codex state is allowed only when the producer caller is also Codex while cell/path/producer-only identities still fail closed. +- [ ] [TEST-3] Run focused and full deterministic verification, validate the changed manifest, and confirm no test invokes real providers. +- [ ] [TEST-4] Run secret-safe live preflight and then exactly one fresh changed-manifest C01-C09 `run`; capture the new run ID and require nine terminal slots with `unresolved=0` without caller resume/retry. +- [ ] [TEST-5] Score the exact new run, use scoring-only retry solely after durable `scoring_failed` and within the three-invocation ceiling, generate the deterministic run report, publish the dated report, and audit identities/counts/links/isolation. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` with exact commands, exits, bounded outputs, changed files, new run/score/report identities, omissions, and remaining risks. + +### [TEST-1] Three-minute micro fixture + +#### Modified Files + +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest_test.py` + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.manifest_test +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +``` + +Expected: manifest is valid, `run_seconds=180`, fixture version/content/checksum match, and exact C01-C09 cells/routes remain unchanged. + +### [TEST-2] Same-caller blind scoring + +#### Modified Files + +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +``` + +Expected: shared Codex caller state does not create a false leak; non-shared callers, cell IDs, producer-only bindings, paths, and binary/raw filename cases still fail closed. + +### [TEST-3] Deterministic regression + +#### Modified Files + +- `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +``` + +Expected: all deterministic tests pass without external model/provider invocation and the worktree patch is clean. + +### [TEST-4] One new live run + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py preflight --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py run --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +``` + +Expected: preflight `ready=9`; exactly one new run ID; nine retained terminal slots; `unresolved=0`, `running=0`, `interrupted=0`. Product/artifact failures remain valid measured outcomes. + +### [TEST-5] Scoring and report + +#### Modified Files + +- `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` +- `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +``` + +Expected: every slot is `scored` or `unscored`, `scoring_failed=0`, report links stay inside the new run, failed rows are retained, and the dated report explicitly distinguishes the three-minute per-cell task ceiling from total sequential matrix wall time. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md` | TEST-1 | +| `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json` | TEST-1 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest_test.py` | TEST-1 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py` | TEST-2 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` | TEST-5 | +| `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` | TEST-1..5 | + +## Dependencies and Execution Order + +- Predecessor 14 PASS is already archived at the exact path above. +- Execute TEST-1 → TEST-2 → TEST-3 before any live allocation, then TEST-4 → TEST-5 using only the new run ID. +- Do not change prompt/reference/manifest/scoring source after allocating the new run. Any pre-run failure is fixed and revalidated; any post-allocation caller failure is retained without a second run. + +## Final Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Expected: deterministic checks pass; the new manifest is immutable and valid; the exact new run is terminal with closed scoring/report evidence; the diagnostic run and testbed remain unchanged. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_2.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_2.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7325d416 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_2.log @@ -0,0 +1,282 @@ + + +# Bound scoring quiescence and finish the preserved benchmark report + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Implement Required R1 exactly as selected below, run every deterministic check before any live score command, then close scoring and reporting on the preserved run only. Fill all implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`, keep both active files in place, and report ready for review. If blocked, record exact commands, output, and the resume condition only; do not ask the user, create stop files, classify next state, archive logs, write `complete.log`, run/resume callers, or allocate another run. + +## Background + +The compact fixture and same-caller identity change pass all 460 deterministic benchmark tests, and run `run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c` has nine terminal slots. C05 also has a successful evaluator lifecycle and valid 94-point worksheet, but scoring finalization scans 5,378 evaluator-visible files under a two-second deadline and exits before appending `result.json`. Fix that bounded publication wait, preserve every existing byte, finish C05/C09 scoring, and publish the deterministic and dated reports. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Failed review: `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log`; verdict `FAIL`, Required R1 only, Suggested/Nit none. +- Closed plan: `plan_cloud_G10_1.log`; TEST-1 through TEST-4 passed, TEST-5 scoring/report remained incomplete. +- Earlier diagnostic pair: `plan_cloud_G09_0.log`, `code_review_cloud_G09_0.log`. +- Preserved final run: `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c`; nine terminal attempts, seven `unscored.json`, C05 `score-000001` allocation/input/runner/success lifecycle/94-point worksheet, zero score results, zero reports. +- Predecessor 14 PASS: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/complete.log`. + +## Finding Resolution Map + +| Finding | Reviewer evidence | Root cause | Selected fix | Mode | Changed precondition | Acceptance commands | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| Required R1 | `_wait_post_cleanup_quiet` on the retained 5,378-file blind tree raises `evaluator lifecycle publication is incomplete` after 2.591s while allocation, input, runner, receipt, lifecycle, worksheet, identity scan, and post-tree checks pass. | `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py:848-905` snapshots all of `blind_root`; evaluator session/plugin/cache traversal consumes the fixed deadline before `_recover_runner` can return and append a score result. | Scope the quiet snapshot to the evaluator `output/` publication surface, raise the bounded maximum wait from 2 seconds to 300 seconds, retain strict lifecycle/receipt/stable-digest checks and cleanup, add a large/mutating-session recovery regression, then finish only the preserved run and publish both reports. | `direct-fix` | The recovery oracle no longer depends on unrelated evaluator session tree size or churn; normal stable output returns immediately after the quiet interval, while incomplete publication remains fail-closed after at most 300 seconds. | `python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test`; full benchmark suite; manifest validation; preserved-run score/status/report commands; final artifact audit. | + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/live_iop.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/reporting.py` +- `scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py` +- `scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json` +- `agent-spec/testing/agent-comparison-benchmark.