diff --git a/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md b/agent-roadmap/archive/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md similarity index 61% rename from agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md rename to agent-roadmap/archive/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md index fef250aa..ea271f5a 100644 --- a/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md +++ b/agent-roadmap/archive/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md @@ -2,8 +2,8 @@ ## 위치 -- Roadmap: [ROADMAP.md](../../../ROADMAP.md) -- Phase: [PHASE.md](../PHASE.md) +- Roadmap: [ROADMAP.md](../../../../ROADMAP.md) +- Phase: [PHASE.md](../../../../phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/PHASE.md) ## 목표 @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ ## 상태 -[진행중] +[완료] ## 구현 잠금 @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ ## 범위 - `[bench-route-01]`과 동일한 9개 caller/model/route 조합 -- 모든 조합에 [얇은 비교 결과 문서](../../../../agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md)의 같은 고정 비교 prompt와 같은 빈 임시 workspace 사용 +- 모든 조합에 [얇은 비교 결과 문서](../../../../../agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md)의 같은 고정 비교 prompt와 같은 빈 임시 workspace 사용 - 조합별 정확히 1회 실행 - 성공 여부, 전체 경과 시간, caller가 직접 제공한 usage, 산출물 경로와 짧은 수동 관찰만 기록 - 실행 전에 잠근 공통 100점 기준표로 각 산출물의 source와 동일 viewport render를 한 번만 분석하고, 항목별 증거·감점 사유·총점을 기록 @@ -35,22 +35,23 @@ ### Epic: [thin-run] 단일 시도 비교 -- [ ] [single-attempt-matrix] 9개 조합을 같은 prompt와 초기 상태에서 정확히 한 번씩 실행한다. 검증: 조합별 producer attempt가 하나이며 retry/resume/recovery 기록이 없어야 한다. -- [ ] [minimal-result-table] 성공 여부, 경과 시간, caller 제공 usage, 산출물 경로와 짧은 관찰을 단일 Markdown 표로 기록한다. 제공되지 않은 usage는 `미제공`으로 두고 추정하거나 0으로 바꾸지 않는다. -- [ ] [single-pass-scorecard] 실행 전에 고정한 공통 100점 기준표로 각 scorable 산출물의 source와 desktop/mobile render를 한 번만 함께 분석해 항목별 점수, 직접 증거, 감점 사유와 산술 총점을 기록한다. 검증: 평가 pass에는 route·model·시간·usage를 제공하지 않고 opaque 평가 ID만 사용하며, 모든 점수는 고정 anchor와 evidence를 가지고 재채점은 산술·전사 오류 수정으로만 제한한다. -- [ ] [bounded-conclusion] 성공한 결과만 비교하고 실패·미제공 데이터를 점수 0으로 취급하지 않는 짧은 결론을 남긴다. 자동 채점이나 통계적 일반화는 하지 않는다. +- [x] [single-attempt-matrix] 9개 조합을 같은 prompt와 초기 상태에서 정확히 한 번씩 실행한다. 검증: 조합별 producer attempt가 하나이며 retry/resume/recovery 기록이 없어야 한다. +- [x] [minimal-result-table] 성공 여부, 경과 시간, caller 제공 usage, 산출물 경로와 짧은 관찰을 단일 Markdown 표로 기록한다. 제공되지 않은 usage는 `미제공`으로 두고 추정하거나 0으로 바꾸지 않는다. +- [x] [single-pass-scorecard] 실행 전에 고정한 공통 100점 기준표로 각 scorable 산출물의 source와 desktop/mobile render를 한 번만 함께 분석해 항목별 점수, 직접 증거, 감점 사유와 산술 총점을 기록한다. 검증: 평가 pass에는 route·model·시간·usage를 제공하지 않고 opaque 평가 ID만 사용하며, 모든 점수는 고정 anchor와 evidence를 가지고 재채점은 산술·전사 오류 수정으로만 제한한다. +- [x] [bounded-conclusion] 성공한 결과만 비교하고 실패·미제공 데이터를 점수 0으로 취급하지 않는 짧은 결론을 남긴다. 자동 채점이나 통계적 일반화는 하지 않는다. ## 완료 리뷰 -- 상태: 없음 -- 요청일: 없음 -- 완료 근거: `[bench-route-01]`과 단일 시도 결과가 아직 없다. +- 상태: 통과 +- 요청일: 2026-08-14 +- 완료 근거: 9개 producer 단일 시도와 최소 결과표는 [실행 완료 로그](../../../../../agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/complete.log), 사용자 승인 동일 viewport 재수집과 점수표·제한 결론은 [평가 완료 로그](../../../../../agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/complete.log)로 확인했다. - 검토 항목: - [x] `[bench-route-01]`이 통과 또는 사용자 승인된 외부 차단 상태다. - - [ ] 새 benchmark script와 자동화 state가 없다. - - [ ] 조합별 정확히 한 번의 실행, 최소 결과 표와 evidence-backed 단일 평가표만 남았다. + - [x] 새 benchmark script와 자동화 state가 없다. + - [x] 조합별 정확히 한 번의 실행, 최소 결과 표와 evidence-backed 단일 평가표만 남았다. - agent-ui 상태 반영: 해당 없음 -- 리뷰 코멘트: 없음 +- Spec sync: 해당 없음 — 제품 코드·계약·런타임 동작을 바꾸지 않은 test-only 비교 evidence이므로 활성 구현 spec 갱신 대상이 아니다. +- 리뷰 코멘트: producer 호출은 재시도하지 않았고, 최초 렌더러 실패 뒤 사용자 승인으로 동일 source·opaque ID·viewport를 유지한 캡처만 재수집했다. 7개 점수 산술과 E04/E06 채점 불가 처리가 공식 리뷰 PASS를 받았다. ## 범위 제외 @@ -62,8 +63,8 @@ ## 작업 컨텍스트 -- 선행 작업: [벤치 경로 최소 HTML 스모크](../../../archive/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/benchmark-route-minimal-html-smoke.md) 완료 +- 선행 작업: [벤치 경로 최소 HTML 스모크](benchmark-route-minimal-html-smoke.md) 완료 - 실행 방식: 기존 공식 caller 명령을 한 번씩 직접 실행하며 공통 runner를 만들지 않는다. -- 결과 위치: [얇은 비교 결과](../../../../agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md) +- 결과 위치: [얇은 비교 결과](../../../../../agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md) - 준비 상태: 교체 가능한 고정 prompt, 9행 결과표, 공통 100점 기준표, 단일 평가 scorecard를 준비했다. 별도 script, judge, manifest, state store는 없다. -- 세션 라우팅: 이 세션에서 execution preset의 Work 바인딩은 사용자 지시에 따라 live `ornith:35b`를 사용하며 tracked 설정은 변경하지 않는다. +- 세션 라우팅: execution preset의 Work 바인딩은 사용자 지시에 따라 live `ornith-fast`를 사용하며 tracked 설정은 변경하지 않는다. diff --git a/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/PHASE.md b/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/PHASE.md index 05cb20c1..ba145cf5 100644 --- a/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/PHASE.md +++ b/agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/PHASE.md @@ -65,9 +65,9 @@ Phase를 가로지르는 실제 다음 작업 선택은 [전역 마일스톤 실 - 경로: [[bench-02] IOP 원샷 Agent 모델 비교 벤치마크](../../archive/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/iop-one-shot-agent-model-comparison.md) - 요약: 전용 harness의 정합성과 복구가 제품 안정성보다 우선되는 목적 역전으로 2026-08-13 폐기했다. 기존 결과와 계획은 재개하지 않는다. -- [진행중] [bench-lite-01] 초경량 Agent 모델 비교 - - 경로: [[bench-lite-01] 초경량 Agent 모델 비교](milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md) - - 요약: 최소 HTML 스모크를 통과한 동일 경로를 복구·재개 없는 단일 시도로 실행하고, 성공 여부·경과 시간·제공된 usage와 고정 100점 기준표의 1회 산출물 평가를 기록한다. +- [완료] [bench-lite-01] 초경량 Agent 모델 비교 + - 경로: [[bench-lite-01] 초경량 Agent 모델 비교](../../archive/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md) + - 요약: 동일 9개 경로를 producer 재시도 없이 한 번씩 실행해 7개 산출물을 공통 100점 기준표로 한 번 평가했고, 실행 실패 1건과 미완료 1건은 점수 0으로 왜곡하지 않고 채점 불가로 분리했다. - [계획] [surface-01] Inference API Surface와 실행 Lifecycle 책임 경계 리팩터링 - 경로: [[surface-01] Inference API Surface와 실행 Lifecycle 책임 경계 리팩터링](milestones/inference-api-surface-execution-lifecycle-refactor.md) diff --git a/agent-roadmap/priority-queue.md b/agent-roadmap/priority-queue.md index 27575895..65617631 100644 --- a/agent-roadmap/priority-queue.md +++ b/agent-roadmap/priority-queue.md @@ -4,11 +4,6 @@ ## 실행 순서 -### bench-lite - -1. [[bench-lite-01] 초경량 Agent 모델 비교](phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md) - 통과한 동일 경로를 복구·재개 없이 한 번씩 실행하고, 고정 기준표로 산출물을 한 번만 깊게 평가해 근거와 총점을 남긴다. - ### route 3. [[route-03] Heavy Plan/Review 실행과 검증 MVP](phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/knowledge-tool-validation-optimization.md) diff --git a/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_0.log similarity index 100% rename from agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_0.log rename to agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_0.log diff --git a/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_1.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_1.log similarity index 100% rename from agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_1.log rename to agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_1.log diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_2.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_2.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7603919c --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_2.log @@ -0,0 +1,166 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST]** Complete implementation-owned sections, paste actual output, and leave this pair active. Do not archive files, write `complete.log`, ask the user, or classify the next state. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-14 +task=m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark, plan=2, tag=TEST + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Pre-refine intent is checkpoint `e09aa66c3cdb829366463c10f8bc5f5801e3136e`. +- Replaced unstarted refinement: `plan_local_G08_1.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_1.log`; no verdict. +- This replan fixes URL normalization, token lifetime, and Claude row-workspace binding without changing the benchmark scope. + +## For the Review Agent + +Rerun applicable deterministic checks and inspect immutable evidence. Append an official verdict only after implementation is submitted. On PASS, archive this pair with suffix `2`, preserve first-line milestone metadata in `complete.log`, and move the task directory to the dated archive; roadmap aggregation remains a later runtime action. + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| TEST-1 Consume the Immutable Nine-Row Matrix | 차단 — 사전 게이트 실패, producer 미시작 | +| TEST-2 Render, Score Once, and Conclude | 미시작 — TEST-1 사전 게이트에 종속 | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] 사전 게이트를 producer workspace 생성 전에 실행했고, 실패 지점을 기록했다. +- [ ] Create nine empty row workspaces and execute each fixed caller/model tuple exactly once in its row workspace, with no retry/resume/recovery. (사전 게이트 차단) +- [ ] Fill the nine-row result table from immutable evidence, using caller-provided usage or `미제공`. (미시작) +- [ ] After all attempts, create one shuffled opaque bijection and copy/extract each scorable exact source without route facts. (미시작) +- [ ] Render each scorable opaque source once at desktop and once at mobile, then score it once with locked anchors and direct evidence. (미시작) +- [ ] Write a bounded conclusion comparing only successful scorable results and separating operational facts from quality. (미시작) +- [ ] Run the final count, isolation, placeholder, retry, secret, arithmetic, and scope checks. (미시작) +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify this checklist. + +- [x] Append one verdict with verified `review_rework_count` and `evidence_integrity_failure`. +- [x] Verify verdict, dimensions, and finding severities agree. +- [ ] Rerun required checks and inspect the nine ledgers/streams plus score evidence. +- [x] For every Required/Suggested finding, record evidence, exact root cause, one selected fix, affected files/tests, and acceptance commands. +- [x] Archive this file to `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log` and the plan to `plan_local_G08_2.log`. +- [x] Verify the Agent-Ops `.gitignore` block. +- [ ] On PASS, write `complete.log`, preserve milestone metadata, move the task directory to the dated archive, and update this checklist there. +- [x] On WARN/FAIL, create only the next state required by the code-review skill and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +계획의 `opencode run --help | rg ...` 사전 확인은 원격 OpenCode가 help를 stderr로만 출력해 실패했다. producer 명령, `run_root`, row workspace, catalog evidence는 생성하지 않았다. stderr를 stdout으로 병합하는 변경은 PLAN의 고정 gate 명령을 바꾸므로 구현자가 임의로 적용하지 않았다. + +## Key Design Decisions + +원격 dev runner(`toki@toki-labs.com`)의 로그인 zsh에서 gate를 실행했다. 로그인 셸에서 `claude`, `opencode`, `codex` 경로와 Claude help gate는 확인됐지만, 고정 OpenCode help 검사는 stderr 출력 때문에 실패했다. 행별 단일 시도 불변식을 지키기 위해 실패 후 보정 실행·retry·대체 실행을 하지 않았다. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Confirm URL normalization yields one `/v1/models`, the token remains available through row 09, and no producer workspace predates gate success. +- Confirm all nine exact tuples ran once and each direct caller was bound to its declared empty row workspace. +- Confirm no product/config/script/manifest/state-store change entered the worktree. +- Confirm route facts were absent from opaque scoring inputs until all scores froze. +- Confirm usage is caller-provided or `미제공`, and failures/unscorable artifacts are not zero. +- Confirm every scorable source has one SHA record, two one-shot renders, direct anchor evidence, and correct arithmetic. + +## Verification Results + +### External gate and producer attempts + +Paste redacted gate output, each expanded command, sole exit status, and `attempt.txt`. Do not paste credentials or sensitive raw provider payloads. + +원격 로그인 zsh에서 다음 조건은 확인됐다(민감값 미출력): `run_root=absent`, clean `dev`, HEAD `16b7aba95a282b6c5d1e88d3b1849eaa1208b28a`, managed CA/secret 파일 존재, `18083`/`19093` 수신, 로그인 PATH에서 Claude/OpenCode/Codex 경로 확인. + +실패한 고정 gate 단계: + +```text +opencode run --help | rg -- '--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir' +exit_status=1 +``` + +별도 진단에서 `opencode run --help`는 성공했으나 matcher 5건이 모두 stderr에 있고 stdout에는 없음을 확인했다. 따라서 고정 pipeline의 exit status는 `1`이다. 실패는 `mkdir "$run_root"` 이전이므로 producer invocation, row ledger, catalog 저장, token 사용은 발생하지 않았다. + +### Local deterministic checks + +Run the exact final checks from `PLAN-local-G08.md` and paste stdout/stderr plus exit statuses. + +실행 가능한 final check 대상이 없다. 외부 gate가 `run_root` 생성 전에 실패했으므로 count/isolation/opaque/render/scorecard 검사는 수행하지 않았다. 현재 worktree 변경은 이 활성 review의 구현자 기록과 dispatcher가 만든 untracked `WORK_LOG.md`뿐이다. + +### Manual scorecard review + +Record reviewer arithmetic, anchor/evidence, opaque isolation, render count, usage handling, and bounded-conclusion findings. + +미시작. opaque source, render, scorecard, 결과 표가 없으므로 수동 평가를 수행하지 않았다. 실패·미제공 데이터를 0점으로 기록하지 않았다. + +--- + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | Note | +|---|---|---| +| Header, overview, archive snapshot, reviewer instructions | Fixed | Implementer must not modify | +| Implementation item/checklist status | Implementer | Check only after actual completion | +| Review-Only Checklist | Review agent | Implementer must not modify | +| Deviations, decisions, verification results | Implementer, then reviewer | Replace placeholders with actual evidence | +| Code Review Result | Review agent | Appended only during official review | + +## Code Review Result + +### Verdict: WARN + +- `review_rework_count=1` +- `evidence_integrity_failure=false` +- Required: 0 +- Suggested: 1 +- Nit: 0 + +### Findings + +#### S1 — OpenCode help preflight drops stderr + +- Severity: Suggested +- Disposition: `direct-fix` +- Evidence: The active Verification Results and worker logs show `opencode run --help | rg -- '--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir'` exited `1`; the help matcher lines were emitted only on stderr. The failure occurred before `mkdir "$run_root"`, so `run_root`, row workspaces, catalog evidence, token/provider calls, and producer attempts were not created or consumed. +- Root Cause: `PLAN-local-G08.md:253` pipes only stdout from `opencode run --help` into `rg`, while OpenCode 1.18.3 emits this help text on stderr. +- Selected Fix: Change exactly that gate to `opencode run --help 2>&1 | rg -- '--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir'`. Preserve the fixed prompt, nine tuples, routes, one-attempt/no-retry conditions, opaque scoring, and all other commands unchanged. +- Affected file: `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md` +- Test decision: No product regression test or benchmark producer call. The regression oracle is the corrected read-only remote gate before `run_root` creation. +- Acceptance command: `ssh toki@toki-labs.com 'zsh -lic '\''set -euo pipefail; cd /Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev; run_root="$PWD/agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01"; test ! -e "$run_root"; command -v opencode >/dev/null; opencode run --help 2>&1 | rg -- "--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir" >/dev/null; printf "corrected_gate_exit=0\\nrun_root=absent\\nproducer_attempts=0\\n"'\'''` +- Fresh acceptance output: + +```text +corrected_gate_exit=0 +run_root=absent +producer_attempts=0 +``` + +### Dimension Assessment + +| Dimension | Result | Evidence | +|---|---|---| +| Correctness | Warn | S1 prevents the fixed preflight from reaching the benchmark setup. | +| Completeness | Warn | Producer execution correctly did not start; the benchmark remains pending behind S1. | +| Test coverage | Pass | The corrected read-only gate exits 0 with no workspace or attempt consumption. | +| API contract | Pass | No product API, wire, config, or caller route contract changed. | +| Code quality | Pass | No product code or common skill change exists. | +| Plan deviation | Pass | The worker stopped at the immutable gate and did not retry or alter the plan. | +| Verification trust | Pass | Active review evidence, worker logs, and the fresh read-only acceptance output agree. | + +### Routing Signals + +- evaluation mode: `isolated-reassessment` +- build closures: scope/context/verification/evidence/ownership/decision = true +- review closures: scope/context/verification/evidence/ownership/decision = true +- build scores: scope 1, state 2, blast 1, evidence 2, verification 2 = G08 +- review scores: scope 1, state 2, blast 1, evidence 2, verification 2 = G08 +- build base route: `local-fit` +- positive loop risk: `variant_product` (1) +- `large_indivisible_context=false` +- `review_rework_count=1` +- `evidence_integrity_failure=false` +- finalizer: `finalize-task-policy.sh pair` +- routed next pair: `PLAN-local-G08.md`, `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_3.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_3.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..97a128df --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_3.log @@ -0,0 +1,214 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - REVIEW_TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST] Filling in this file is the mandatory final step of implementation.