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md` +- `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log` +- `plan_cloud_G10_1.log` + +### SDD Criteria + +- SDD: `agent-roadmap/sdd/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/SDD.md`, `[승인됨]`, 잠금 해제. +- Milestone tasks: `claude-standalone`, `gemini-standalone`, `gpt-standalone`, `gemini-hybrid`, `gpt-hybrid`, `objective-validation`, `quality-scoring`, `performance-usage`, `benchmark-report`. +- Target scenarios/evidence: S04-S09 retain the exact nine terminal execution and web evidence; S10 requires blind Codex rubric results without identity leakage; S11 requires run-bound timing/usage; S12 requires the dated report and contained raw links. +- The checklist therefore forbids caller rerun and run replacement, requires append-only closure of existing C05 scoring before C09 allocation, and makes successful score/report projection the final oracle. + +### Verification Context + +- Handoff source: `code_review_cloud_G10_1.log` with reviewer-run 132-test and 460-test passes, manifest validation, exact status, report exit 69, and read-only durable-state diagnostics. +- Local rules: deterministic unit/integration tests run without provider environment; live benchmark operations use `/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env` without printing protected values. +- External verification preflight: current repo `/config/workspace/iop-s0`, branch `feature/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison`, preserved dirty implementation patch, Python 3.12.3 through the wrapper, exact manifest/run identity fixed above. The wrapper is a Bash script and is invoked through `/bin/bash`; executable mode is not required. +- Constraints: no caller `run`/`resume`, no new run, no state edit, no deletion, no route/model/effort substitution. Score invocation 1 must be normal so `_complete_interrupted` can append the existing C05 result; one `--retry-scoring-failed` invocation is allowed only if that invocation durably publishes C05 `scoring_failed`. +- Confidence: high. The failure reproduces from retained bytes and the selected fix has a deterministic regression boundary. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- Existing `test_receipt_only_recovery_waits_for_lifecycle_quiescence` covers delayed, changed, and missing lifecycle output on small trees, but not large or continuously changing evaluator session state. +- Add one regression under `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` that churns `session/` while stable lifecycle output is recovered; it must fail before the fix and pass after it. +- Existing full suite covers scoring retry, append-only evidence, input mutation, identity leakage, report projection, and live adapter boundaries. + +### Symbol References + +- No public or removed symbol. +- `_wait_post_cleanup_quiet` callers: `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py:944`, `:962`, `:997`. Preserve the helper signature unless an internal publication-root parameter is required; update all three call sites and tests together. + +### Split Judgment + +Keep one packet. Recovery semantics, retained score closure, and report publication form one append-only invariant: a source fix is not independently complete until the preserved run projects a terminal score/report, while live scoring must not run before the deterministic fix passes. + +### Scope Rationale + +- Include only `scoring.py`, its regression test, the dated report, and active review evidence. +- Exclude fixture/manifest/scoring identity semantics already verified, caller adapters, runtime deployment, credentials, old runs, existing run bytes, and roadmap files. +- Do not modify `agent-test/runs/**`; official CLI operations alone may append evidence under the preserved run. + +### Final Routing + +- `evaluation_mode=isolated-reassessment`; `finalizer=finalize-task-policy.sh`, mode `pair`. +- Closures: build/review scope, context, verification, evidence, ownership, and decisions all true; no capability gap. +- Build scores `2+2+2+2+2=G10`, `grade-boundary`, `cloud`, `PLAN-cloud-G10.md`. +- Review scores `2+2+2+2+2=G10`, `official-review`, `cloud`, `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`. +- `large_indivisible_context=false`; positive risks: `temporal_state`, `boundary_contract`, `variant_product` (3). +- `review_rework_count=1`, `evidence_integrity_failure=false`; no recovery-boundary override. + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] [REVIEW_TEST-1] Scope lifecycle quiescence to evaluator output publication, set the bounded maximum wait to 300 seconds, and preserve lifecycle/receipt/digest and cleanup fail-closed checks. +- [ ] [REVIEW_TEST-2] Add a deterministic large/mutating-session recovery regression and keep delayed, changed, and missing output cases passing. +- [ ] [REVIEW_TEST-3] Run focused/full deterministic verification and manifest validation before any live score invocation. +- [ ] [REVIEW_TEST-4] On the preserved run only, invoke normal score once; use one retry flag only after durable `scoring_failed`; require C05/C09 scored, seven retained unscored rows, no blocked/failure result, and no caller/run allocation. +- [ ] [REVIEW_TEST-5] Generate the run-owned report, publish `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md`, and audit exact run links, failures, three-minute per-cell/sequential limitation, metrics, scores, and append-only isolation. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +### [REVIEW_TEST-1] Bound lifecycle publication quiescence + +#### Problem + +`scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py:848-905` recursively snapshots the entire blind tree on every poll. `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py:944-952` passes `blind_root`, so a 5,378-file Codex session tree consumes the two-second publication deadline despite already stable `output/lifecycle-journal.jsonl`, `output/lifecycle-result.json`, and cleanup receipt. + +#### Solution + +Before (`scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py:944-952`): + +```python +stable_lifecycle = _wait_post_cleanup_quiet( + blind_root, + lifecycle_validator=lambda: _validate_lifecycle_binding(...), +) +``` + +After: + +```python +stable_lifecycle = _wait_post_cleanup_quiet( + blind_root / "output", + lifecycle_validator=lambda: _validate_lifecycle_binding(...), +) +``` + +Apply the same publication-root rule at all three recovery call sites. Do not weaken `_validate_lifecycle_binding`, cleanup receipt validation, final digest comparison, socket cleanup, alias cleanup, input freezing, identity scanning, or post-tree digest validation. + +Set `_POST_CLEANUP_TIMEOUT_SECONDS = 300.0`. This is a maximum deadline, not a mandatory delay: stable publication still returns after the existing quiet interval. If publication never becomes valid or stable, recovery must fail closed when the 300-second deadline expires. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py`: use bounded evaluator output publication roots at all recovery waits and set the maximum publication deadline to 300 seconds. + +#### Test Strategy + +Regression required in REVIEW_TEST-2; no new public API test is needed. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +``` + +Expected: all scoring tests pass without a provider invocation. + +### [REVIEW_TEST-2] Lock large-session recovery behavior + +#### Problem + +`scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py:1227-1622` validates lifecycle publication and recovery only with small `session/` trees, so unrelated session churn can regress the output publication boundary undetected. + +#### Solution + +Extend `test_receipt_only_recovery_waits_for_lifecycle_quiescence` or add a focused sibling test. Create a stable, valid output lifecycle/receipt and a bounded background writer that repeatedly changes files under `session/`; call `_recover_runner`, require it to return valid lifecycle/receipt digests within the patched timeout, stop/join the writer, and prove existing evidence bytes remain unchanged. Retain the existing test cases that reject changed lifecycle output and missing publication. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py`: add deterministic session-churn recovery regression and append-only assertions. + +#### Test Strategy + +Write the regression above. Use local files/threading only; no real provider, network, or benchmark CLI call. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +``` + +Expected: the new regression and all existing scoring tests pass. + +### [REVIEW_TEST-3] Deterministic gate before live continuation + +#### Problem + +The preserved run is expensive append-only state. A live score continuation before validating the fix could leave another interrupted score allocation. + +#### Solution + +Run focused and full tests, manifest validation, and diff hygiene first. If any fails, stop without score invocation and record the failure. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`: record exact commands, exits, and bounded output. + +#### Test Strategy + +Use fresh unittest execution; unittest does not reuse cached results. + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +``` + +Expected: all commands exit 0, 460 or more benchmark tests pass, and no external provider is invoked by tests. + +### [REVIEW_TEST-4] Close preserved scoring append-only + +#### Problem + +C05 `score-000001` lacks `result.json`, C09 has no allocation, and seven ineligible rows are correctly retained as unscored. + +#### Solution + +After REVIEW_TEST-3 passes, run the normal public score command exactly once. It must recover and append the existing C05 result without allocating `score-000002`, then score C09. If and only if it durably publishes C05 as `scoring_failed`, run one explicit `--retry-scoring-failed`; otherwise do not use the flag. Never run/resume callers or create a new run. Require final `scored=2 unscored=7 scoring_failed=0 blocked=0`. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`: record exact score commands, exits, counts, C05/C09 score ids, and append-only audit. + +#### Test Strategy + +Use the official public CLI only; no ad-hoc evaluator or manual state write. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +``` + +Expected: score exits 0 with `scored=2 unscored=7 scoring_failed=0 blocked=0`; status retains nine one-attempt terminal slots and `unresolved=0`. + +### [REVIEW_TEST-5] Publish and audit reports + +#### Problem + +No run-owned `report.md` or dated comparison report exists, so S12 and the Milestone report tasks are incomplete. + +#### Solution + +Generate the deterministic report through the public CLI. Publish the exact run projection to `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md`, including conditions/version, all nine rows, two scores and seven unscored reasons, timing/usage sources, failures, unavailable values, the 180-second per-cell versus sequential total limitation, previous diagnostic-run relationship, and contained raw links. Do not invent zeros or ranks for unscored rows. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md`: publish the final dated comparison. +- [ ] `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md`: record report output/path and contained-link/isolation audit. + +#### Test Strategy + +Use deterministic report generation and bounded path/count audits; no new report unit test is needed because production reporting behavior is unchanged. + +#### Verification + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +test -f agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/report.md +test -f agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md +rg --sort path -n 'run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c|per-cell|sequential|unscored|scored' agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md +``` + +Expected: report exits 0, both files exist, and the dated report uses only the preserved run's contained evidence. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py` | REVIEW_TEST-1 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` | REVIEW_TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` | REVIEW_TEST-5 | +| `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` | REVIEW_TEST-3..5 | + +## Dependencies and Execution Order + +Execute REVIEW_TEST-1 → REVIEW_TEST-2 → REVIEW_TEST-3. Only after all deterministic gates pass may REVIEW_TEST-4 invoke scoring; only after scoring closes may REVIEW_TEST-5 publish reports. + +## Final Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Expected: deterministic tests and validation pass; status remains nine terminal one-attempt slots; scoring is two scored/seven unscored with no failure/block; run-owned and dated reports exist; no second run or caller retry exists; all changes stay within the declared write boundary. + +After completing all code changes, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md`. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_3.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_3.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..fc59031b --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/plan_cloud_G10_3.log @@ -0,0 +1,104 @@ + + +# Separate evaluator-owned session state from anonymous scoring evidence + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Fix only the confirmed C09 false positive, run every deterministic gate before live scoring, then continue the preserved run through the official CLI. Do not run or resume producer callers, allocate another run, edit/delete prior evidence, weaken input/prompt/output identity checks, or perform more than one newly authorized `--retry-scoring-failed` invocation. Fill the paired review and leave finalization to official review. + +## Background + +Plan 2 fixed lifecycle recovery by observing only evaluator `output/` and setting the maximum publication wait to 300 seconds. All 460 deterministic tests passed. The preserved run then durably reached `scored=1 unscored=7 scoring_failed=1`: C05 scored 93, while C09 twice produced valid 94/95 worksheets but failed `evaluator_output_leak`. + +Read-only diagnosis reproduced the scanner failure. C09 producer-only tokens `gpt-5.6-terra` and `high` are absent from anonymous input and worksheet content but occur in the fresh Codex evaluator's own `session/.codex` model documentation and plugin cache. The session is created empty by the controller and populated only by the evaluator. Scanning it as producer evidence is therefore a provenance error. + +## Evidence Snapshot + +- Prior pair: `plan_cloud_G10_2.log`, `code_review_cloud_G10_2.log` in this task directory. +- Preserved run only: `agent-test/runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c`. +- Current durable state: C05 `score-000002` scored 93; C09 `score-000001` and `score-000002` are `scoring_failed/evaluator_output_leak`; seven rows remain unscored; nine producer attempts and one run identity remain fixed. +- C09 retained worksheets are valid totals 94 and 95 but are not publishable scores. + +## Required Fix + +Apply producer-identity scanning to the provenance-bearing anonymous `input/` and evaluator publication `output/` trees, not to the fresh evaluator-owned `session/` tree. Keep all of these boundaries strict: + +- input materialization, path, prompt, and frozen-input identity checks; +- output filenames and contents, including worksheet and lifecycle publication; +- secret scrubbing across input/session/output; +- invalid file-type handling, lifecycle/receipt/digest checks, and post-tree binding; +- cell ID, attempt path, and producer-only route/model/effort checks on producer evidence. + +Do not globally exempt `gpt-5.6-terra`, `high`, `.codex`, or arbitrary output content. The allowance is provenance-based and limited to controller-created fresh evaluator session state. + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-1] Refactor the post-evaluator identity scan to exclude only evaluator-owned `session/` while retaining input and output scans. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-2] Add regression coverage proving producer tokens in evaluator session state are accepted and the same tokens in input/output still fail closed. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-3] Run focused and full deterministic tests, manifest validation, and diff hygiene before live scoring. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-4] Invoke exactly one newly authorized `--retry-scoring-failed` on the preserved run; require C09 scored, C05 unchanged, and final `scored=2 unscored=7 scoring_failed=0 blocked=0`. +- [x] [REVIEW_TEST-5] Generate the run-owned report and publish `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md`, preserving all nine outcomes and the per-cell/sequential timing limitation. +- [x] Fill all implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` with exact commands, exits, score IDs, counts, and isolation audit. + +### REVIEW_TEST-1/2 — Provenance-aware identity boundary + +#### Modified Files + +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py` +- `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` + +#### Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest scripts.agent_benchmark.scoring_test +``` + +Expected: evaluator-created session state containing C09 producer model/effort strings is accepted; producer identities in anonymous input, prompt, output path/content, worksheet, cell id, attempt path, route, model, and effort remain rejected. + +### REVIEW_TEST-3 — Deterministic gate + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +``` + +Expected: all checks pass without live provider invocation. On any failure, stop before scoring. + +### REVIEW_TEST-4 — One preserved-run retry + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py score --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c --retry-scoring-failed +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +``` + +Expected: only C09 receives the next append-only score allocation; final counts are exactly two scored and seven unscored, with no scoring failure, producer retry, or new run. + +### REVIEW_TEST-5 — Reports + +```bash +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py report --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +``` + +Publish the deterministic projection to the dated report without inventing values or ranks for unscored rows. All raw links must remain inside the preserved run. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py` | REVIEW_TEST-1 | +| `scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py` | REVIEW_TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md` | REVIEW_TEST-5 | +| `agent-task/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md` | REVIEW_TEST-1..5 | + +## Final Verification + +```bash +python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts/agent_benchmark -p '*_test.py' +python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py validate --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +/bin/bash /tmp/iop-bench-13-env python3 scripts/agent_comparison_benchmark.py status --manifest scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json --run-id run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c +git diff --check -- . ':(exclude)agent-task/archive/**' +git status --short --branch +``` + +Expected: two scored/seven unscored, report files present, nine original producer attempts, one run identity, no evidence rewrite, and no active scoring failure. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/work_log_7.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/work_log_7.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..86bfbcdc --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/work_log_7.log @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +# Milestone Work Log + +> Dispatcher-owned execution timeline. Workers and reviewers do not edit this file. + +| seq | time | event | task | loop | role | attempt | model | result | locator | +|---:|---|---|---|---:|---|---:|---|---|---| +| 1 | 26-08-13 08:48:56 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G09.md | 0 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T084856+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 2 | 26-08-13 09:17:53 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G09.md | 0 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T084856+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 3 | 26-08-13 09:17:55 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G09.md | 0 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T091755+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p0__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 4 | 26-08-13 09:24:09 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G09.md | 0 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T091755+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p0__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 5 | 26-08-13 09:24:10 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md | 0 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T092410+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p0__review__a00/locator.json | +| 6 | 26-08-13 10:18:29 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G09.md | 0 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T092410+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p0__review__a00/locator.json | +| 7 | 26-08-13 10:18:29 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T101829+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p1__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 8 | 26-08-13 11:35:08 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T101829+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p1__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 9 | 26-08-13 11:35:10 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T113510+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p1__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 10 | 26-08-13 11:38:52 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T113510+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p1__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 11 | 26-08-13 11:38:53 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md | 1 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T113852+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p1__review__a00/locator.json | +| 12 | 26-08-13 11:55:04 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md | 1 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T113852+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p1__review__a00/locator.json | +| 13 | 26-08-13 15:39:00 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G08.md | 2 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T153900+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p2__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 14 | 26-08-13 15:58:33 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/PLAN-cloud-G08.md | 2 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol high | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T153900+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p2__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 15 | 26-08-13 15:58:34 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md | 2 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T155834+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p2__review__a00/locator.json | +| 16 | 26-08-13 16:08:14 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/14+13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md | 2 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol high | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T155834+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__14__13_runtime_compatibility_and_admission__p2__review__a00/locator.json | +| 17 | 26-08-13 16:08:15 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G09.md | 0 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T160815+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 18 | 26-08-13 16:50:09 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G09.md | 0 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:cancelled | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T160815+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 19 | 26-08-13 17:04:59 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T170459+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p1__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 20 | 26-08-13 17:40:28 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T170459+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p1__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 21 | 26-08-13 17:40:30 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T174030+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p1__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 22 | 26-08-13 17:45:12 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 1 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T174030+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p1__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 23 | 26-08-13 17:45:12 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md | 1 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T174512+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p1__review__a00/locator.json | +| 24 | 26-08-13 18:07:35 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md | 1 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T174512+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p1__review__a00/locator.json | +| 25 | 26-08-13 18:07:35 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 2 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T180735+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p2__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 26 | 26-08-13 18:26:25 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 2 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T180735+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p2__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 