** +> The task is NOT complete until every implementation-owned section below is filled in. +> Complete the `Implementation Checklist`; the final checklist item is mandatory before saving. +> Fill implementation-owned sections, then stop with active files in place and report ready for review. +> Execute the plan's selected root cause, scope, files, and dependency decisions as written. Do not choose another owner, narrow/expand the write boundary, or replace a fix with another verification attempt. +> If implementation is blocked, record the exact blocker, attempted commands/output, and resume condition only in implementation-owned evidence fields. +> Do not ask the user directly, present choices, call user-input tools, create control-plane stop files, or classify the next state. +> Finalization (`Code Review Result`, log rename, `complete.log`, archive moves, `Review-Only Checklist`) is review-agent-only, even after compaction/resume. +> Follow the ownership table at the bottom of this file for which sections you own. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-14 +task=m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark, plan=3, tag=REVIEW_TEST + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Pre-refine intent: checkpoint `e09aa66c3cdb829366463c10f8bc5f5801e3136e`, with one atomic pair covering all four Milestone Task ids. +- Replaced unstarted refinement: `plan_local_G08_1.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_1.log`; no verdict or implementation evidence. +- Earlier unstarted pair: `plan_local_G08_0.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_0.log`; no verdict. +- Current WARN evidence: `plan_local_G08_2.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log`; S1 is the only Suggested finding, Required 0, Nit 0, producer attempts 0. +- Fresh read-only acceptance: corrected matcher exited 0 while `run_root` remained absent and no producer attempt was consumed. +- Preserved invariants: fixed prompt and nine tuples, empty row workspaces, one producer invocation per tuple, no benchmark runner/state machine, opaque single-pass scoring, failures and missing usage are not zero. + + +## For the Review Agent + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** The finalization steps below are review-agent only. Implementing agents must not execute this section. + +Compare implementation of each item against source files. Run the applicable verification commands directly and record fresh output in `Verification Results`; implementation-owned output is handoff evidence, not a substitute for reviewer verification. If implementation is present, repair missing or stale verification output instead of failing solely for insufficient recorded evidence. When verification exposes a defect, collect the necessary data, determine the exact root cause, and select one concrete fix before generating the follow-up plan; never delegate investigation or remedy selection to the worker. +Review completion means the following steps are finished: + +1. Append verdict and `review_rework_count` / `evidence_integrity_failure` routing signals. +2. Archive `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` → `code_review_cloud_G08_3.log` and `PLAN-local-G08.md` → `plan_local_G08_3.log`. +3. If PASS, write `complete.log` and move active task directory to `agent-task/archive/YYYY/MM/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/`. If WARN/FAIL, fully write the next filesystem state required by the code-review skill. +4. If PASS and task group is `m-`, preserve the first-line `milestone-task` metadata in `complete.log` and report it for the runtime aggregation event. Roadmap state evaluation belongs to `sync-milestone-workstate`. +5. Check applicable `Review-Only Checklist` items at the final `.log` location before reporting. + +--- + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|------|---------| +| TEST-1 Consume the Immutable Nine-Row Matrix | [ ] | +| TEST-2 Render, Score Once, and Conclude | [ ] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] Pass the authenticated catalog/runtime gate without creating a producer workspace. +- [ ] Create nine empty row workspaces and execute each fixed caller/model tuple exactly once in its row workspace, with no retry/resume/recovery. +- [ ] Fill the nine-row result table from immutable evidence, using caller-provided usage or `미제공`. +- [ ] After all attempts, create one shuffled opaque bijection and copy/extract each scorable exact source without route facts. +- [ ] Render each scorable opaque source once at desktop and once at mobile, then score it once with locked anchors and direct evidence. +- [ ] Write a bounded conclusion comparing only successful scorable results and separating operational facts from quality. +- [ ] Run the final count, isolation, placeholder, retry, secret, arithmetic, and scope checks. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** This checklist is used only by the review agent. +> Implementing agents must not modify or check this section. + +- [x] Append one verdict of `PASS`, `WARN`, or `FAIL` and verified `review_rework_count`, `evidence_integrity_failure` to `Code Review Result`. +- [x] Verify that verdict, `Dimension Assessment`, and Required/Suggested/Nit classifications match. +- [x] Run applicable required verification and record fresh command/output; repair reviewer-reconstructable evidence gaps instead of forwarding them to another plan. +- [x] For every Required/Suggested finding, record reviewer-collected `Evidence`, exact `Root Cause`, and one `Selected Fix` with affected files/symbols/tests and acceptance commands before creating a follow-up plan. +- [x] Archive active `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md` to `code_review_cloud_G08_3.log`. +- [x] Archive active `PLAN-*-G??.md` to `plan_local_G08_3.log`. +- [x] Verify that the Agent-Ops managed block in `.gitignore` unignores `agent-task/**/*.md` and `agent-task/**/*.log` and ignores `agent-roadmap/current.md`. +- [ ] If PASS, write `complete.log` based on `agent-ops/skills/common/code-review/templates/complete-log-template.md` and leave no active `.md` files. +- [ ] If PASS, move active task directory `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/` to `agent-task/archive/YYYY/MM/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/` and update this checklist at the final archive path. +- [ ] If PASS and task group is `m-`, preserve and report `milestone-task` metadata for runtime aggregation, without modifying roadmap or directly calling `update-roadmap`. +- [ ] If PASS for split work, remove empty active parent `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/` or verify it was kept due to remaining siblings/files. +- [x] If WARN/FAIL, write the next filesystem state matching code-review verdict and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +Producer 실행과 tracked 결과 문서 수정은 수행하지 않았다. 첫 원격 shell은 non-login `zsh`로 시작되어 사용자 CLI PATH를 찾지 못했으나 `run_root` 생성 전 종료했고, login `zsh`로 다시 수행한 고정 gate도 catalog 단계에서 종료했다. 두 실행 모두 producer attempt를 시작하지 않았으며 `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01`은 계속 존재하지 않는다. + +## Key Design Decisions + +PLAN이 `base_url`에서 trailing slash와 trailing `/v1`만 제거하도록 고정하고 다른 fix를 선택하지 말라고 명시하므로, SOPS의 `http` scheme을 구현자가 임의로 `https`로 치환하지 않았다. 재개 조건은 secret의 `base_url`이 현재 TLS listener와 일치하도록 외부 환경에서 수정되거나, scheme 보정을 허용하는 후속 PLAN이 materialize되는 것이다. 어느 경우든 `run_root=absent`, producer attempt 0 상태에서 전체 gate부터 새로 시작할 수 있다. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Confirm the corrected OpenCode help matcher exits 0 before any producer workspace exists. +- Confirm URL normalization yields one `/v1/models`, the token remains available through row 09, and no producer workspace predates gate success. +- Confirm all nine exact tuples run once and each direct caller is bound to its declared empty row workspace. +- Confirm no product/config/script/manifest/state-store change enters the worktree. +- Confirm route facts remain absent from opaque scoring inputs until all scores freeze. +- Confirm usage is caller-provided or `미제공`, and failures/unscorable artifacts are not zero. +- Confirm every scorable source has one SHA record, two one-shot renders, direct anchor evidence, and correct arithmetic. + +## Verification Results + +### Corrected external gate and producer attempts + +Run the exact remote preflight from `PLAN-local-G08.md`. The OpenCode line must be exactly: + +```bash +opencode run --help 2>&1 | rg -- '--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir' +``` + +Before producer work, record that the corrected gate exits 0 and that `run_root` did not pre-exist. Then paste each redacted expanded producer command, sole exit status, and `attempt.txt`; do not expose credentials or sensitive provider payloads. + +실행 환경: `ssh toki@toki-labs.com`, `/Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev`, login `zsh`. + +비민감 preflight 결과: + +```text +branch=dev +head=16b7aba95a282b6c5d1e88d3b1849eaa1208b28a +dirty_count=0 +run_root=absent +tool_rg=0 +tool_claude=0 +tool_opencode=0 +tool_codex=0 +port_18083=0 +port_19093=0 +ca_file=0 +base_url_read=0 +token_read=0 +``` + +Corrected OpenCode matcher `opencode run --help 2>&1 | rg -- '--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir'`는 login shell에서 통과했다. 이후 고정 catalog 호출은 `catalog_http=400`, `json_valid=no`로 실패했고 응답은 다음 1행이었다. + +```text +Client sent an HTTP request to an HTTPS server. +``` + +Credential 원문과 private endpoint는 출력하거나 기록하지 않았다. 비밀값을 노출하지 않는 추가 확인에서 SOPS URL은 `scheme=http`, port `18083`이었고 listener 응답은 HTTPS를 요구했다. 종료 후 확인 결과는 다음과 같다. + +```text +run_root=absent +producer_attempts=0 +producer_streams=0 +``` + +따라서 redacted expanded producer command, exit status, `attempt.txt`는 없다. 행을 소비하지 않았으므로 retry/resume/recovery도 없다. + +2026-08-14 후속 worker attempt에서도 동일한 login `zsh` gate를 fresh로 재실행했다. 두 port 연결과 corrected help matcher는 통과했지만 catalog는 다시 `catalog_http=400`으로 종료됐다. 이 재실행도 gate 성공 전에 종료되어 `run_root`나 producer attempt를 생성하지 않았다. + +### Local deterministic checks + +Run every fresh final count, isolation, placeholder, retry, secret, arithmetic, and scope command from `PLAN-local-G08.md` exactly as written. + +PLAN의 count/isolation/placeholder/retry/secret/arithmetic/scope 최종 검사는 선행 catalog gate 실패로 실행 대상 evidence가 생성되지 않아 수행하지 않았다. 로컬 read-only 확인에서 `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01`은 부재했고, `git status --short`에는 dispatcher가 만든 active PLAN/review/log 파일만 존재했으며 제품·config·script·결과 문서 변경은 없었다. + +### Manual scorecard review + +Record arithmetic, locked-anchor evidence, opaque isolation, render counts, usage handling, and bounded-conclusion findings. + +Producer attempt 0건으로 scorable source와 render가 없어 scorecard 검토를 수행하지 않았다. 실패나 미제공 데이터를 0점으로 전환하지 않았고, 결과표 placeholder도 변경하지 않았다. 남은 위험은 외부 secret URL과 TLS listener 불일치가 해소되기 전에는 authenticated catalog와 9행 측정을 시작할 수 없다는 점이다. + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING] Have you filled in every implementation-owned section?** +> If anything is blank, go back and fill it in before saving this file. +> Leave review-agent-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | Note | +|---------|-------|------| +| Header comment, Overview, Review Agent Instructions | Fixed at stub creation | Implementing agent must not modify or execute these (archive, complete.log, and task-directory archive move are review-agent only) | +| Archive Evidence Snapshot | Fixed at stub creation from plan when present | Implementing agent uses it as default prior-loop context; read only the specific archive files cited there when more detail is required | +| Implementation Item Completion (item names) | Fixed at stub creation | Implementing agent checks `[ ]` → `[x]` only | +| Implementation Checklist (item text/order) | Fixed at stub creation from plan | Implementing agent checks `[ ]` → `[x]` only | +| Review-Only Checklist | Review agent only | Implementing agent must not modify or check this section | +| Deviations from Plan, Key Design Decisions | Implementing agent | Replace placeholder text with actual content | +| Reviewer Checkpoints | Fixed at stub creation | Pre-filled from plan | +| Verification Results (section headings + commands) | Implementing agent, then review agent | Implementing agent records initial output; review agent reruns applicable commands and may fill, replace, or append fresh verified output before verdict. Implementing-agent command changes require a `Deviations from Plan` entry | +| Code Review Result | Review agent appends | Not included in stub | + +## Code Review Result + +### Overall Verdict: WARN + +### Dimension Assessment + +| Dimension | Result | Evidence | +|---|---|---| +| Correctness | Warn | The authenticated catalog preflight cannot reach the qualified TLS listener while the command-scoped `api_root` preserves the stale `http` scheme. | +| Completeness | Warn | S1 is closed, but the benchmark correctly remains unstarted behind the catalog gate. | +| Test coverage | Pass | Fresh read-only evidence proves the matcher fix, protocol mismatch, and zero producer effects before `run_root`. | +| API contract | Pass | No product API, wire protocol, token, SOPS file, or tracked runtime configuration changed. | +| Code quality | Pass | No product code or common skill change was made. | +| Implementation deviation | Pass | The worker stopped at the immutable gate and preserved all benchmark invariants. | +| Verification trust | Pass | Active lines 119-147 and remote read-only confirmation agree; no claimed execution evidence is contradicted. | + +### Findings + +#### Suggested S2 — Command-scoped API root preserves a stale HTTP scheme for the qualified TLS listener + +- Evidence: `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md:119-147` records that the corrected OpenCode matcher passes, the decrypted SOPS `base_url` has `scheme=http` and port `18083`, the live listener requires HTTPS, and the sole authenticated catalog request returns HTTP `400` with `Client sent an HTTP request to an HTTPS server.` Fresh checks show `run_root=absent`, `producer_attempts=0`, and `producer_streams=0`. +- Root Cause: `PLAN-local-G08.md:262` normalizes only one trailing slash and one trailing `/v1`; it preserves the stale `http://` scheme even though the smoke-qualified port `18083` listener is TLS. +- Selected Fix: After deriving `api_root`, change only the command-scoped `api_root` scheme from `http://` to `https://` when its parsed port is exactly `18083`. Keep the SOPS file and token unchanged, continue using the managed CA, and require exactly one authenticated `${api_root}/v1/models` request to return HTTP `200` before creating `run_root`. Preserve S1, the fixed prompt, all nine tuples, the one-attempt/no-retry boundary, scoring, and all product/tracked runtime configuration. +- Disposition: `direct-fix` in the follow-up PLAN only. +- Acceptance: The pre-run gate prints only redacted `scheme=https`, `port=18083`, `catalog_http=200`, `run_root=absent`, and `producer_attempts=0`; it does not execute a producer call. + +### Routing Signals + +- `review_rework_count=2` +- `evidence_integrity_failure=false` + +### Next Step + +Run plan `prepare-follow-up` with isolated reassessment, archive the current active pair, and materialize the smallest routed follow-up pair for S2. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_4.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_4.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c9fa3c69 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_4.log @@ -0,0 +1,188 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - REVIEW_TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST]** Fill every implementation-owned section, run the routed PLAN exactly, keep active files in place, and report ready for official review. If blocked, record exact evidence and the resume condition here. Do not ask the user, create control-plane stop files, archive logs, or write `complete.log`. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-14 +task=m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark, plan=4, tag=REVIEW_TEST + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Closing pair: `plan_local_G08_3.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_3.log`; WARN, Suggested S2 only. +- S2: stale command-scoped HTTP scheme on qualified TLS port 18083; pre-fix catalog HTTP 400; no `run_root`, producer attempt, or producer stream. +- Prior S1: `plan_local_G08_2.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log`; corrected OpenCode help matcher passes. +- Preserved benchmark protocol is in `plan_local_G08_3.log`; only the selected S2 command-scoped scheme derivation may change. + +## For the Review Agent + +Run the applicable read-only gate and repository checks directly. Do not execute producer calls during review unless implementation has already produced the immutable nine-row evidence and the PLAN explicitly makes a safe reviewer rerun applicable; the one-attempt boundary normally forbids producer reruns. Append one verdict, archive this pair to suffix 4, and create the required next state. + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|---|---| +| TEST-1 Correct the Command-Scoped TLS Scheme Before Any Producer Effect | [x] | +| TEST-2 Execute the Preserved Immutable Nine-Row Benchmark | [x] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] Apply and record the command-scoped S2 TLS scheme correction through the exact read-only acceptance gate without creating `run_root` or a producer attempt. +- [x] Pass the full authenticated catalog/runtime gate before creating the producer workspace. +- [x] Execute the preserved nine caller/model tuples exactly once in their empty row workspaces, without retry/resume/recovery. +- [x] Fill the immutable nine-row result table using caller-provided usage or `미제공`. +- [x] Create one post-attempt opaque bijection, render each scorable source once per fixed viewport, and freeze the scorecard as unscorable because every render failed. +- [x] Write the bounded conclusion and run all preserved count, isolation, secret, arithmetic, and scope checks. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementers must not modify this checklist. + +- [x] Append one verdict and verified routing signals. +- [x] Verify dimensions and finding severities agree. +- [x] Record fresh applicable reviewer verification without consuming a producer attempt. +- [x] Close Evidence, Root Cause, Selected Fix, files, and acceptance for every finding. +- [x] Archive this review to `code_review_cloud_G08_4.log` and the plan to `plan_cloud_G08_4.log`. +- [x] Verify task artifacts are not ignored. +- [x] On PASS, write `complete.log`, preserve milestone metadata, and move the task directory to the dated archive. +- [ ] On WARN/FAIL, materialize the required next state and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +The initial normal remote session was started with a non-login shell, so caller PATH checks failed before catalog access, `run_root`, or producer effects. It was restarted with login `zsh`. After row-01, the shell-local name `status` collided with zsh's read-only parameter; row-01 remained consumed and was never rerun. Long-lived SSH sessions then closed at row boundaries, so rows 03-09 were executed in separate login shells with immutable existence/empty-workspace guards; no catalog or producer was repeated. Caller streams completed, but several post-command elapsed/exit fields are therefore explicitly `unrecorded`. + +All 14 one-shot Chromium renders failed to produce images: the first desktop render hung and was terminated, bounded later invocations timed out, and one mobile status was lost with its parent shell. No render was retried; the scorecard is frozen as `채점 불가` rather than assigning source-only scores. + +## Key Design Decisions + +After removing one trailing slash and `/v1`, the command parsed scheme and authority port. It required port `18083`, replaced only a command-scoped `http://` prefix with `https://`, required final scheme `https`, and used the unchanged managed CA and decrypted shell-local token. Neither the SOPS file nor tracked runtime configuration was written. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Confirm TEST-1 prints only `scheme=https`, `port=18083`, `catalog_http=200`, `run_root=absent`, `producer_attempts=0`. +- Confirm the SOPS file/token and managed CA are unchanged. +- Confirm exactly one authenticated catalog request precedes `run_root` in the benchmark session. +- Confirm S1, fixed prompt, nine tuples, empty workspaces, one-attempt/no-retry boundary, opaque scoring, and bounded conclusion are preserved. +- Confirm no product code, common skill, script, roadmap/spec/contract, or tracked runtime configuration changed. + +## Verification Results + +### S2 read-only acceptance + +Paste the exact five redacted output lines and exit status. Do not paste endpoint, token, catalog body, models, or credentials. + +```text +scheme=https +port=18083 +catalog_http=200 +run_root=absent +producer_attempts=0 +``` + +Command exit status: `0`. + +### Immutable nine-row execution + +Paste each redacted producer command/status and immutable ledger evidence. Never rerun a consumed row. + +```text +row-01 claude/claude-sonnet-5: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, result=success, duration_ms=83745, postprocess exit=unrecorded +row-02 claude/gemini-3.6-flash: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, exit=0, elapsed=81s +row-03 opencode/gemini-3.6-flash: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, caller elapsed=77s, postprocess exit=unrecorded +row-04 claude/gpt-5.6-luna: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, result=success, duration_ms=63757, postprocess exit=unrecorded +row-05 codex/gpt-5.6-luna: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, turn.completed, postprocess exit=unrecorded +row-06 claude/gemini-hybrid: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, exit=1, API error, no source +row-07 opencode/gemini-hybrid: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, exact terminal fence extracted once, postprocess exit=unrecorded +row-08 claude/gpt-hybrid: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, no exact terminal fence/source +row-09 codex/gpt-hybrid: stream=1, attempt_count=1, workspace_initial_entries=0, turn.completed, exact terminal fence extracted once, postprocess exit=unrecorded +attempts=9 +streams=9 +retry/resume/recovery positive markers=0 +``` + +### Deterministic local and manual checks + +Paste fresh count, isolation, secret, arithmetic, scope, opaque render, anchor, usage, and bounded-conclusion evidence. + +```text +opaque map: 9 unique rows -> 9 unique E ids +scorable exact sources: 7 +source.txt files: 7 +render ledgers: 7, each with two viewport entries +successful image renders: 0/14 +scorecard: 9 rows frozen as 채점 불가; no numeric scores or arithmetic substitutions +usage: caller-provided fields recorded for all rows; no estimates +conclusion: only operational facts compared; no quality/model ranking +``` + +### Fresh Reviewer Verification + +The reviewer did not execute any producer call. The first remote command was rejected by zsh before its body ran because the transport quoting was malformed. The second stopped before catalog access because the non-interactive session had no SOPS age key configured. After resolving the repository-declared key-file location without printing key material, the read-only gate exited `0` with exactly: + +```text +scheme=https +port=18083 +catalog_http=200 +run_root=absent +producer_attempts=0 +``` + +Fresh local evidence checks exited `0` and reported: + +```text +attempt_files=9 +stream_files=9 +attempt_count_one=9 +workspace_initial_zero=9 +retry_zero=9 +resume_zero=9 +opaque_rows=9 +opaque_ids=9 +opaque_lines=9 +source_files=7 +render_ledgers=7 +viewport_desktop_entries=7 +viewport_mobile_entries=7 +render_exit_entries=14 +desktop_images=0 +mobile_images=0 +positive_retry_markers=0 +opaque_identity_leaks=0 +catalog_sensitive_keys=0 +tracked_scope_changes=0 +result_rows=9 +score_rows=9 +unscorable_rows=9 +source_sha_match=7/7 +``` + +The seven render ledgers each contain exactly one desktop and one mobile entry. All 14 statuses are failure outcomes (`124`, one terminated hang, or one unrecorded parent-shell exit), so the absence of images and the nine `채점 불가` rows preserve the one-shot render boundary. The result document contains no numeric quality score or model-quality ranking, and failed, incomplete, unscorable, and unavailable values were not converted to zero. + +--- + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | +|---|---| +| Header, overview, archive snapshot, reviewer instructions/checkpoints | Fixed | +| Implementation item/checklist status, deviations, decisions, verification results | Implementer, then reviewer verification repair | +| Review-Only Checklist and Code Review Result | Official review agent | + +## Code Review Result + +- Overall Verdict: PASS +- Dimension Assessment: + - Correctness: Pass — the fixed TLS derivation reaches the qualified listener, and all nine immutable row ledgers match the requested tuples and one-attempt boundary. + - Completeness: Pass — the result table, opaque bijection, render ledgers, frozen scorecard, and bounded conclusion are present. + - Test Coverage: Pass — fresh read-only remote and deterministic local checks cover the applicable benchmark invariants without consuming another producer attempt. + - API Contract: Pass — no product API, wire, configuration, spec, or contract changed. + - Code Quality: Pass — no product code or benchmark automation was added; evidence remains bounded to the requested task and ignored run tree. + - Implementation Deviation: Pass — shell/session and render failures are recorded without retry, fabricated completion data, or broadened scope. + - Verification Trust: Pass — fresh counts, hashes, redaction checks, result rows, and the authenticated catalog gate agree with the implementation record. + - Spec Conformance: Pass — all four milestone task contribution ids exist and the implementation satisfies their current evidence requirements; SDD is not required. +- Findings: None +- Routing Signals: `review_rework_count=2`, `evidence_integrity_failure=false` +- Next Step: PASS — write `complete.log`, archive the active pair and task directory, and emit milestone completion metadata for runtime aggregation. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/complete.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/complete.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..9b9be3d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/complete.log @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ + + +# Complete - m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark + +## 완료 일시 + +2026-08-14 + +## 요약 + +두 차례 WARN 보완 뒤 고정된 9개 조합 단일 시도, 최소 결과표, one-shot render evidence, 채점 불가 처리와 제한된 결론을 검증해 최종 PASS했다. + +## 루프 이력 + +| Plan | Review | Verdict | 메모 | +|------|--------|---------|------| +| `plan_local_G08_0.log` | `code_review_cloud_G08_0.log` | 미판정 | 초기 계획 체크포인트가 후속 세분화로 교체됨 | +| `plan_local_G08_1.log` | `code_review_cloud_G08_1.log` | 미판정 | 실행 전 URL·token lifetime·workspace binding 결함을 보정하는 재계획으로 교체됨 | +| `plan_local_G08_2.log` | `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log` | WARN | OpenCode help가 stderr로 출력되어 S1 matcher 보완 필요 | +| `plan_local_G08_3.log` | `code_review_cloud_G08_3.log` | WARN | TLS listener에 stale HTTP scheme을 사용해 S2 command-scoped 보완 필요 | +| `plan_cloud_G08_4.log` | `code_review_cloud_G08_4.log` | PASS | TLS gate 통과 후 9개 단일 시도와 결과·opaque·render·결론 evidence 검증 완료 | + +## 구현/정리 내용 + +- 포트 18083의 command-scoped endpoint scheme을 HTTPS로 제한하고 authenticated catalog HTTP 200을 producer effect 전에 확인했다. +- 9개 caller/model tuple을 각각 한 번 실행하고 attempt/stream ledger, caller 제공 usage, exact source SHA와 opaque bijection을 기록했다. +- scorable source 7개의 desktop/mobile render를 각각 한 번 시도했으며 14건 모두 실패해 9개 scorecard 행을 수치 점수 없이 `채점 불가`로 동결했다. +- 성공·실패·응답 불완전·미제공 값을 0으로 치환하지 않고 운영 사실만 비교하는 제한된 결론을 남겼다. + +## 최종 검증 + +- `ssh toki@toki-labs.com` read-only TLS/catalog gate - PASS; `scheme=https`, `port=18083`, `catalog_http=200`, review 전용 `run_root=absent`, `producer_attempts=0`. +- task-local deterministic evidence checks - PASS; attempts 9, streams 9, attempt_count 9/9, empty workspace 9/9, retry/resume/recovery positive marker 0. +- opaque/source/render checks - PASS; 9:9 bijection, source SHA 7/7, render ledgers 7, viewport entries 14, images 0, scorecard `채점 불가` 9/9. +- secret/scope checks - PASS; catalog sensitive key 0, opaque identity leak 0, task/result 문서 밖 tracked scope change 0. + +## 잔여 Nit + +- 없음 + +## 후속 작업 + +- 없음 diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_cloud_G08_4.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_cloud_G08_4.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0ccf8e2a --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_cloud_G08_4.log @@ -0,0 +1,223 @@ + + +# Plan - Correct the Command-Scoped TLS Scheme and Run the Thin-Agent Matrix Once + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Implement S2 exactly as selected below. First run the read-only acceptance gate and record only its redacted five lines. Only after that gate returns HTTP 200 may the normal benchmark session create `run_root` and execute the preserved nine tuples. A producer invocation consumes its row even on failure or timeout; never retry, resume, recover, or replace it. Keep active files in place, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`, and report ready for official review. Do not ask the user, create `USER_REVIEW.md`, archive task files, or write `complete.log`. + +## Background + +S1 is closed: the corrected OpenCode help matcher passes. The next authenticated catalog preflight fails because the repository PLAN preserves a stale `http` scheme for the qualified TLS listener on port 18083. This follow-up changes only command-scoped `api_root`; the SOPS file/token, managed CA, prompt, nine tuples, attempt boundary, evidence, scoring, product code, and tracked runtime configuration remain unchanged. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Closing pair: `plan_local_G08_3.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_3.log`; verdict WARN with Suggested S2 only. +- S2 evidence: the SOPS URL is redacted as `scheme=http`, `port=18083`; the live listener requires HTTPS; the authenticated request returned HTTP 400 text `Client sent an HTTP request to an HTTPS server.` +- Side-effect evidence: `run_root=absent`, `producer_attempts=0`, `producer_streams=0`. +- Prior S1 evidence: `plan_local_G08_2.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log`; corrected help matcher acceptance passed with no producer attempt. +- Exact unchanged benchmark protocol is preserved from `plan_local_G08_3.log`; reading this cited task-local archive is allowed when expanding the nine producer commands. + +## Finding Resolution Map + +| Finding | Reviewer Evidence | Root Cause | Selected Fix | Mode | Changed Precondition | Acceptance Commands | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| S2 | Active review lines 119-147 and remote read-only confirmation prove `scheme=http`, `port=18083`, a TLS-required listener, catalog HTTP 400, absent `run_root`, and zero producer attempts/streams. | The PLAN removes only a trailing slash and `/v1`, preserving `http://` for the qualified TLS listener. | After deriving `api_root`, change only its command-scoped scheme from `http://` to `https://` when the parsed port is exactly 18083. Keep SOPS/token unchanged, use the managed CA, and require exactly one authenticated `${api_root}/v1/models` HTTP 200 before `run_root`. | `direct-fix` | The catalog request now uses the protocol required by the already-qualified listener, before any producer effect. | Run `[TEST-1]` acceptance once. It must print only `scheme=https`, `port=18083`, `catalog_http=200`, `run_root=absent`, `producer_attempts=0`. | + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md` +- `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` +- `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_2.log` +- `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_2.log` +- `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-test/dev/rules.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md` + +### SDD Criteria + +SDD is not required because this is test-only observation of existing paths with no API, state-machine, retry, or schema change. The pair preserves all four milestone task ids. + +### Verification Context + +The closed reviewer handoff supplies the evidence, root cause, selected fix, constraints, and acceptance output contract. Use `ssh toki@toki-labs.com`, login `zsh`, workdir `/Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev`, the existing SOPS principal token, managed CA, and qualified port 18083. The remote checkout/runtime identity checks remain those in `plan_local_G08_3.log`. The pre-run acceptance is read-only and must not create `run_root` or invoke any producer. After it passes, the normal benchmark session independently repeats the same corrected derivation and performs exactly one authenticated catalog call before creating `run_root`. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- No unit test substitutes for the live listener protocol; the exact authenticated catalog request is the oracle. +- The nine live caller results and manual opaque scorecard remain measured evidence, not product regression tests. + +### Symbol References + +None; no product symbols change. + +### Split Judgment + +Keep one atomic pair. The catalog gate, nine attempts, result table, opaque bijection, score freeze, and conclusion must bind to one immutable run. Splitting would weaken the single-attempt and blind-evaluation boundary. + +### Scope Rationale + +Only task artifacts, the benchmark result document, and ignored benchmark evidence may change. Do not modify the SOPS file/token, common skills, product code, scripts, roadmap/spec/contract, caller installation/configuration, or tracked runtime configuration. + +### Final Routing + +- evaluation_mode: `isolated-reassessment` +- finalizer: `finalize-task-policy.sh`, mode `pair` +- closures: scope/context/verification/evidence/ownership/decision are true for build and review +- build: scores 1+2+1+2+2 = G08, base `local-fit`, recovery boundary matched, route `cloud`, `PLAN-cloud-G08.md` +- review: scores 1+2+1+2+2 = G08, `official-review`, `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` +- positive loop risk: `variant_product` (1); `large_indivisible_context=false` +- `review_rework_count=2`; `evidence_integrity_failure=false` + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] Apply and record the command-scoped S2 TLS scheme correction through the exact read-only acceptance gate without creating `run_root` or a producer attempt. +- [x] Pass the full authenticated catalog/runtime gate before creating the producer workspace. +- [x] Execute the preserved nine caller/model tuples exactly once in their empty row workspaces, without retry/resume/recovery. +- [x] Fill the immutable nine-row result table using caller-provided usage or `미제공`. +- [x] Create one post-attempt opaque bijection, render each scorable source once per fixed viewport, and freeze one anchored scorecard. +- [x] Write the bounded conclusion and run all preserved count, isolation, secret, arithmetic, and scope checks. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +### [TEST-1] Correct the Command-Scoped TLS Scheme Before Any Producer Effect + +**Problem:** The existing plan derives `api_root` by removing a trailing slash and `/v1`, so a stale `http://...:18083` URL is sent to a listener that requires TLS. + +**Solution:** Decrypt the existing URL and token without printing either. Derive `api_root` as before. Parse its scheme and port. Require port 18083; if and only if the scheme is `http`, replace the command-scoped prefix with `https`. Require the final scheme to be `https`. Use the managed CA and token for exactly one authenticated `${api_root}/v1/models` request, require HTTP 200, discard the response after validation, and prove `run_root` and producer evidence remain absent. Never edit or rewrite the SOPS file. + +**Modified Files and Checklist:** + +- [x] `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-cloud-G08.md`: retain the reviewer-selected S2 command contract. +- [x] `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`: paste only redacted acceptance output and later benchmark evidence. + +**Test Strategy:** No product test. The live authenticated read-only catalog gate is the deterministic regression oracle. + +**Verification:** Run once before any benchmark session. The command may use shell-local secret values but stdout must contain exactly these five redacted keys and no endpoint, token, model catalog, or response body: + +```text +scheme=https +port=18083 +catalog_http=200 +run_root=absent +producer_attempts=0 +``` + +### [TEST-2] Execute the Preserved Immutable Nine-Row Benchmark + +**Problem:** The milestone remains incomplete because no producer row has been consumed and no result/score evidence exists. + +**Solution:** After TEST-1 passes, execute the exact unchanged row protocol recorded in `plan_local_G08_3.log`. Preserve S1 (`opencode run --help 2>&1 | rg ...`), normalize slash and `/v1`, apply the same port-18083 command-scoped HTTPS correction, and make exactly one authenticated catalog request. Only HTTP 200 permits `mkdir "$run_root"`. Then run, in order: Claude/`claude-sonnet-5`; Claude/`gemini-3.6-flash`; OpenCode/`gemini-3.6-flash`; Claude/`gpt-5.6-luna`; Codex/`gpt-5.6-luna`; Claude/`gemini-hybrid`; OpenCode/`gemini-hybrid`; Claude/`gpt-hybrid`; Codex/`gpt-hybrid`. Use one empty row workspace and one producer invocation per tuple, the fixed prompt, 900-second bound, no retry/resume/recovery, caller-provided usage or `미제공`, one post-attempt opaque mapping, one desktop/mobile render per scorable source, locked anchors, arithmetic checks, and a conclusion comparing only successful scorable outputs. + +**Modified Files and Checklist:** + +- [x] `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md`: immutable results, scorecard, and conclusion. +- [x] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/prompt.txt`: fixed prompt. +- [x] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/catalog.json`: credential-free catalog body. +- [x] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/runtime.txt`: redacted runtime identity. +- [x] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt`: one post-attempt mapping. +- [x] `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`: actual commands/statuses and deterministic check output. + +**Test Strategy:** No runner, manifest, state store, automated judge, or new test code. Immutable ledgers/streams plus one-shot render and manual anchored scoring are the evidence. + +**Verification:** Execute every exact producer, extraction, render, count, isolation, placeholder, retry, secret, arithmetic, and scope command from `plan_local_G08_3.log`, changing only the selected command-scoped S2 scheme derivation. Cached output is not acceptable. Expect nine attempt ledgers and nine sole streams, exact workspace binding, no retry/resume/recovery, opaque route isolation until score freeze, correct arithmetic, and no changes outside the result document and task artifacts. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-cloud-G08.md` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` | TEST-1, TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/prompt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/catalog.json` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/runtime.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-01/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-01/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-01/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-01/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-02/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-02/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-02/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-02/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-03/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-03/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-03/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-03/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-04/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-04/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-04/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-04/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-06/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-06/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-06/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-06/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-07/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-07/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-07/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-07/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-08/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-08/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-08/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-08/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-09/attempt.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-09/producer.jsonl` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-09/terminal.txt` | TEST-2 when caller emits/extracts terminal evidence | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-09/workspace/index.html` | TEST-2 when the row produces a scorable workspace artifact | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/index.html` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/source.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/desktop.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/mobile.png` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/render.txt` | TEST-2 when mapped/scorable | + +## Final Verification + +First require the TEST-1 acceptance output exactly as specified, with `run_root=absent` and `producer_attempts=0`. Then run TEST-2 from the same clean qualified dev runtime using the exact archived protocol and the selected S2 correction. Reviewer acceptance requires nine immutable attempts, no retry/resume/recovery, complete result/opaque/render/score evidence for scorable rows, correct arithmetic, bounded conclusions, no secret leakage, and no product/common-skill/tracked-runtime-config changes. + +After completing all code changes, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` with actual implementation notes and verification output. diff --git a/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_0.log similarity index 100% rename from agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_0.log rename to agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_0.log diff --git a/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_1.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_1.log similarity index 100% rename from agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_1.log rename to agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_1.log diff --git a/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_2.log similarity index 100% rename from agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md rename to agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_2.log diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_3.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_3.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ec4d6e45 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_3.log @@ -0,0 +1,316 @@ + + +# Plan - Correct the OpenCode Preflight and Run the Thin-Agent Matrix Once + +## For the Implementing Agent + +The S1 fix is materialized in this plan: execute the corrected read-only pre-attempt gate and the nine rows exactly as specified. A started producer command consumes that row even on timeout, failure, or malformed output; never retry, resume, recover, or replace it. Fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`, then leave the active pair for official review. + +## Background + +Official review closed S1 as a repository-fixable WARN: OpenCode 1.18.3 emits `run --help` on stderr, so the stdout-only matcher exited 1 before any producer attempt. This follow-up changes only that fixed gate to merge stderr into stdout; the benchmark prompt, tuples, routes, one-attempt boundary, evidence, and scoring conditions are unchanged. + +The checkpoint pair established the intended atomic benchmark and the first refinement added explicit evidence paths. That refinement remained non-executable: it could form `/v1/v1/models`, unset the token before producer work, and ran Claude outside the row workspace. This replacement preserves the original nine-route, single-attempt, blind-score intent while closing those command and evidence defects. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Pre-refine intent: checkpoint `e09aa66c3cdb829366463c10f8bc5f5801e3136e`, with one atomic pair covering all four Milestone Task ids. +- Replaced unstarted refinement: `plan_local_G08_1.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_1.log`; no verdict or implementation evidence. +- Earlier unstarted pair: `plan_local_G08_0.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_0.log`; no verdict. +- Current WARN evidence: `plan_local_G08_2.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log`; S1 is the only Suggested finding, Required 0, Nit 0, producer attempts 0. +- Fresh read-only acceptance: corrected matcher exited 0 while `run_root` remained absent and no producer attempt was consumed. +- Preserved invariants: fixed prompt and nine tuples, empty row workspaces, one producer invocation per tuple, no benchmark runner/state machine, opaque single-pass scoring, failures and missing usage are not zero. + +## Finding Resolution Map + +| Finding | Reviewer Evidence | Root Cause | Selected Fix | Mode | Changed Precondition | Acceptance | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| S1 | Active Verification Results and worker logs show the stdout-only OpenCode help matcher exited 1 before `run_root`; help flags were present only on stderr and producer attempts remained 0. | `opencode run --help` emits help on stderr, but the fixed pipeline sent only stdout to `rg`. | Use exactly `opencode run --help 2>&1 | rg -- '--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir'`; change no prompt, tuple, route, attempt, evidence, or scoring condition. | `direct-fix` | The matcher now receives the OpenCode help stream before any workspace, token/provider, or producer action. | Run the corrected read-only remote gate; expect exit 0, `run_root=absent`, `producer_attempts=0`. | + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `AGENTS.md` +- `agent-ops/rules/project/rules.md` +- `agent-ops/rules/common/rules-roadmap.md` +- `agent-ops/rules/common/rules-agent-spec.md` +- `agent-ops/rules/project/domain/testing/rules.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/router.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/plan/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/refine-plans/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/code-review/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/finalize-task-routing/SKILL.md` +- `agent-test/local/rules.md` +- `agent-test/dev/rules.md` +- `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-test/dev/iop-benchmark-route-minimal-html-smoke.md` +- `agent-roadmap/current.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md` +- `agent-spec/index.md` +- `agent-contract/index.md` +- `docs/dev-opencode-settings-guide.md` +- `scripts/e2e-hot-path-agents.sh` +- `scripts/e2e-single-request-claude.sh` +- the four earlier task-local logs named above +- `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md` +- `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` +- `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/WORK_LOG.md` + +### SDD Criteria + +SDD is not required. The Milestone records a test-only observation of existing caller/product paths with no API, state-machine, retry, or schema change. This pair contributes exactly `single-attempt-matrix`, `minimal-result-table`, `single-pass-scorecard`, and `bounded-conclusion`. + +### Verification Context + +The official review handoff supplied closed S1 evidence, root cause, selected fix, and acceptance output. Repository-native dev rules select `toki@toki-labs.com`, `/Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev`, Edge port `18083`, the existing SOPS principal token, and the managed CA. Before creating `run_root`, normalize the decrypted URL once to `api_root` by removing one trailing slash and one trailing `/v1`; use `${api_root}/v1/models`, `ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL=$api_root`, and OpenCode `baseURL=${api_root}/v1`. Keep the shell-local token through row 09 and unset it immediately afterward. + +External preflight must prove the smoke-qualified clean `dev` runtime identity, required caller versions/flags, ports, credential inputs, timeout tool, and authenticated five-model catalog. It does not deploy or mutate tracked runtime config. Local `/config/.local/bin/chromium` renders each scorable source once at each fixed viewport. Secrets and raw caller streams remain ignored evidence. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- Live availability has no unit substitute; the authenticated catalog gate and immutable row ledgers are the evidence. +- Caller usage schemas differ; use an explicit caller field from the sole stream or `미제공`. +- Visual judgment is manual by design; opaque input, fixed renders, locked anchors, arithmetic, and direct evidence bound it. + +### Symbol References + +None; no product symbol changes. + +### Split Judgment + +Keep one atomic pair. The result table, post-attempt opaque bijection, scorecard, and conclusion must bind to the same immutable nine-attempt set; independent children could expose route identity early or weaken the no-retry boundary. The explicit row protocol keeps `large_indivisible_context=false`. + +### Scope Rationale + +Writable tracked output is only the comparison document and active review evidence. Writable ignored evidence is the enumerated `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01` files below. Product source/config, caller installation or user config, roadmap/spec/contract, scripts, runner/manifest/state-store, and prior smoke evidence are excluded. + +### Final Routing + +- evaluation_mode: `isolated-reassessment` +- finalizer: `finalize-task-policy.sh`, mode `pair` +- closures: scope/context/verification/evidence/ownership/decision are true for build and review +- build scores: scope 1, state 2, blast 1, evidence 2, verification 2 = G08; `local-fit`; `PLAN-local-G08.md` +- review scores: scope 1, state 2, blast 1, evidence 2, verification 2 = G08; `official-review`; `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` +- positive loop risk: `variant_product` (1); `large_indivisible_context=false` +- `review_rework_count=1`; `evidence_integrity_failure=false`; recovery boundary not matched + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] Pass the authenticated catalog/runtime gate without creating a producer workspace. +- [ ] Create nine empty row workspaces and execute each fixed caller/model tuple exactly once in its row workspace, with no retry/resume/recovery. +- [ ] Fill the nine-row result table from immutable evidence, using caller-provided usage or `미제공`. +- [ ] After all attempts, create one shuffled opaque bijection and copy/extract each scorable exact source without route facts. +- [ ] Render each scorable opaque source once at desktop and once at mobile, then score it once with locked anchors and direct evidence. +- [ ] Write a bounded conclusion comparing only successful scorable results and separating operational facts from quality. +- [ ] Run the final count, isolation, placeholder, retry, secret, arithmetic, and scope checks. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +### [TEST-1] Consume the Immutable Nine-Row Matrix + +**Problem:** `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md:28-41` requires nine empty-workspace single attempts. The prior refinement appended `/v1/models` to an unnormalized URL, released the token before attempts, and invoked Claude from the repository root rather than the row workspace; those defects can fail the gate or invalidate that comparison. + +**Solution:** Run one remote `zsh` session. Complete the gate in Final Verification, keeping `api_root`, `iop_token`, `ca`, `run_root`, and the prompt alive. Create all row workspaces before row 01. Execute these tuples in order: row 01 Claude/`claude-sonnet-5`; 02 Claude/`gemini-3.6-flash`; 03 OpenCode/`gemini-3.6-flash`; 04 Claude/`gpt-5.6-luna`; 05 Codex/`gpt-5.6-luna`; 06 Claude/`gemini-hybrid`; 07 OpenCode/`gemini-hybrid`; 08 Claude/`gpt-hybrid`; 09 Codex/`gpt-hybrid`. + +Before each command, require missing `attempt.txt` and `producer.jsonl`, require an empty workspace, and write caller/model/version/start plus `attempt_count=1`, `retry=0`, `resume=0`. Wrap the sole invocation with `/opt/homebrew/bin/gtimeout 900`, redirect its only stream to `producer.jsonl`, and append end/elapsed/exit. Use the following exact caller forms, substituting only the tuple values: + +```bash +# Claude rows: invoke from the row workspace. +( cd "$workspace" && ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL="$api_root" ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN="$iop_token" NODE_EXTRA_CA_CERTS="$ca" CLAUDE_CODE_MAX_RETRIES=0 /opt/homebrew/bin/gtimeout 900 claude --print --output-format stream-json --verbose --bare --no-session-persistence --dangerously-skip-permissions --model "$model" "$(cat "$run_root/prompt.txt")" ) > "$run_root/$row/producer.jsonl" 2>&1 + +# OpenCode rows: --dir and command-scoped config bind the row workspace. +IOP_BENCH_TOKEN="$iop_token" OPENCODE_CONFIG_CONTENT="$(jq -cn --arg base "$api_root/v1" --arg model "$model" '{permission:{read:"allow",write:"allow",edit:"allow",glob:"allow",bash:"allow"},provider:{iop:{npm:"@ai-sdk/openai-compatible",options:{baseURL:$base,apiKey:"{env:IOP_BENCH_TOKEN}"},models:{($model):{name:$model}}}}}')" NODE_EXTRA_CA_CERTS="$ca" /opt/homebrew/bin/gtimeout 900 opencode run --pure --auto --model "iop/$model" --agent build --format json --dir "$workspace" "$(cat "$run_root/prompt.txt")" > "$run_root/$row/producer.jsonl" 2>&1 + +# Codex rows: isolated auth/config home and explicit row cwd. +codex_home="$(mktemp -d)" +cp /Users/toki/.codex/auth.json "$codex_home/auth.json" +cp /Users/toki/.codex/iop-direct.config.toml "$codex_home/iop-direct.config.toml" +CODEX_HOME="$codex_home" IOP_CODEX_API_KEY="$iop_token" CODEX_CA_CERTIFICATE="$ca" /opt/homebrew/bin/gtimeout 900 codex exec --ephemeral --json --sandbox workspace-write --skip-git-repo-check --cd "$workspace" --profile iop-direct --model "$model" --output-last-message "$run_root/$row/terminal.txt" "$(cat "$run_root/prompt.txt")" > "$run_root/$row/producer.jsonl" 2>&1 +rm -rf "$codex_home" +``` + +Capture status with `set +e`/`status=$?`/`set -e` around each exact invocation; cleanup is not a retry. For direct rows 01-05, accept `workspace/index.html` only with exactly one terminal `BENCH_LITE_01_DONE`. For preset rows 06-09, extract terminal text once from that row's sole stream; if its caller-native terminal event is absent or ambiguous, mark `채점 불가`. A terminal is scorable only when this strict one-shot extractor finds exactly one `html` fence: `ruby -e 's=File.binread(ARGV[0]);m=s.scan(/```html\r?\n(.*?)\r?\n```/m);abort("expected exactly one html fence") unless m.length==1;File.binwrite(ARGV[1],m[0][0])' terminal.txt index.html`. + +After row 09, unset `iop_token`, transfer the ignored run directory once to this checkout, then create `opaque-map.txt` exactly once with a shuffled row/E01-E09 bijection. Copy only scorable exact HTML into the mapped `E*/index.html`; write only its SHA-256 to `source.txt`. Do not place route, caller, model, time, usage, or row id in any `E*` directory. Freeze all scores before joining the mapping. + +**Modified Files and Checklist:** + +- [ ] `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md`: immutable result rows and observations. +- [ ] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/prompt.txt`: exact fixed prompt. +- [ ] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/catalog.json`: credential-free catalog body. +- [ ] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/runtime.txt`: redacted preflight identity. +- [ ] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt`: one post-attempt bijection. +- [ ] Row and opaque evidence files enumerated in Modified Files Summary. + +**Test Strategy:** No new test code or common runner. The measured behavior is the nine live caller invocations; immutable ledgers and sole streams are the regression evidence. + +**Verification:** Run Final Verification. Expect gate success before `run_root`, nine ledgers/streams, one attempt marker per row, exact empty-workspace binding, and no retry/resume/recovery. + +### [TEST-2] Render, Score Once, and Conclude + +**Problem:** `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md:43-91` requires source plus desktop/mobile evidence under a single blind evaluation pass, while its conclusion must not turn missing or failed data into zero. + +**Solution:** For each scorable `E*/index.html`, create fresh temporary Chromium profiles outside the repository and invoke Chromium once with `--window-size=1440,900 --screenshot=desktop.png`, then once with `--window-size=390,844 --screenshot=mobile.png`. Record viewport and sole exit status in `render.txt`; a failed render is not repeated. Score only the opaque source/renders, use the fixed A selectors and B-D anchors 0/1/3/5, record direct evidence and each deduction, and verify A+B+C+D. Join route facts only after all score blocks are frozen. Compare only successful scorable results; keep failure, unscorable output, and `미제공` separate. + +**Modified Files and Checklist:** + +- [ ] `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md`: score rows, evidence blocks, allowed correction notes, bounded conclusion. +- [ ] Opaque render evidence enumerated in Modified Files Summary. + +**Test Strategy:** No automated judge/browser gate. Fixed source, two one-shot renders, locked anchors, reviewer inspection, and arithmetic are the required evidence. + +**Verification:** Expect every scorable ID to have exactly one source, SHA record, two images, and one two-entry render ledger; every score has anchor/evidence and correct arithmetic. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md` | S1 (reviewer-materialized gate fix) | +| `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md` | TEST-1, TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/prompt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/catalog.json` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/runtime.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-01/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-01/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-01/workspace/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-02/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-02/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-02/workspace/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-03/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-03/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-03/workspace/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-04/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-04/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-04/workspace/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/terminal.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-05/workspace/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-06/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-06/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-06/terminal.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-07/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-07/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-07/terminal.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-08/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-08/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-08/terminal.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-09/attempt.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-09/producer.jsonl` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-09/terminal.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md` | TEST-1, TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E02/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E03/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E04/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E05/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E06/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E07/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E08/render.txt` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/index.html` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/source.txt` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/desktop.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/mobile.png` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E09/render.txt` | TEST-2 | + +## Final Verification + +Before creating `run_root`, run in one remote `zsh` shell: + +```bash +set -euo pipefail +cd /Users/toki/agent-work/iop-dev +run_root="$PWD/agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01" +test ! -e "$run_root" +ca="$PWD/build/dev-runtime/.secrets/credential-plane/ca.pem" +secret=/Users/toki/.config/iop/secrets/dev-openai-toki.sops.yaml +export SOPS_AGE_KEY_FILE=/Users/toki/.config/sops/age/keys.txt +base_url="$(/opt/homebrew/bin/sops -d --extract '["base_url"]' "$secret")" +api_root="${base_url%/}"; api_root="${api_root%/v1}" +iop_token="$(/opt/homebrew/bin/sops -d --extract '["tokens"]["toki-dev-cline"]' "$secret")" +test -n "$api_root"; test -n "$iop_token"; test -f "$ca" +test -z "$(git status --short)"; test "$(git branch --show-current)" = dev +test "$(git rev-parse HEAD)" = 16b7aba95a282b6c5d1e88d3b1849eaa1208b28a +command -v /opt/homebrew/bin/gtimeout jq ruby claude opencode codex +claude --help | rg -- '--print|--output-format|--verbose|--no-session-persistence|--bare' +opencode run --help 2>&1 | rg -- '--pure|--model|--agent|--format|--dir' +codex exec --help | rg -- '--ephemeral|--json|--sandbox|--cd|--profile|--model|--output-last-message' +nc -z 127.0.0.1 18083; nc -z 127.0.0.1 19093 +tmp_catalog="$(mktemp)" +http_code="$(curl --cacert "$ca" -sS -o "$tmp_catalog" -w '%{http_code}' -H "Authorization: Bearer $iop_token" "$api_root/v1/models")" +test "$http_code" = 200 +for model in claude-sonnet-5 gemini-3.6-flash gpt-5.6-luna gemini-hybrid gpt-hybrid; do jq -e --arg model "$model" '.data[] | select(.id == $model)' "$tmp_catalog" >/dev/null; done +mkdir "$run_root"; mv "$tmp_catalog" "$run_root/catalog.json" +printf 'branch=dev\nhead=%s\nports=18083,19093\ncatalog_http=200\n' "$(git rev-parse HEAD)" > "$run_root/runtime.txt" +``` + +Copy the exact fixed prompt into `prompt.txt`, create all nine row workspaces, and execute the expanded caller forms in TEST-1. Preserve redacted expanded commands, exit statuses, and ledgers in the active review. Unset `iop_token` only after row 09. + +For each scorable opaque ID, run once with a fresh profile per viewport and record both statuses: + +```bash +opaque_id=E01; opaque_dir="$PWD/agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/$opaque_id"; render_log="$opaque_dir/render.txt" +test ! -e "$render_log"; : > "$render_log" +profile="$(mktemp -d)"; printf 'viewport=1440x900\n' >> "$render_log" +set +e; /config/.local/bin/chromium --headless --disable-gpu --hide-scrollbars --run-all-compositor-stages-before-draw --user-data-dir="$profile" --window-size=1440,900 --screenshot="$opaque_dir/desktop.png" "file://$opaque_dir/index.html"; status=$?; set -e +printf 'exit_status=%s\n' "$status" >> "$render_log" +profile="$(mktemp -d)"; printf 'viewport=390x844\n' >> "$render_log" +set +e; /config/.local/bin/chromium --headless --disable-gpu --hide-scrollbars --run-all-compositor-stages-before-draw --user-data-dir="$profile" --window-size=390,844 --screenshot="$opaque_dir/mobile.png" "file://$opaque_dir/index.html"; status=$?; set -e +printf 'exit_status=%s\n' "$status" >> "$render_log" +``` + +Run fresh local checks; cached output is not applicable: + +```bash +test "$(find agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 -mindepth 2 -maxdepth 2 -name attempt.txt -type f | wc -l)" -eq 9 +test "$(find agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 -mindepth 2 -maxdepth 2 -name producer.jsonl -type f | wc -l)" -eq 9 +test "$(rg -l '^attempt_count=1$' agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-*/attempt.txt | wc -l)" -eq 9 +test "$(rg -l '^workspace_initial_entries=0$' agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/row-*/attempt.txt | wc -l)" -eq 9 +test "$(cut -d' ' -f1 agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt | LC_ALL=C sort -u | wc -l)" -eq 9 +test "$(cut -d' ' -f2 agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt | LC_ALL=C sort -u | wc -l)" -eq 9 +scorable="$(find agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 -mindepth 2 -maxdepth 2 -path '*/E*/index.html' -type f | wc -l)" +for name in desktop.png mobile.png render.txt source.txt; do test "$(find agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 -mindepth 2 -maxdepth 2 -path "*/E*/$name" -type f | wc -l)" -eq "$scorable"; done +! rg -n '미실행|미측정|미확인|미부여-[0-9]|미채점' agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md +! rg -n '(retry|resume|recovery)[[:space:]]*[:=][[:space:]]*(true|yes|[1-9])' agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 +! rg -n --hidden '(sk-|Bearer [A-Za-z0-9._-]{16,}|api[_-]?key[[:space:]]*[:=][[:space:]]*[A-Za-z0-9._-]{16,})' agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 +! rg -n 'Claude|OpenCode|Codex|claude-sonnet|gemini|gpt|hybrid|경과|usage|row-[0-9]' agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E*/source.txt agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E*/render.txt +git diff --check -- agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark +git diff --name-only -- . ':(exclude)agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md' ':(exclude)agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/**' +``` + +The last command must print nothing. Reviewer inspection must confirm gate-before-workspace ordering, exact tuple/workspace binding, one producer invocation per row, explicit usage or `미제공`, opaque isolation through score freeze, fixed-anchor arithmetic, and a conclusion that excludes failed/unscorable rows from quality comparison. + +After completing all code changes, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md`. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/work_log_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/work_log_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..499382c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/work_log_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +# Milestone Work Log + +> Dispatcher-owned execution timeline. Workers and reviewers do not edit this file. + +| seq | time | event | task | loop | role | attempt | model | result | locator | +|---:|---|---|---|---:|---|---:|---|---|---| +| 1 | 26-08-14 07:02:33 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 0 | opencode/glm-5.2 high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070232+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 2 | 26-08-14 07:02:40 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 0 | opencode/glm-5.2 high | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070232+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 3 | 26-08-14 07:02:42 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 1 | opencode/glm-5.2 high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070242+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 4 | 26-08-14 07:02:47 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 1 | opencode/glm-5.2 high | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070242+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 5 | 26-08-14 07:02:51 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 2 | opencode/glm-5.2 high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070251+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a02/locator.json | +| 6 | 26-08-14 07:02:56 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 2 | opencode/glm-5.2 high | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070251+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a02/locator.json | +| 7 | 26-08-14 07:02:56 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 3 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070256+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a03/locator.json | +| 8 | 26-08-14 07:08:23 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 3 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070256+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a03/locator.json | +| 9 | 26-08-14 07:08:31 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 4 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070831+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a04/locator.json | +| 10 | 26-08-14 07:09:58 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 4 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T070831+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a04/locator.json | +| 11 | 26-08-14 07:10:14 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 5 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T071014+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a05/locator.json | +| 12 | 26-08-14 07:12:55 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 2 | worker | 5 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T071014+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p2__worker__a05/locator.json | +| 13 | 26-08-14 07:20:49 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T072049+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 14 | 26-08-14 07:26:03 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T072049+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 15 | 26-08-14 07:26:05 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T072605+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 16 | 26-08-14 07:28:19 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 1 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | failed:generic-error:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T072605+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a01/locator.json | +| 17 | 26-08-14 07:28:23 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 2 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T072823+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a02/locator.json | +| 18 | 26-08-14 07:30:18 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 3 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T073018+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a03/locator.json | +| 19 | 26-08-14 07:38:30 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-cloud-G08.md | 4 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T073830+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p4__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 20 | 26-08-14 08:06:14 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-cloud-G08.md | 4 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T073830+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p4__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 21 | 26-08-14 08:06:15 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md | 4 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T080615+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p4__review__a00/locator.json | +| 22 | 26-08-14 08:49:21 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md | 4 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T080615+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p4__review__a00/locator.json | +| 23 | 26-08-14 08:49:21 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 2 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | reconciled:verified-complete-archive | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T072823+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a02/locator.json | +| 24 | 26-08-14 08:49:21 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md | 3 | worker | 3 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | reconciled:verified-complete-archive | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T073018+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p3__worker__a03/locator.json | diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/work_log_1.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/work_log_1.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..40e29697 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/work_log_1.log @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +# Milestone Work Log + +> Dispatcher-owned execution timeline. Workers and reviewers do not edit this file. + +| seq | time | event | task | loop | role | attempt | model | result | locator | +|---:|---|---|---|---:|---|---:|---|---|---| +| 1 | 26-08-14 09:11:43 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md | 0 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T090548+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p0__review__a00/locator.json | diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/WORK_LOG.md b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/WORK_LOG.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1fd3f5d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/WORK_LOG.md @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +# Milestone Work Log + +> Dispatcher-owned execution timeline. Workers and reviewers do not edit this file. + +| seq | time | event | task | loop | role | attempt | model | result | locator | +|---:|---|---|---|---:|---|---:|---|---|---| +| 1 | 26-08-14 09:02:30 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G03.md | 0 | worker | 0 | pi/ornith:35b high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T090230+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 2 | 26-08-14 09:02:44 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G03.md | 0 | worker | 0 | pi/ornith:35b high | failed:cancelled | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T090230+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 3 | 26-08-14 09:03:19 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G03.md | 0 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T090319+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 4 | 26-08-14 09:05:47 KST | FINISH | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G03.md | 0 | worker | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-sol | succeeded:0 | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T090319+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p0__worker__a00/locator.json | +| 5 | 26-08-14 09:05:48 KST | START | m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md | 0 | review | 0 | codex/gpt-5.6-terra high | running | /config/workspace/iop-s0/.git/agent-task-dispatcher/runs/20260814T090548+0900__m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark__p0__review__a00/locator.json | diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/code_review_cloud_G03_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/code_review_cloud_G03_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ec5b9e59 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/code_review_cloud_G03_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,251 @@ + + +# Code Review Reference - TEST + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST] Filling in this file is the mandatory final step of implementation.** +> The task is NOT complete until every implementation-owned section below is filled in. +> Complete the `Implementation Checklist`; the final checklist item is mandatory before saving. +> Fill implementation-owned sections, then stop with active files in place and report ready for review. +> Execute the plan's scope, files, and evidence decisions as written. Do not expand the write boundary or replace verification with any producer/model/render execution. +> If implementation is blocked, record the exact blocker, attempted commands/output, and resume condition only in implementation-owned evidence fields. +> Do not ask the user directly, present choices, call user-input tools, create control-plane stop files, or classify the next state. +> Finalization (`Code Review Result`, log rename, `complete.log`, archive moves, `Review-Only Checklist`) is review-agent-only. + +## Overview + +date=2026-08-14 +task=m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark, plan=0, tag=TEST + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Prior task: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/`. +- Terminal verdict: PASS in `code_review_cloud_G08_4.log`; no Required, Suggested, or Nit findings remained. +- Completion evidence: `complete.log` confirms nine producer attempts, seven exact sources, a 9:9 opaque map, fourteen failed initial render attempts, and a scorecard frozen as unscorable before the separately user-approved render retry. +- Carryover: `single-attempt-matrix` and `minimal-result-table` are already reconciled. This packet contributes only `single-pass-scorecard` and `bounded-conclusion`. +- Do not search other archive paths. Read the exact prior `complete.log` or `code_review_cloud_G08_4.log` only if this snapshot is insufficient. + +## For the Review Agent + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** The finalization steps below are review-agent only. Implementing agents must not execute this section. + +Compare implementation against the plan and source files. Run the applicable verification commands directly and record fresh output in `Verification Results`; do not rerun producer/model, browser, screenshot, capture, or render paths, and do not semantically rescore the seven frozen evaluations. Review completion means: + +1. Append verdict and routing signals. +2. Archive the active pair to `code_review_cloud_G03_0.log` and `plan_local_G03_0.log`. +3. If PASS, write canonical `complete.log`, archive this active task directory using the next collision-free destination, and emit the Milestone completion metadata for `sync-milestone-workstate`. +4. Roadmap workstate evaluation belongs to `sync-milestone-workstate`; do not directly pre-check the remaining task IDs. + +--- + +## Implementation Item Completion + +| Item | Status | +|------|---------| +| TEST-1 Verify Approved Retry Evidence and Finalize Scorecard | [x] | +| TEST-2 Preserve Milestone Workstate Reconciliation Boundary | [x] | + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [x] Verify the existing approved retry evidence, opaque mapping, exact source hashes, and fixed viewport PNG dimensions without running any producer/model or render path. +- [x] Finalize the single-pass scorecard and bounded conclusion in `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md`, changing only proven transcription/arithmetic defects and preserving non-zero treatment for failed, incomplete, and unavailable data. +- [x] Preserve runtime-owned Milestone reconciliation: confirm the active Milestone still leaves `single-pass-scorecard` and `bounded-conclusion` unchecked until PASS aggregation, and preserve their metadata in the active pair. +- [x] Run the bounded final verification commands and record actual output without rerunning benchmark production or capture. +- [x] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +## Review-Only Checklist + +> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify or check this section. + +- [x] Append one verdict of `PASS`, `WARN`, or `FAIL` and verified `review_rework_count`, `evidence_integrity_failure` to `Code Review Result`. +- [x] Verify verdict, dimension assessment, and finding classifications match. +- [x] Run only the read-only provenance, arithmetic, metadata, and scope verification; do not repeat semantic scoring or any producer/render path. +- [x] For every Required/Suggested finding, record evidence, exact root cause, and one selected fix with acceptance commands before follow-up planning. (No Required/Suggested findings.) +- [x] Archive `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md` to `code_review_cloud_G03_0.log`. +- [x] Archive `PLAN-local-G03.md` to `plan_local_G03_0.log`. +- [x] Verify the Agent-Ops managed `.gitignore` block. +- [x] If PASS, write canonical `complete.log` preserving `milestone-task=single-pass-scorecard,bounded-conclusion` and leave no active task Markdown files. +- [x] If PASS, move the active task directory to the next collision-free `agent-task/archive/YYYY/MM/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark[_N]/` destination. +- [x] If PASS, report the completion log for runtime `sync-milestone-workstate`; do not directly modify roadmap completion state. +- [ ] If WARN/FAIL, write the next filesystem state required by the code-review skill and do not write `complete.log`. + +## Deviations from Plan + +없음. 기존 점수 행, evidence block, 재수집 provenance와 결론에서 산술 또는 전사 결함이 발견되지 않아 결과 문서에 추가 수정을 가하지 않았다. producer/model, browser, screenshot, capture, render, retry, resume, recovery 경로는 실행하지 않았다. + +## Key Design Decisions + +- 현재 7개 평가를 고정된 단일 semantic pass로 취급하고, 검증은 source ledger, PNG header, 점수 전사와 산술, 제한된 결론 문구에만 한정했다. +- ignored run evidence 전체 파일의 SHA-256 목록을 검증 전후 비교해 검증 과정에서 evidence tree가 변경되지 않았음을 확인했다. +- Milestone의 `single-pass-scorecard`와 `bounded-conclusion`은 runtime PASS 집계를 위해 미체크로 유지했고, PLAN/CODE_REVIEW 첫 줄 metadata가 byte-for-byte 동일함을 확인했다. + +## Reviewer Checkpoints + +- Confirm the ignored run tree was not regenerated or modified during implementation. +- Confirm the seven HTML hashes equal their source ledgers and the fourteen existing PNG headers encode the fixed viewports. +- Confirm numeric rows use the frozen values, totals are arithmetic sums, and E04/E06 remain unscorable. +- Confirm the conclusion does not infer missing timing/usage, assign failure zeros, or generalize model superiority. +- Confirm both remaining Milestone task IDs stay unchecked before PASS and are preserved in completion metadata. + +## Verification Results + +### Evidence Provenance and PNG Dimensions + +```bash +python3 - <<'PY' +from pathlib import Path +import hashlib, struct +root = Path('agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01') +ids = ['E01','E02','E03','E05','E07','E08','E09'] +for eid in ids: + d = root / eid + expected = (d / 'source.txt').read_text().strip() + actual = hashlib.sha256((d / 'index.html').read_bytes()).hexdigest() + assert actual == expected, (eid, actual, expected) + for name, dims in [('desktop.png',(1440,900)),('mobile.png',(390,844))]: + data = (d / name).read_bytes() + assert data[:8] == b'\x89PNG\r\n\x1a\n' + width, height = struct.unpack('>II', data[16:24]) + assert (width, height) == dims, (eid, name, width, height) +print('source_sha_match=7/7') +print('desktop_dimensions=7/7') +print('mobile_dimensions=7/7') +PY +``` + +```text +source_sha_match=7/7 +desktop_dimensions=7/7 +mobile_dimensions=7/7 +``` + +### Frozen Score Transcription and Arithmetic + +```bash +python3 - <<'PY' +from pathlib import Path +import re +p = Path('agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md').read_text() +expected = {'E01':(40,11,14,18,83),'E02':(40,11,14,20,85),'E03':(40,11,14,20,85),'E05':(40,11,14,18,83),'E07':(40,11,14,18,83),'E08':(40,11,14,18,83),'E09':(40,11,14,20,85)} +for eid, scores in expected.items(): + m = re.search(rf'^\| {eid} \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| 완료 \|$', p, re.M) + assert m and tuple(map(int, m.groups())) == scores + assert sum(scores[:4]) == scores[4] + assert re.search(rf'^{eid} — A:', p, re.M) +for eid in ('E04','E06'): + assert re.search(rf'^\| {eid} \| — \| — \| — \| — \| — \| 채점 불가 — source 없음 \|$', p, re.M) +assert '통계적 모델 우위' in p and '0으로 치환하지 않았고' in p +print('numeric_score_rows=7/7') +print('score_arithmetic=7/7') +print('unscorable_rows=2/2') +print('bounded_conclusion=present') +PY +``` + +```text +numeric_score_rows=7/7 +score_arithmetic=7/7 +unscorable_rows=2/2 +bounded_conclusion=present +``` + +### Metadata, Scope, and Diff Integrity + +```bash +test "$(awk '{print $2}' agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt | sort -u | wc -l)" -eq 9 +test "$(sed -n '1p' agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G03.md)" = "$(sed -n '1p' agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md)" +rg -n --sort path '^- \[ \] \[(single-pass-scorecard|bounded-conclusion)\]' agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md +git diff --check +git status --short -- agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark +``` + +```text +40:- [ ] [single-pass-scorecard] 실행 전에 고정한 공통 100점 기준표로 각 scorable 산출물의 source와 desktop/mobile render를 한 번만 함께 분석해 항목별 점수, 직접 증거, 감점 사유와 산술 총점을 기록한다. 검증: 평가 pass에는 route·model·시간·usage를 제공하지 않고 opaque 평가 ID만 사용하며, 모든 점수는 고정 anchor와 evidence를 가지고 재채점은 산술·전사 오류 수정으로만 제한한다. +41:- [ ] [bounded-conclusion] 성공한 결과만 비교하고 실패·미제공 데이터를 점수 0으로 취급하지 않는 짧은 결론을 남긴다. 자동 채점이나 통계적 일반화는 하지 않는다. + M agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md + D agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md + D agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G08.md + D agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_0.log + D agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_1.log + D agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_0.log + D agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_local_G08_1.log + M agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md +?? agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md +?? agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G03.md +?? agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/WORK_LOG.md +opaque_ids=9/9 +headers=identical +run_tree_unchanged=yes +``` + +`git diff --check`와 run-tree 전후 SHA-256 비교(`cmp`)는 stdout 없이 exit 0이었다. 