27 | 26-08-13 18:26:27 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 2 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T182627+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p2__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 28 | 26-08-13 18:28:59 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 2 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T182627+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p2__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 29 | 26-08-13 18:29:03 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 2 | worker | 2 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T182903+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p2__worker__a02/locator.json | +| 30 | 26-08-13 18:36:43 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 2 | worker | 2 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T182903+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p2__worker__a02/locator.json | +| 31 | 26-08-13 18:40:08 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 3 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T184008+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p3__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 32 | 26-08-13 19:07:31 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 3 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | failed:session-stall:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T184008+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p3__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 33 | 26-08-13 19:07:34 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 3 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T190733+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p3__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 34 | 26-08-13 19:23:41 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/PLAN-cloud-G10.md | 3 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T190733+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p3__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 35 | 26-08-13 19:23:42 KST | START | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md | 3 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T192342+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p3__review__a00/locator.json | +| 36 | 26-08-13 19:39:04 KST | FINISH | m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison/15+14_scored_benchmark_and_report/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G10.md | 3 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol xhigh | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260813T192342+0900__m-iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison__15__14_scored_benchmark_and_report__p3__review__a00/locator.json | diff --git a/agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md b/agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d9b642ce --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-test/dev/iop-one-shot-agent-comparison-2026-08-13.md @@ -0,0 +1,114 @@ +# IOP 원샷 Agent 모델 비교 결과 — 2026-08-13 + +## 결론 + +`run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c`은 C01-C09 모두에 대해 한 번씩 실행한 terminal evidence를 보존했다. 최종 상태는 `unresolved=0`, `scored=2`, `unscored=7`, `scoring_failed=0`, `blocked=0`이다. + +자동 웹 gate를 모두 통과해 익명 품질 채점이 가능했던 C05 GPT 단독과 C09 GPT 하이브리드는 각각 93점으로 공동 1위다. 나머지 7개 결과는 0점이 아니라 `unscored`이며 순위를 부여하지 않는다. 따라서 이 1회 실행만으로 caller 또는 model 전체의 우열을 일반화할 수 없다. + +- 결정적 원본 보고서: [run report](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/report.md) +- 이전 `run-20260813T071816Z-755d136c3e2b`은 fixture/scoring 진단 run으로만 보존하며 이 결과나 순위에 포함하지 않았다. +- 최종 run은 9개 cell마다 producer attempt가 정확히 1개다. producer caller를 retry하거나 새 run으로 교체하지 않았다. + +## 실행 조건 + +| 항목 | 값 | +|---|---| +| environment | `dev` | +| pipeline version | `2` | +| manifest digest | `sha256:38e48ef35beaa6ecc1aee0460df443e0ccf101a89aa6b91ce1f4b198aa84022a` | +| fixture | `product-card-v2` (`sha256:fb16198fd4c3576f880f047ed7de54dddc160b0f70c2ba55b435cf078c61828e`) | +| rubric | `one-shot-agent-comparison-v1` | +| session/cache | `fresh` / `isolated` | +| evaluator | `codex/gpt-5.6-luna/xhigh` | +| execution preflight | sequence 1, `ready=9` | +| repetition / timeout | cell별 1회 / cell별 180초 | + +## 9개 결과 + +표의 순서는 immutable seed가 정한 실제 실행 순서다. + +| 순서 | cell | 구성 | controller | product | harness | process | 자동 웹 gate | 채점 | 점수 | 순위 | +|---:|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---:|---:| +| 1 | C02 | Claude Code → Gemini 단독 | completed | succeeded | passed | exited | accessibility 실패 | unscored | — | — | +| 2 | C05 | Codex → GPT 단독 | completed | succeeded | passed | exited | 통과 | scored | 93 | 1 | +| 3 | C03 | agy → Gemini 단독 | completed | failed | passed | exited | 산출물 없음 | unscored | — | — | +| 4 | C06 | Claude Code → Gemini 하이브리드 | completed | failed | passed | exited | 산출물 없음 | unscored | — | — | +| 5 | C08 | Claude Code → GPT 하이브리드 | completed | failed | passed | exited | 산출물 없음 | unscored | — | — | +| 6 | C09 | Codex → GPT 하이브리드 | completed | succeeded | passed | exited | 통과 | scored | 93 | 1 | +| 7 | C01 | Claude Code → Claude 단독 | completed | unknown | failed | exited | 산출물 없음 | unscored | — | — | +| 8 | C07 | agy → Gemini 하이브리드 | timed_out | unknown | failed | timed_out | 산출물 없음 | unscored | — | — | +| 9 | C04 | Claude Code → GPT 단독 | completed | failed | passed | exited | 산출물 없음 | unscored | — | — | + +집계는 controller `completed=8`, `timed_out=1`; product `succeeded=3`, `failed=4`, `unknown=2`; harness `passed=7`, `failed=2`; process `exited=8`, `timed_out=1`; artifact `passed=2`, `failed=7`이다. + +## 익명 품질 점수 + +| 항목 | 최대 | C05 GPT 단독 | C09 GPT 하이브리드 | +|---|---:|---:|---:| +| 요구사항 충족 | 25 | 24 | 23 | +| 시각 완성도 | 25 | 24 | 24 | +| 반응형·접근성 | 15 | 13 | 13 | +| 이미지 활용·디테일 | 10 | 10 | 10 | +| 동작 안정성 | 10 | 9 | 9 | +| 코드 품질 | 10 | 9 | 9 | +| 자체 검증 완결성 | 5 | 4 | 5 | +| 합계 | 100 | 93 | 93 | + +자동 웹 gate는 채점 eligibility만 결정하며 점수에 합산되지 않았다. C05는 `score-000002`, C09는 provenance 경계 수정 후 새로 할당한 `score-000003`의 결과다. + +## 시간 비교 + +모든 시간은 harness monotonic clock 기준이며, first write는 workspace poll로 관측했다. `first output`과 `first write`는 제출 시점부터의 경과 시간이다. + +| cell | 전체 시간 | first output | first write | 관측 결과 | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---| +| C01 | 65.048초 | 1.285초 | 미관측 | parser error 뒤 product unknown | +| C02 | 127.718초 | 1.363초 | 95.441초 | product 성공, accessibility gate 실패 | +| C03 | 17.661초 | 0.662초 | 미관측 | caller error | +| C04 | 12.139초 | 1.069초 | 미관측 | caller error | +| C05 | 150.131초 | 0.791초 | 미제공 (`observer_unavailable`) | 통과·채점 | +| C06 | 24.394초 | 1.368초 | 미관측 | caller error | +| C07 | 180.284초 | 0.699초 | 미관측 | 180초 cell timeout | +| C08 | 16.606초 | 1.477초 | 미관측 | caller error | +| C09 | 179.132초 | 0.785초 | 77.213초 | 통과·채점 | + +180초는 전체 9개 matrix의 제한이 아니라 각 cell의 실행 제한이다. cell들은 순차 실행되므로 전체 matrix가 3분 안에 끝났다고 해석할 수 없다. 위 시간은 cell별 attempt 관측치이며 preflight, cell 사이 overhead, scoring과 report 시간을 포함한 run 전체 wall clock으로 합산하지 않는다. + +## 호출과 token 비교 + +caller가 제공한 값만 기록한다. 미제공 값을 0으로 바꾸거나 서로 다른 tokenizer의 값을 합산하지 않았다. + +| cell | model calls | tool calls | input | cached input | cache write | output | reasoning | total | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---| +| C02 | 12 | 미제공 | 182,484 | 97,822 | 0 | 3,701 | 미제공 | 미제공 | +| C05 | 1 | 9 | 248,818 | 217,034 | 31,751 | 20,721 | 5,156 | 미제공 | +| C09 | 1 | 7 | 247,278 | 218,156 | 28,649 | 12,134 | 4,317 | 미제공 | +| C01, C03, C04, C06, C07, C08 | 미제공 | 미제공 | 미제공 | 미제공 | 미제공 | 미제공 | 미제공 | 미제공 | + +C02의 caller-reported model duration은 116.081초, caller-reported total duration은 116.760초다. 이 구간은 harness 전체 시간과 clock/source가 다르고 중첩되므로 임의로 더하거나 overhead로 분해하지 않았다. 나머지 cell의 model/tool/queue duration은 미제공이다. + +## 실패와 한계 + +- C02는 product가 성공하고 두 viewport screenshot도 생성했지만 accessibility gate가 실패해 unscored다. +- C03, C04, C06, C08은 caller error와 non-zero exit 뒤 필수 산출물이 없어 unscored다. +- C01은 parser error로 product가 unknown이고 harness가 실패했으며, C07은 180초 timeout으로 product가 unknown이다. +- C05와 C09만 모든 자동 gate를 통과했다. 두 결과의 동점은 이 두 eligible artifact 사이의 1회 평가 결과일 뿐, 실패한 7개 조합의 품질이 0점이라는 의미가 아니다. +- provider/caller가 제공하지 않은 timing·usage는 `미제공`으로 유지했다. stage별, queue, tool duration과 total token은 비교할 수 없다. +- scored 결과는 각 1회뿐이므로 분산, 재현성, 비용 일반화나 통계적 유의성을 제공하지 않는다. + +## Raw evidence + +모든 링크는 preserved run 내부만 가리킨다. + +| cell | 실행 | 측정 | 웹 검증 | 채점 | screenshot | +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| C01 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c01-claude-sonnet-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c01-claude-sonnet-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c01-claude-sonnet-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [unscored](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c01-claude-sonnet-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/unscored.json) | — | +| C02 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c02-claude-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c02-claude-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c02-claude-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [unscored](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c02-claude-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/unscored.json) | [desktop](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c02-claude-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/screenshot-desktop_1080.png), [mobile](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c02-claude-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/screenshot-mobile_375.png) | +| C03 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c03-agy-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c03-agy-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c03-agy-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [unscored](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c03-agy-gemini-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/unscored.json) | — | +| C04 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c04-claude-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c04-claude-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c04-claude-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [unscored](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c04-claude-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/unscored.json) | — | +| C05 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c05-codex-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c05-codex-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c05-codex-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [score-000002](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c05-codex-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/score-000002/result.json) | [desktop](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c05-codex-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/screenshot-desktop_1080.png), [mobile](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c05-codex-gpt-direct/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/screenshot-mobile_375.png) | +| C06 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c06-claude-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c06-claude-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c06-claude-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [unscored](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c06-claude-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/unscored.json) | — | +| C07 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c07-agy-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c07-agy-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c07-agy-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [unscored](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c07-agy-gemini-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/unscored.json) | — | +| C08 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c08-claude-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c08-claude-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c08-claude-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [unscored](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c08-claude-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/unscored.json) | — | +| C09 | [attempt](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c09-codex-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt.json) | [measurement](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c09-codex-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/attempt-measurement.json) | [web](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c09-codex-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/web-validation.json) | [score-000003](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c09-codex-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/scoring/score-000003/result.json) | [desktop](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c09-codex-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/screenshot-desktop_1080.png), [mobile](../runs/bench-02/run-20260813T081326Z-4e1ac5152c6c/cells/c09-codex-gpt-hybrid/repetition-0001/attempt-000001/screenshot-mobile_375.png) | diff --git a/scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest_test.py b/scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest_test.py index 9a2fbd2c..ade46952 100644 --- a/scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest_test.py +++ b/scripts/agent_benchmark/manifest_test.py @@ -205,7 +205,7 @@ class ManifestValidationTest(unittest.TestCase): "session_policy": "fresh", "setup_cache_policy": "isolated", "timeout": { - "run_seconds": 300, + "run_seconds": 180, "idle_seconds": 30, "quiet_seconds": 10, "cleanup_grace_seconds": 5, @@ -236,7 +236,7 @@ class ManifestValidationTest(unittest.TestCase): ) expected_fixture = { - "version": "landing-v1", + "version": "product-card-v2", "prompt": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md", "assets": [ { @@ -252,7 +252,7 @@ class ManifestValidationTest(unittest.TestCase): "workspace_path": "assets/orbit-rings.svg", }, ], - "checksum": "sha256:7dc1be6ed4a9f2f873016b708b99d827b0249c74f2ac287e1fcf8deade8dcd98", + "checksum": "sha256:fb16198fd4c3576f880f047ed7de54dddc160b0f70c2ba55b435cf078c61828e", } self.assertEqual(raw["fixture"], expected_fixture) self.assertEqual( @@ -277,7 +277,7 @@ class ManifestValidationTest(unittest.TestCase): self.assertEqual( manifest.timeout, Timeout( - run_seconds=300, + run_seconds=180, idle_seconds=30, quiet_seconds=10, cleanup_grace_seconds=5, diff --git a/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py b/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py index 9d63b83a..de0febfc 100644 --- a/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py +++ b/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring.py @@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ SCORING_STATUSES = ("scored", "unscored", "scoring_failed", "blocked") SCORING_INVOCATION_REASONS = TERMINAL_REASONS + ( "binding_mismatch", "evaluator_failed", ) -_POST_CLEANUP_TIMEOUT_SECONDS = 2.0 +_POST_CLEANUP_TIMEOUT_SECONDS = 300.0 _POST_CLEANUP_QUIET_SECONDS = 0.2 _POST_CLEANUP_POLL_SECONDS = 0.01 @@ -369,10 +369,11 @@ def _identity_values(manifest: Manifest, attempt: Attempt) -> ProducerIdentity: producer.update( item.effort for item in cell.iop.expected_bindings if item.effort ) + exact = {attempt.identity.cell_id} + if cell.caller != manifest.evaluator.caller: + exact.add(cell.caller) return ProducerIdentity( - exact_tokens=tuple( - sorted(value for value in (attempt.identity.cell_id, cell.caller) if value) - ), + exact_tokens=tuple(sorted(value for value in exact if value)), path_tokens=(str(Path(attempt.root).resolve()),), producer_tokens=tuple(sorted(value for value in producer if value)), evaluator_shared_tokens=tuple(sorted(value for value in shared if value)), @@ -877,8 +878,8 @@ def _wait_post_cleanup_quiet( lifecycle_digest: str | None = None if lifecycle_validator is not None: - journal = root / "output" / "lifecycle-journal.jsonl" - result = root / "output" / "lifecycle-result.json" + journal = root / "lifecycle-journal.jsonl" + result = root / "lifecycle-result.json" journal_published = journal.exists() or journal.is_symlink() result_published = result.exists() or result.is_symlink() if journal_published and result_published: @@ -941,7 +942,7 @@ def _recover_runner( locator, control_target=control_target ) stable_lifecycle = _wait_post_cleanup_quiet( - blind_root, + blind_root / "output", lifecycle_validator=lambda: _validate_lifecycle_binding( blind_root, locator, @@ -959,7 +960,7 @@ def _recover_runner( locator, control_target=control_target ) lifecycle = _wait_post_cleanup_quiet( - blind_root, + blind_root / "output", lifecycle_validator=lambda: _validate_lifecycle_binding( blind_root, locator, @@ -993,7 +994,7 @@ def _recover_runner( expected_reason=outcome.reason, control_target=control_target, ) - _wait_post_cleanup_quiet(blind_root) + _wait_post_cleanup_quiet(blind_root / "output") _remove_cleaned_socket(locator, control_target) lifecycle = _validate_lifecycle_binding( blind_root, @@ -2102,7 +2103,15 @@ def _score_one( ) return "scoring_failed" try: - _scan_visible_tree(blind_root, identities) + # Producer identity belongs only to the frozen anonymous input and the + # evaluator's publication surface. The fresh session tree is owned by + # the evaluator itself and remains covered by secret scrubbing and the + # whole-tree digest, but is not producer provenance. + for evidence_root in ( + Path(blind.input_dir), + Path(blind.output_dir), + ): + _scan_visible_tree(evidence_root, identities) except ScoringError: _publish_current_failure( score_root, blind, allocation, run, attempt, "evaluator_output_leak" diff --git a/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py b/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py index ab0cfe18..ed83d7dc 100644 --- a/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py +++ b/scripts/agent_benchmark/scoring_test.py @@ -970,6 +970,133 @@ class ScoringTest(unittest.TestCase): ) self.assertEqual(result["reason"], "blind_preparation_failed") + def test_evaluator_session_identity_tokens_are_accepted_but_anonymous_evidence_rejects_them(self): + raw = json.loads(self.manifest_path.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + raw["matrix"][0]["iop"]["request_model"] = "gpt-5.6-terra" + raw["matrix"][0]["iop"]["expected_bindings"][0]["model"] = ( + "gpt-5.6-terra" + ) + raw["output_root"] = "agent-test/runs/evaluator-session-provenance" + path = self.root / "evaluator-session-provenance.json" + path.write_text(json.dumps(raw), encoding="utf-8") + self.manifest_path = path + self.manifest = load_manifest(path, repo_root=self.root) + tokens = iter(f"{index:012x}" for index in range(1, 9)) + self.store = RunStore( + self.root, + clock=lambda: datetime.datetime( + 2026, 8, 11, 1, 2, 4, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc + ), + token_hex=lambda _n: next(tokens), + ) + self.run = self.store.create(self.manifest, path.read_bytes()) + + class IdentityEvidenceAdapter(FakeScoringAdapter): + def __init__(self, location): + super().__init__() + self.location = location + + def invoke(self, cell, blind, task_payload, timeout, on_started): + result = super().invoke( + cell, blind, task_payload, timeout, on_started + ) + if self.location == "session": + state = Path(blind.session_dir) / "gpt-5.6-terra" + state.mkdir() + (state / "high").write_text( + "gpt-5.6-terra high", encoding="utf-8" + ) + elif self.location == "output-path": + (Path(blind.output_dir) / "gpt-5.6-terra").write_text( + "anonymous", encoding="utf-8" + ) + elif self.location == "output-content": + (Path(blind.output_dir) / "identity.txt").write_text( + "gpt-5.6-terra high", encoding="utf-8" + ) + elif self.location == "worksheet": + worksheet_path = Path(blind.output_dir) / "worksheet.json" + worksheet = json.loads(worksheet_path.read_text(encoding="ascii")) + worksheet["categories"][0]["evidence"] = ( + "gpt-5.6-terra high" + ) + worksheet_path.write_text( + json.dumps( + worksheet, + sort_keys=True, + separators=(",", ":"), + ) + + "\n", + encoding="ascii", + ) + return result + + accepted_attempt = self._attempt() + identities = scoring_module._identity_values( + self.manifest, accepted_attempt + ) + self.assertIn("gpt-5.6-terra", identities.producer_tokens) + self.assertIn("high", identities.producer_tokens) + accepted = IdentityEvidenceAdapter("session") + accepted_summary = score_run( + self.store, self.run, self.manifest, adapter=accepted + ) + self.assertEqual( + (accepted_summary.scored, accepted_summary.scoring_failed), + (1, 0), + ) + + self.run = self.store.create( + self.manifest, self.manifest_path.read_bytes() + ) + leaked_input = self._attempt(leaked_identity="gpt-5.6-terra high") + input_adapter = FakeScoringAdapter() + input_summary = score_run( + self.store, self.run, self.manifest, adapter=input_adapter + ) + self.assertEqual( + (input_summary.scored, input_summary.scoring_failed), (0, 1) + ) + self.assertEqual(input_adapter.invocations, []) + input_result = json.loads( + ( + Path(leaked_input.root) + / "scoring" + / "score-000001" + / "result.json" + ).read_text(encoding="ascii") + ) + self.assertEqual(input_result["reason"], "blind_preparation_failed") + + for location in ("output-path", "output-content", "worksheet"): + with self.subTest(location=location): + self.run = self.store.create( + self.manifest, self.manifest_path.read_bytes() + ) + leaked_output = self._attempt() + output_adapter = IdentityEvidenceAdapter(location) + output_summary = score_run( + self.store, + self.run, + self.manifest, + adapter=output_adapter, + ) + self.assertEqual( + (output_summary.scored, output_summary.scoring_failed), + (0, 1), + ) + output_result = json.loads( + ( + Path(leaked_output.root) + / "scoring" + / "score-000001" + / "result.json" + ).read_text(encoding="ascii") + ) + self.assertEqual( + output_result["reason"], "evaluator_output_leak" + ) + def test_delimited_short_caller_and_cell_identity_leaks_fail(self): identity = scoring_module.ProducerIdentity( exact_tokens=("agy", "cell-sentinel"), @@ -1303,21 +1430,36 @@ class ScoringTest(unittest.TestCase): errors.append(exc) worker = threading.Thread(target=recover) - started = time.monotonic() - worker.start() - time.sleep(0.35) - self.assertTrue(worker.is_alive()) - self.assertFalse(successor_started.is_set()) - self.assertTrue(alias.is_symlink()) - self.assertFalse((output / "lifecycle-result.json").exists()) + wait_started = threading.Event() + original_wait = scoring_module._wait_post_cleanup_quiet - (output / "lifecycle-journal.jsonl").write_text(journal, encoding="utf-8") - (output / "lifecycle-result.json").write_text( - json.dumps(lifecycle), encoding="utf-8" - ) - time.sleep(0.05) - self.assertTrue(worker.is_alive()) - worker.join(5) + def observe_wait(*args, **kwargs): + wait_started.set() + return original_wait(*args, **kwargs) + + started = time.monotonic() + with mock.patch.object( + scoring_module, + "_wait_post_cleanup_quiet", + side_effect=observe_wait, + ): + worker.start() + self.assertTrue(wait_started.wait(1)) + self.assertTrue(worker.is_alive()) + self.assertFalse(successor_started.is_set()) + self.assertTrue(alias.is_symlink()) + self.assertFalse((output / "lifecycle-result.json").exists()) + + time.sleep(0.35) + (output / "lifecycle-journal.jsonl").write_text( + journal, encoding="utf-8" + ) + (output / "lifecycle-result.json").write_text( + json.dumps(lifecycle), encoding="utf-8" + ) + time.sleep(0.05) + self.assertTrue(worker.is_alive()) + worker.join(5) self.assertFalse(worker.is_alive()) self.assertGreaterEqual(time.monotonic() - started, 0.5) self.assertEqual(errors, []) @@ -1475,6 +1617,66 @@ class ScoringTest(unittest.TestCase): self.assertFalse((stable_control / "control.sock").exists()) self.assertTrue(stable_successor_started.is_set()) + ( + churn_root, + churn_output, + churn_control, + churn_alias, + churn_locator, + _churn_lifecycle, + ) = prepare_prepublished("prepublished-session-churn") + churn_session = churn_root / "session" + for index in range(2048): + (churn_session / f"state-{index:04d}.txt").write_text( + "evaluator session state", encoding="utf-8" + ) + protected = { + path: path.read_bytes() + for path in ( + churn_control / "cleanup-receipt.json", + churn_output / "lifecycle-journal.jsonl", + churn_output / "lifecycle-result.json", + ) + } + stop_churn = threading.Event() + churn_count = 0 + + def churn_session_state() -> None: + nonlocal churn_count + changing = churn_session / "changing-state.txt" + while not stop_churn.is_set(): + churn_count += 1 + changing.write_text(str(churn_count), encoding="ascii") + time.sleep(0.005) + + churn_writer = threading.Thread(target=churn_session_state) + churn_writer.start() + try: + with mock.patch.object( + scoring_module, "_POST_CLEANUP_TIMEOUT_SECONDS", 0.4 + ), mock.patch.object( + scoring_module, "_POST_CLEANUP_QUIET_SECONDS", 0.1 + ), mock.patch.object( + scoring_module, "_POST_CLEANUP_POLL_SECONDS", 0.005 + ): + churn_recovered = scoring_module._recover_runner( + churn_root, + churn_locator, + invocation_digest, + control_target=churn_control, + ) + finally: + stop_churn.set() + churn_writer.join(2) + self.assertFalse(churn_writer.is_alive()) + self.assertGreater(churn_count, 1) + self.assertRegex(churn_recovered[0] or "", r"^sha256:[0-9a-f]{64}$") + self.assertRegex(churn_recovered[1], r"^sha256:[0-9a-f]{64}$") + self.assertFalse((churn_control / "control.sock").exists()) + self.assertTrue(churn_alias.is_symlink()) + for path, data in protected.items(): + self.assertEqual(path.read_bytes(), data) + ( changed_root, changed_output, diff --git a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json index b7c61a0d..b76a8888 100644 --- a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json +++ b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-direct-preflight.example.json @@ -30,14 +30,14 @@ }, "output_root": "agent-test/runs/bench-01-direct-preflight", "fixture": { - "version": "landing-v1", + "version": "product-card-v2", "prompt": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md", "assets": [ {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt", "workspace_path": "brief/reference.txt"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/aurora-grid.