위 status는 작업 시작 시 존재한 bounded evidence/document/Milestone 및 task-pair 상태를 보존하며, 이번 구현에서 run tree와 Milestone을 수정하지 않았다. + +### Reviewer Fresh Re-verification + +```text +source_sha_match=7/7 +desktop_dimensions=7/7 +mobile_dimensions=7/7 +numeric_score_rows=7/7 +score_arithmetic=7/7 +unscorable_rows=2/2 +bounded_conclusion=present +opaque_ids=9/9 +headers=identical +single-pass-scorecard=unchecked +bounded-conclusion=unchecked +git_diff_check=pass +active_task_artifacts=not_ignored +secret_markers=absent +``` + +The reviewer reran the plan's read-only Python provenance/dimension and score-transcription checks, then reran opaque-ID, active-header, Milestone-checkbox, and `git diff --check` verification. No producer/model, browser, capture, screenshot, render, retry, resume, or recovery command was executed. + +--- + +> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — BEFORE SAVING] Have you filled in every implementation-owned section?** +> If anything is blank, go back and fill it in before saving this file. Leave review-agent-only sections unchanged. + +## Section Ownership + +| Section | Owner | Note | +|---------|-------|------| +| Header, Overview, Review Agent Instructions | Fixed | Implementer must not modify or execute archive/finalization steps | +| Archive Evidence Snapshot | Fixed | Use exact cited archive only when needed | +| Implementation Item Completion | Implementer | Check status only after work and verification | +| Implementation Checklist | Implementer | Check status only; preserve text/order | +| Review-Only Checklist | Review agent only | Implementer must not modify | +| Deviations from Plan, Key Design Decisions | Implementer | Replace placeholders with actual evidence | +| Reviewer Checkpoints | Fixed | Review contract | +| Verification Results | Implementer, then reviewer | Paste actual output; reviewer reruns applicable read-only commands | +| Code Review Result | Review agent appends | Not included in stub | + +## Code Review Result + +### Overall Verdict + +PASS + +### Dimension Assessment + +| Dimension | Assessment | Evidence | +|---|---|---| +| Correctness | Pass | Seven source ledgers match their HTML SHA-256 values; all fourteen existing PNG headers carry the fixed viewport dimensions. | +| Completeness | Pass | Both TEST-1 and TEST-2 checklist outcomes are present, and the two Milestone contribution IDs remain pending for runtime aggregation. | +| Test coverage | Pass | The plan's bounded deterministic provenance, arithmetic, metadata, and scope checks were rerun by the reviewer; product tests are not applicable to this evidence-only change. | +| API contract | Pass | No API, wire, config, or product contract changed. | +| Code quality | Pass | The result document preserves frozen-score wording and the bounded conclusion without unrelated code or automation. | +| Implementation deviation | Pass | No plan deviation beyond the recorded no-op transcription result. | +| Verification trust | Pass | Fresh reviewer output matches the implementation handoff; no claimed command or evidence was contradicted. | + +### Findings + +None. + +### Routing Signals + +review_rework_count=0 +evidence_integrity_failure=false + +### Next Step + +PASS: write the canonical completion log, archive this pair as `code_review_cloud_G03_0.log` and `plan_local_G03_0.log`, then emit the Milestone completion metadata for runtime workstate aggregation. diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/complete.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/complete.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ec19974f --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/complete.log @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ + + +# Complete - m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark + +## 완료 일시 + +2026-08-14 + +## 요약 + +승인된 재수집 render 증거의 provenance·고정 viewport·점수 전사/산술·제한 결론을 독립적으로 재검증해 최종 PASS했다. + +## 루프 이력 + +| Plan | Review | Verdict | 메모 | +|---|---|---|---| +| `plan_local_G03_0.log` | `code_review_cloud_G03_0.log` | PASS | 기존 7개 source/render 증거와 scorecard·bounded conclusion을 읽기 전용으로 재검증함 | + +## 구현/정리 내용 + +- 7개 scorable source의 SHA-256, 14개 기존 PNG의 고정 viewport header, 7개 점수 행과 E04/E06 채점 불가 처리, 제한 결론을 검증했다. +- `single-pass-scorecard`, `bounded-conclusion` metadata를 유지하고 Milestone 체크박스는 runtime workstate 집계 전까지 변경하지 않았다. + +## 최종 검증 + +- `python3` provenance/PNG-header check - PASS; source SHA 7/7, desktop 7/7, mobile 7/7. +- `python3` frozen-score transcription/arithmetic check - PASS; numeric rows 7/7, arithmetic 7/7, unscorable rows 2/2, bounded conclusion present. +- opaque-ID/header/Milestone/diff check - PASS; opaque IDs 9/9, active headers identical, target IDs unchecked, `git diff --check` exit 0. +- task artifact ignore and secret-marker check - PASS; active artifacts not ignored, secret markers absent. + +## 잔여 Nit + +- 없음 + +## 후속 작업 + +- 없음 diff --git a/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/plan_local_G03_0.log b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/plan_local_G03_0.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d0d85371 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark_1/plan_local_G03_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,232 @@ + + +# Plan - Approved Render Retry Scorecard Finalization + +## For the Implementing Agent + +Filling implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md` is mandatory. Verify only the existing evidence, finalize the bounded document changes, record actual command output, keep both active files in place, and report ready for review. Finalization is code-review-skill only. If blocked, record the exact blocker, attempted commands/output, and resume condition in the review evidence fields; do not ask the user, call user-input tools, create control-plane stop files, classify the next state, archive logs, or write `complete.log`. + +## Background + +The prior task completed the nine immutable producer attempts and recorded that all first render attempts failed. The user subsequently approved a render-only retry, and the worktree now contains seven desktop/mobile pairs plus a single-pass scorecard and bounded conclusion. This packet verifies and finalizes those existing changes without invoking any producer/model benchmark path, recapturing renders, adding automation, or touching product code. + +## Archive Evidence Snapshot + +- Prior task: `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/`. +- Terminal verdict: PASS in `code_review_cloud_G08_4.log`; no Required, Suggested, or Nit findings remained. +- Completion evidence: `complete.log` confirms nine producer attempts, seven exact sources, a 9:9 opaque map, fourteen failed initial render attempts, and a scorecard frozen as unscorable before the separately user-approved render retry. +- Carryover: `single-attempt-matrix` and `minimal-result-table` are already reconciled. This packet contributes only `single-pass-scorecard` and `bounded-conclusion`. +- Do not search other archive paths. Read the exact prior `complete.log` or `code_review_cloud_G08_4.log` only if the snapshot above is insufficient. + +## Analysis + +### Files Read + +- `agent-ops/rules/project/rules.md` +- `agent-ops/rules/common/rules-roadmap.md` +- `agent-ops/rules/project/domain/testing/rules.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/router.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/plan/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/update-test/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/sync-milestone-workstate/SKILL.md` +- `agent-ops/skills/common/finalize-task-routing/SKILL.md` +- `agent-test/local/rules.md` +- `agent-test/local/testing-smoke.md` +- `agent-roadmap/current.md` +- `agent-roadmap/priority-queue.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/PHASE.md` +- `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md` +- `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md` +- `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt` +- `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/source.txt`, `E02/source.txt`, `E03/source.txt`, `E05/source.txt`, `E07/source.txt`, `E08/source.txt`, `E09/source.txt` +- `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/E01/render.txt`, `E02/render.txt`, `E03/render.txt`, `E05/render.txt`, `E07/render.txt`, `E08/render.txt`, `E09/render.txt` +- Existing `index.html`, `desktop.png`, and `mobile.png` evidence for E01, E02, E03, E05, E07, E08, and E09 under `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/` +- `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/complete.log` +- `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/plan_cloud_G08_4.log` +- `agent-task/archive/2026/08/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/code_review_cloud_G08_4.log` + +### SDD Criteria + +SDD is not required because the Milestone is a test-only observation of existing caller/product paths and changes no product API, state machine, retry policy, or schema. + +### Verification Context + +- Handoff: repository `update-test mode=resolve-context` guidance was applied from `agent-test/local/rules.md` and `agent-test/local/testing-smoke.md`. +- Environment: current checkout, local read-only verification; no external service, model endpoint, credential, Docker, or remote runner is required. +- Commands/criteria: check exact source SHA against `index.html`, opaque ID uniqueness, existing PNG dimensions and hashes, score arithmetic/allowed anchors, bounded conclusion wording, secret markers, and `git diff --check`. +- Preconditions: preserve the existing ignored run tree; do not invoke producer/model commands, render/capture commands, benchmark runners, or any retry/resume/recovery path. +- Constraints: the seven existing score blocks are the single semantic evaluation pass. Verification may check provenance, transcription, anchors, and arithmetic but must not rescore or rewrite quality judgments except a proven arithmetic/transcription error. +- Repository-native fallback evidence: the prior exact `complete.log`, current result document, source ledgers, opaque map, HTML hashes, and fourteen existing PNG files. +- Gaps: no image metadata utility is installed, so the deterministic verification uses Python standard-library PNG header reads. No external preflight applies. +- Confidence: high; all required inputs are local, bounded, and independently hash-checkable. + +### Test Coverage Gaps + +- No behavior or product code changes exist, so unit/E2E product tests are not applicable. +- Semantic visual quality cannot be replayed without violating the single-pass rule. The plan therefore verifies only the frozen evaluation's evidence/provenance and arithmetic. +- The ignored render evidence is not tracked; review must verify its presence in this checkout and must report absence as a blocker rather than regenerate it. + +### Symbol References + +None. No symbol is renamed or removed. + +### Split Judgment + +Keep one compact plan: provenance validation, scorecard transcription, bounded conclusion, and completion metadata form one evidence-finalization boundary. Splitting would not yield independently useful PASS states and could separate the score table from its conclusion and workstate contribution. + +### Scope Rationale + +Included: the existing user-approved evidence under `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01`, bounded edits to `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md`, and review/runtime reconciliation for `single-pass-scorecard` and `bounded-conclusion`. Excluded: all producer/model execution, render recapture, scripts, harnesses, manifests, state stores, product code, config, API/wire/spec/contract changes, and unrelated active tasks. The Milestone file remains runtime reconciliation evidence; the implementer must not pre-check its two remaining tasks before official PASS aggregation. + +### Final Routing + +- evaluation_mode: `first-pass` +- finalizer: `finalize-task-policy.sh`, mode `pair` +- closures: build/review `scope_closed=true`, `context_closed=true`, `verification_closed=true`, `evidence_trusted=true`, `ownership_closed=true`, `decision_closed=true` +- build grade scores: scope 1, state 0, blast 0, evidence 1, verification 1; grade `G03`; base/route `local-fit`; catalog `worker/local/G03` +- review grade scores: scope 1, state 0, blast 0, evidence 1, verification 1; grade `G03`; route `official-review`; catalog `review/cloud/G03` +- large_indivisible_context: `false` +- matched loop risks: `structured_interpretation`; count `1`; risk boundary `false` +- recovery: `review_rework_count=0`, `evidence_integrity_failure=false`; recovery boundary `false` +- capability gap: none +- canonical files: `PLAN-local-G03.md`, `CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md` + +## Implementation Checklist + +- [ ] Verify the existing approved retry evidence, opaque mapping, exact source hashes, and fixed viewport PNG dimensions without running any producer/model or render path. +- [ ] Finalize the single-pass scorecard and bounded conclusion in `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md`, changing only proven transcription/arithmetic defects and preserving non-zero treatment for failed, incomplete, and unavailable data. +- [ ] Preserve runtime-owned Milestone reconciliation: confirm the active Milestone still leaves `single-pass-scorecard` and `bounded-conclusion` unchecked until PASS aggregation, and preserve their metadata in the active pair. +- [ ] Run the bounded final verification commands and record actual output without rerunning benchmark production or capture. +- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. + +### [TEST-1] Verify Approved Retry Evidence and Finalize Scorecard + +#### Problem + +The current result document contains the intended scorecard and conclusion at `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md:60`, but the prior completion evidence predates the user-approved render-only retry. The new evidence must be tied to the same seven opaque sources and fixed viewports, and the numeric table must remain a single frozen evaluation rather than silently becoming a second scoring pass. + +#### Solution + +Treat the current seven score blocks as immutable semantic judgments. Validate their opaque/source/render provenance, allowed anchors, and arithmetic; correct only a demonstrable transcription or sum error in the result document. Preserve E04 and E06 as unscorable and keep missing timing/usage fields distinct from zero. + +Before, the archived completion state was: + +```text +successful image renders: 0/14 +scorecard: 9 rows frozen as 채점 불가 +``` + +After the approved retry, the bounded final state is: + +```text +existing approved images: 7 desktop + 7 mobile +scored once: E01,E02,E03,E05,E07,E08,E09 +unscorable: E04,E06 +``` + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md`: preserve the nine-row result table, seven numeric score rows, seven evidence blocks, retry provenance, and bounded conclusion; repair only proven transcription/arithmetic defects. +- [ ] `agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/**`: read-only evidence; do not modify, regenerate, or add files. + +#### Test Strategy + +No test code is added because there is no behavior change. Use deterministic read-only ledger, hash, PNG-header, Markdown, and arithmetic checks. Cached output is not applicable. + +#### Verification + +Run the Final Verification commands below. Expect seven exact source/hash matches, fourteen PNGs with seven `1440x900` and seven `390x844` dimensions, unique E01-E09 opaque IDs, seven valid numeric totals, E04/E06 unscorable, and no producer/render mutation. + +### [TEST-2] Preserve Milestone Workstate Reconciliation Boundary + +#### Problem + +The Milestone already reconciles the prior producer/result-table completion at `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md:38`, while the two scorecard-related tasks at lines 40-41 must remain pending until this pair passes. Directly checking them during implementation would bypass `sync-milestone-workstate` evidence aggregation. + +#### Solution + +Keep `single-pass-scorecard` and `bounded-conclusion` unchecked during implementation. Preserve both IDs in the first-line metadata so official review PASS can write a canonical completion log and route normal Milestone workstate reconciliation. + +#### Modified Files and Checklist + +- [ ] `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md`: preserve the current reconciliation state; do not pre-check the two remaining tasks. +- [ ] `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md`: record implementation evidence while preserving the identical first-line milestone metadata. + +#### Test Strategy + +No roadmap helper or product test is added. Verify exact task IDs and checkbox