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/aurora-grid.svg"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/orbit-rings.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/orbit-rings.svg"} ], - "checksum": "sha256:7dc1be6ed4a9f2f873016b708b99d827b0249c74f2ac287e1fcf8deade8dcd98" + "checksum": "sha256:fb16198fd4c3576f880f047ed7de54dddc160b0f70c2ba55b435cf078c61828e" }, "matrix": [ { diff --git a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json index 81b5d5d8..804576dd 100644 --- a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json +++ b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-iop-one-shot.json @@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ "session_policy": "fresh", "setup_cache_policy": "isolated", "timeout": { - "run_seconds": 300, + "run_seconds": 180, "idle_seconds": 30, "quiet_seconds": 10, "cleanup_grace_seconds": 5 @@ -31,14 +31,14 @@ }, "output_root": "agent-test/runs/bench-02", "fixture": { - "version": "landing-v1", + "version": "product-card-v2", "prompt": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md", "assets": [ {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt", "workspace_path": "brief/reference.txt"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/aurora-grid.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/aurora-grid.svg"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/orbit-rings.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/orbit-rings.svg"} ], - "checksum": "sha256:7dc1be6ed4a9f2f873016b708b99d827b0249c74f2ac287e1fcf8deade8dcd98" + "checksum": "sha256:fb16198fd4c3576f880f047ed7de54dddc160b0f70c2ba55b435cf078c61828e" }, "matrix": [ { diff --git a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-manifest.example.json b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-manifest.example.json index e1d5bcb9..76111e14 100644 --- a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-manifest.example.json +++ b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-manifest.example.json @@ -30,14 +30,14 @@ }, "output_root": "agent-test/runs/bench-01", "fixture": { - "version": "landing-v1", + "version": "product-card-v2", "prompt": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md", "assets": [ {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt", "workspace_path": "brief/reference.txt"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/aurora-grid.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/aurora-grid.svg"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/orbit-rings.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/orbit-rings.svg"} ], - "checksum": "sha256:7dc1be6ed4a9f2f873016b708b99d827b0249c74f2ac287e1fcf8deade8dcd98" + "checksum": "sha256:fb16198fd4c3576f880f047ed7de54dddc160b0f70c2ba55b435cf078c61828e" }, "matrix": [ { diff --git a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-supported-direct.example.json b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-supported-direct.example.json index a754b1e0..a2e138c6 100644 --- a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-supported-direct.example.json +++ b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark-supported-direct.example.json @@ -30,14 +30,14 @@ }, "output_root": "agent-test/runs/bench-01-supported-direct", "fixture": { - "version": "landing-v1", + "version": "product-card-v2", "prompt": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md", "assets": [ {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt", "workspace_path": "brief/reference.txt"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/aurora-grid.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/aurora-grid.svg"}, {"source": "scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/orbit-rings.svg", "workspace_path": "assets/orbit-rings.svg"} ], - "checksum": "sha256:7dc1be6ed4a9f2f873016b708b99d827b0249c74f2ac287e1fcf8deade8dcd98" + "checksum": "sha256:fb16198fd4c3576f880f047ed7de54dddc160b0f70c2ba55b435cf078c61828e" }, "matrix": [ { diff --git a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md index 40d138ba..851eba58 100644 --- a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md +++ b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/prompt.md @@ -1,11 +1,11 @@ -Build a polished, responsive one-page product landing page for the fictional product described in `brief/reference.txt`. +Build a polished, responsive product card for the fictional product described in `brief/reference.txt`. Requirements: - Create exactly these implementation files at the workspace root: `index.html`, `styles.css`, and `script.js`. - Use both provided local images, `assets/aurora-grid.svg` and `assets/orbit-rings.svg`, as visible `` content with meaningful `alt` text. -- Include a keyboard-accessible navigation, hero, feature section, workflow section, testimonial, pricing callout, and footer using the supplied copy. -- Provide one small progressive-enhancement interaction in `script.js`; the page must remain readable when JavaScript is unavailable. +- Compose one compact card with a small product header, one hero area, and one primary CTA using the supplied copy. Do not add feature, workflow, testimonial, pricing, or footer sections. +- Provide one tiny keyboard-accessible toggle in `script.js` for the supplied status detail; the detail must remain readable when JavaScript is unavailable. - Support the supplied desktop and mobile viewports without horizontal overflow, clipped primary content, or overlapping controls. - Use semantic HTML, visible focus states, sufficient text/background contrast, a logical heading order, and labels for interactive controls. - Do not use external network assets, frameworks, package managers, build tools, inline data URLs, or generated replacements for the provided images. diff --git a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt index 78e210a3..79aaac87 100644 --- a/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt +++ b/scripts/fixtures/agent-comparison-benchmark/reference.txt @@ -1,21 +1,7 @@ PRODUCT: Lumen Atlas -EYEBROW: A calmer way to understand complex systems +EYEBROW: Operational clarity, at a glance HEADLINE: Turn scattered signals into a shared operating picture. SUMMARY: Lumen Atlas brings service health, ownership, and live operational context into one focused workspace so teams can decide with confidence. PRIMARY CTA: Explore the workspace -SECONDARY CTA: See how it works - -FEATURE 1 TITLE: One clear map -FEATURE 1 BODY: Connect services, dependencies, and owners without flattening the details that matter. -FEATURE 2 TITLE: Evidence in context -FEATURE 2 BODY: Keep decisions close to live signals, recent changes, and the people responsible for the next move. -FEATURE 3 TITLE: Calm by default -FEATURE 3 BODY: Prioritize meaningful changes and reduce the visual noise that slows incident response. - -WORKFLOW TITLE: From signal to shared decision -WORKFLOW STEPS: Observe / Connect / Act -TESTIMONIAL: “Lumen Atlas helps our team see the same system, ask better questions, and move together.” -TESTIMONIAL ATTRIBUTION: Maya Chen, Platform Lead at Northstar Labs -PRICING TITLE: Start with the systems you operate today. -PRICING BODY: A focused workspace for growing platform teams, with room to expand as ownership evolves. -FOOTER NOTE: Fictional benchmark content. No production data. +STATUS TOGGLE: Show live context +STATUS DETAIL: Ownership, service health, and recent changes stay connected in one calm view.