state with deterministic searches; official PASS/runtime owns the later sync. + +#### Verification + +Confirm the PLAN and review first lines are identical and contain `milestone-task=single-pass-scorecard,bounded-conclusion`, while the active Milestone has both IDs unchecked. Expect no direct Milestone completion change in this implementation pass. + +## Modified Files Summary + +| File | Items | +|---|---| +| `agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md` | TEST-1 | +| `agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md` | TEST-2 | +| `agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md` | TEST-1, TEST-2 | + +## Final Verification + +1. Run this read-only provenance and dimension check from the repository root: + +```bash +python3 - <<'PY' +from pathlib import Path +import hashlib, struct +root = Path('agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01') +ids = ['E01','E02','E03','E05','E07','E08','E09'] +for eid in ids: + d = root / eid + expected = (d / 'source.txt').read_text().strip() + actual = hashlib.sha256((d / 'index.html').read_bytes()).hexdigest() + assert actual == expected, (eid, actual, expected) + for name, dims in [('desktop.png',(1440,900)),('mobile.png',(390,844))]: + data = (d / name).read_bytes() + assert data[:8] == b'\x89PNG\r\n\x1a\n' + width, height = struct.unpack('>II', data[16:24]) + assert (width, height) == dims, (eid, name, width, height) +print('source_sha_match=7/7') +print('desktop_dimensions=7/7') +print('mobile_dimensions=7/7') +PY +``` + +2. Run this frozen-score transcription/arithmetic check: + +```bash +python3 - <<'PY' +from pathlib import Path +import re +p = Path('agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md').read_text() +expected = {'E01':(40,11,14,18,83),'E02':(40,11,14,20,85),'E03':(40,11,14,20,85),'E05':(40,11,14,18,83),'E07':(40,11,14,18,83),'E08':(40,11,14,18,83),'E09':(40,11,14,20,85)} +for eid, scores in expected.items(): + m = re.search(rf'^\| {eid} \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| (\d+) \| 완료 \|$', p, re.M) + assert m and tuple(map(int, m.groups())) == scores + assert sum(scores[:4]) == scores[4] + assert re.search(rf'^{eid} — A:', p, re.M) +for eid in ('E04','E06'): + assert re.search(rf'^\| {eid} \| — \| — \| — \| — \| — \| 채점 불가 — source 없음 \|$', p, re.M) +assert '통계적 모델 우위' in p and '0으로 치환하지 않았고' in p +print('numeric_score_rows=7/7') +print('score_arithmetic=7/7') +print('unscorable_rows=2/2') +print('bounded_conclusion=present') +PY +``` + +3. Verify opaque IDs, milestone metadata/state, and scope integrity: + +```bash +test "$(awk '{print $2}' agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01/opaque-map.txt | sort -u | wc -l)" -eq 9 +test "$(sed -n '1p' agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/PLAN-local-G03.md)" = "$(sed -n '1p' agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G03.md)" +rg -n --sort path '^- \[ \] \[(single-pass-scorecard|bounded-conclusion)\]' agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md +git diff --check +git status --short -- agent-test/runs/bench-lite-01 agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md agent-roadmap/phase/knowledge-tool-optimization-extension/milestones/thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark.md agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark +``` + +Expected: nine unique opaque IDs; identical active headers; exactly the two target Milestone tasks remain unchecked before PASS; `git diff --check` exits zero; status contains only the pre-existing bounded evidence/document/Milestone changes plus this active pair. Do not run a producer, model, benchmark runner, browser, screenshot, render, retry, resume, or recovery command. + +After completing all code changes, fill implementation-owned sections in `CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md`. diff --git a/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md b/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md deleted file mode 100644 index cfce9400..00000000 --- a/agent-task/m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark/CODE_REVIEW-cloud-G08.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,100 +0,0 @@ - - -# Code Review Reference - TEST - -> **[IMPLEMENTING AGENT — READ FIRST]** Complete implementation-owned sections, paste actual output, and leave this pair active. Do not archive files, write `complete.log`, ask the user, or classify the next state. - -## Overview - -date=2026-08-14 -task=m-thin-agent-model-comparison-benchmark, plan=2, tag=TEST - -## Archive Evidence Snapshot - -- Pre-refine intent is checkpoint `e09aa66c3cdb829366463c10f8bc5f5801e3136e`. -- Replaced unstarted refinement: `plan_local_G08_1.log`, `code_review_cloud_G08_1.log`; no verdict. -- This replan fixes URL normalization, token lifetime, and Claude row-workspace binding without changing the benchmark scope. - -## For the Review Agent - -Rerun applicable deterministic checks and inspect immutable evidence. Append an official verdict only after implementation is submitted. On PASS, archive this pair with suffix `2`, preserve first-line milestone metadata in `complete.log`, and move the task directory to the dated archive; roadmap aggregation remains a later runtime action. - -## Implementation Item Completion - -| Item | Status | -|---|---| -| TEST-1 Consume the Immutable Nine-Row Matrix | [ ] | -| TEST-2 Render, Score Once, and Conclude | [ ] | - -## Implementation Checklist - -- [ ] Pass the authenticated catalog/runtime gate without creating a producer workspace. -- [ ] Create nine empty row workspaces and execute each fixed caller/model tuple exactly once in its row workspace, with no retry/resume/recovery. -- [ ] Fill the nine-row result table from immutable evidence, using caller-provided usage or `미제공`. -- [ ] After all attempts, create one shuffled opaque bijection and copy/extract each scorable exact source without route facts. -- [ ] Render each scorable opaque source once at desktop and once at mobile, then score it once with locked anchors and direct evidence. -- [ ] Write a bounded conclusion comparing only successful scorable results and separating operational facts from quality. -- [ ] Run the final count, isolation, placeholder, retry, secret, arithmetic, and scope checks. -- [ ] Fill implementation-owned sections in CODE_REVIEW-*-G??.md with actual implementation notes and verification output. - -## Review-Only Checklist - -> **[REVIEW AGENT ONLY]** Implementing agents must not modify this checklist. - -- [ ] Append one verdict with verified `review_rework_count` and `evidence_integrity_failure`. -- [ ] Verify verdict, dimensions, and finding severities agree. -- [ ] Rerun required checks and inspect the nine ledgers/streams plus score evidence. -- [ ] For every Required/Suggested finding, record evidence, exact root cause, one selected fix, affected files/tests, and acceptance commands. -- [ ] Archive this file to `code_review_cloud_G08_2.log` and the plan to `plan_local_G08_2.log`. -- [ ] Verify the Agent-Ops `.gitignore` block. -- [ ] On PASS, write `complete.log`, preserve milestone metadata, move the task directory to the dated archive, and update this checklist there. -- [ ] On WARN/FAIL, create only the next state required by the code-review skill and do not write `complete.log`. - -## Deviations from Plan - -_Replace with actual deviations or `None`._ - -## Key Design Decisions - -_Replace with actual implementation decisions._ - -## Reviewer Checkpoints - -- Confirm URL normalization yields one `/v1/models`, the token remains available through row 09, and no producer workspace predates gate success. -- Confirm all nine exact tuples ran once and each direct caller was bound to its declared empty row workspace. -- Confirm no product/config/script/manifest/state-store change entered the worktree. -- Confirm route facts were absent from opaque scoring inputs until all scores froze. -- Confirm usage is caller-provided or `미제공`, and failures/unscorable artifacts are not zero. -- Confirm every scorable source has one SHA record, two one-shot renders, direct anchor evidence, and correct arithmetic. - -## Verification Results - -### External gate and producer attempts - -Paste redacted gate output, each expanded command, sole exit status, and `attempt.txt`. Do not paste credentials or sensitive raw provider payloads. - -_Replace with actual output._ - -### Local deterministic checks - -Run the exact final checks from `PLAN-local-G08.md` and paste stdout/stderr plus exit statuses. - -_Replace with actual output._ - -### Manual scorecard review - -Record reviewer arithmetic, anchor/evidence, opaque isolation, render count, usage handling, and bounded-conclusion findings. - -_Replace with actual findings._ - ---- - -## Section Ownership - -| Section | Owner | Note | -|---|---|---| -| Header, overview, archive snapshot, reviewer instructions | Fixed | Implementer must not modify | -| Implementation item/checklist status | Implementer | Check only after actual completion | -| Review-Only Checklist | Review agent | Implementer must not modify | -| Deviations, decisions, verification results | Implementer, then reviewer | Replace placeholders with actual evidence | -| Code Review Result | Review agent | Appended only during official review | diff --git a/agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md b/agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md index 22366240..a5ed89ae 100644 --- a/agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md +++ b/agent-test/dev/iop-thin-agent-model-comparison.md @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ - execution preset은 Edge private workspace cleanup 계약을 유지하므로 caller-visible terminal marker와 최종 응답의 exact HTML code block을 확인한다. - usage는 caller가 직접 제공한 값만 기록하고 없으면 `미제공`으로 둔다. - 기존 원격 SOPS token과 command-scoped managed CA만 사용하며 별도 benchmark token이나 전역 CA override를 만들지 않는다. -- 이 세션의 execution preset Work는 live `ornith:35b` 바인딩을 사용한다. tracked runtime 설정은 변경하지 않는다. +- 이 세션의 execution preset Work는 live `ornith-fast` 바인딩을 사용한다. tracked runtime 설정은 변경하지 않는다. - 각 exact HTML source와 SHA-256, `1440×900` desktop 및 `390×844` mobile render만 ignored run evidence에 보존한다. render는 품질 분석 입력이지 제품 경로의 pass/fail gate가 아니다. - full source를 얻지 못한 실행은 `실행 실패`와 별개로 `채점 불가`로 기록하며 0점으로 바꾸지 않는다. - scorable source에는 실행 후 opaque 평가 ID를 부여한다. 단일 평가 pass에는 ID, source와 두 render만 제공하고 route·model·시간·usage 매핑은 점수와 evidence가 고정된 뒤 결합한다. @@ -29,15 +29,15 @@ | 경로 | 평가 ID | 상태 | 경과 시간 | caller usage | source SHA-256 / terminal evidence | 짧은 관찰 | |---|---|---|---:|---|---|---| -| Claude Code → Claude direct | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| Claude Code → Gemini direct | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| OpenCode → Gemini direct | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| Claude Code → GPT direct | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| Codex → GPT direct | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| Claude Code → Gemini execution preset | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| OpenCode → Gemini execution preset | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| Claude Code → GPT execution preset | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | -| Codex → GPT execution preset | 미부여 | 미실행 | 미측정 | 미제공 | 미확인 | — | +| Claude Code → Claude direct | E08 | 성공 | 83.745초 | input 5, cache create 15,062, cache read 10,396, output 11,622 | `e15fc6f3295438a0a384d41b15e38fe793d842760d505003345cfede56612bf1` / marker 확인 | exact workspace source 및 사용자 승인 동일 viewport render 확보 | +| Claude Code → Gemini direct | E05 | 성공 | 80.363초 | input 41,736, output 10,858 | `7dc4d4d520c28504135ad81c7594599a0aef15f3be4f1e486db0bafd2908fbcd` / marker 확인 | exact workspace source 및 사용자 승인 동일 viewport render 확보 | +| OpenCode → Gemini direct | E01 | 성공 | 77초 | input 12,285, cache read 24,478, output 4,482, total 41,245 | `c83a046c9ebe6aa2bdeb4954ecad37312abd362caa30c20041862ca65edd6aeb` / marker 확인 | exact workspace source 및 사용자 승인 동일 viewport render 확보 | +| Claude Code → GPT direct | E09 | 성공 | 63.757초 | input 31,056, output 12,377 | `b256b53042b4e4d1bfe49c1a36175c0e1055fe30f6d813995f59dfd98457e6a8` / marker 확인 | exact workspace source 및 사용자 승인 동일 viewport render 확보 | +| Codex → GPT direct | E03 | 성공 | 미제공 | input 58,576, cached input 38,245, cache write input 20,106, output 9,007, reasoning output 369 | `2cf8cd8782e5b10b70c09674b7c2b768ccc96c41e57107df63abfec66b434b01` / terminal marker 확인 | exact workspace source 및 사용자 승인 동일 viewport render 확보 | +| Claude Code → Gemini execution preset | E04 | 실행 실패 | 37.532초 | input 0, output 0 | source 없음 / `API Error: single-request execution failed` | sole invocation exit 1; 재시도하지 않음 | +| OpenCode → Gemini execution preset | E07 | 성공 | 0초 | input 0, output 0 | `a9966cac565854c69c56d5c288ae92519e45f9c1686f80df0008559f46cab958` / terminal marker 확인 | terminal exact fence 추출 및 사용자 승인 동일 viewport render 확보 | +| Claude Code → GPT execution preset | E06 | 응답 불완전 | 89.870초 | input 0, output 0 | source 없음 / terminal marker·exact fence 없음 | 완료 문구만 반환해 채점 불가; 재시도하지 않음 | +| Codex → GPT execution preset | E02 | 성공 | 미제공 | input 123,280, cached input 39,124, cache write input 83,814, output 7,557, reasoning output 372 | `c7760fcffe964ffe7189a600d47534bab9731fe158f49b169c6461d83324838c` / terminal marker 확인 | terminal exact fence 추출 및 사용자 승인 동일 viewport render 확보 | ## 공통 평가 기준표 — 100점 @@ -59,20 +59,38 @@ | 평가 ID | A /40 | B /20 | C /20 | D /20 | 총점 /100 | 채점 상태 | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---| -| 미부여-01 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-02 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-03 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-04 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-05 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-06 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-07 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-08 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | -| 미부여-09 | — | — | — | — | — | 미채점 | +| E01 | 40 | 11 | 14 | 18 | 83 | 완료 | +| E02 | 40 | 11 | 14 | 20 | 85 | 완료 | +| E03 | 40 | 11 | 14 | 20 | 85 | 완료 | +| E04 | — | — | — | — | — | 채점 불가 — source 없음 | +| E05 | 40 | 11 | 14 | 18 | 83 | 완료 | +| E06 | — | — | — | — | — | 채점 불가 — source 없음 | +| E07 | 40 | 11 | 14 | 18 | 83 | 완료 | +| E08 | 40 | 11 | 14 | 18 | 83 | 완료 | +| E09 | 40 | 11 | 14 | 20 | 85 | 완료 | + +E01 — A: 문서·style·무외부자산·무JS·exact meta와 필수 구조를 모두 충족해 40; B: desktop 위계는 명확하지만 mobile에서 제목·본문·카드가 오른쪽으로 잘려 11; C: landmark·CTA·문자 상태표시는 명확하나 mobile 가독성이 깨져 14; D: 일관된 dark palette와 카드 체계는 좋지만 mobile polish 결함으로 18; 감점: 390×844 overflow/clipping. + +E02 — A: 모든 요청 selector와 정확한 meta를 충족해 40; B: desktop 구성은 강하지만 mobile의 hero·상태 라벨이 오른쪽에서 잘려 11; C: heading/landmark, 의미 있는 CTA, `Operational` 문구는 좋으나 mobile 가독성 결함으로 14; D: 강한 타이포·status component·색상 체계와 독자성이 명확해 20; 감점: 390×844 horizontal overflow. + +E03 — A: 필수 문서·구조·콘텐츠·breakpoint를 모두 충족해 40; B: desktop hierarchy는 뛰어나지만 mobile hero와 CTA가 viewport 밖으로 잘려 11; C: semantic heading/landmark, CTA, 문자 상태표시는 충족하나 mobile 사용성이 저하돼 14; D: 타이포·lime accent·mission-control card의 결속과 독자성이 명확해 20; 감점: 390×844 clipping. + +E05 — A: 모든 명시 요구를 충족해 40; B: desktop은 안정적이나 mobile 제목·본문·section heading이 잘려 11; C: landmark·CTA·상태 label은 갖췄지만 mobile reading flow 결함으로 14; D: palette/type/card 일관성은 좋으나 비교적 일반적이고 mobile polish가 부족해 18; 감점: 390×844 overflow. + +E07 — A: 문서·내부 style·무외부자산·무JS·meta와 요청 section을 모두 충족해 40; B: desktop은 균형 잡혔지만 mobile copy와 feature heading/card가 잘려 11; C: 의미 있는 CTA와 non-color status label은 명확하나 mobile 가독성으로 14; D: gradient accent와 component cohesion은 좋지만 mobile 마감 결함으로 18; 감점: 390×844 clipping. + +E08 — A: 모든 필수 selector와 exact meta를 충족해 40; B: desktop hierarchy는 안정적이나 mobile navigation wrap과 hero/section text clipping으로 11; C: landmark·CTA·상태 문구는 명확하나 좁은 viewport 가독성으로 14; D: 정돈된 palette·spacing·card 체계는 좋지만 mobile header와 overflow 마감이 부족해 18; 감점: 390×844 header wrap 및 clipping. + +E09 — A: 필수 문서·구조·콘텐츠·breakpoint를 모두 충족해 40; B: desktop은 강한 2-column hierarchy지만 mobile hero·CTA·dashboard가 오른쪽으로 잘려 11; C: semantic 구조·CTA·문자 상태표시는 좋으나 mobile 조작·읽기 영역이 손실돼 14; D: typography, blue palette, dashboard/status cohesion과 독자성이 명확해 20; 감점: 390×844 horizontal overflow. Evidence block 형식: `평가 ID — A: 충족/누락 selector와 점수; B~D: source selector 또는 viewport에서 직접 관찰한 근거; 감점: 기준·anchor·사유`. 한 결함당 한 문장으로 제한한다. 평가는 산출물별 한 번만 수행하고, 이후 수정은 합계 산술 오류나 evidence 전사 오류만 허용하며 수정 사유를 같은 block에 남긴다. 이 총점은 고정 rubric과 직접 evidence에 기반한 재검산 가능한 단일 평가 점수다. 반복 표본이나 다중 평가자 합의가 아니므로 통계적 모델 우위나 절대적 품질 척도로 해석하지 않는다. +재수집 render provenance: 최초 로컬 Chromium 실패 뒤 사용자 승인으로 프로세스를 강제 종료·재시작했고, 동일 source·opaque ID·viewport를 유지해 dev runner의 독립 Chrome으로 다시 캡처했다. desktop/mobile SHA-256은 각각 E01 `769177e7…`/`64898950…`, E02 `63e9bcdb…`/`1b2e9cd0…`, E03 `46f255b9…`/`fff81780…`, E05 `cf430192…`/`fef49876…`, E07 `6d799a75…`/`ae7be5a4…`, E08 `fce30317…`/`b99eaa2b…`, E09 `d0c7990c…`/`ccef5b70…`이다. + ## 결론 -9개 단일 시도와 단일 평가가 끝난 뒤 scorable 결과의 총점과 축별 강점·약점만 짧게 비교한다. 실행 성공률·속도·usage는 품질 총점과 별도로 제시한다. 실패, 채점 불가와 미제공 usage를 0점으로 바꾸거나 반복 실행·통계적 우위로 일반화하지 않는다. +9개 조합은 각각 한 번씩 실행되었고, 7개는 exact HTML source를 확보했으며 1개는 실행 실패, 1개는 exact terminal source가 없어 응답 불완전으로 남았다. caller가 제공한 경과 시간 중에는 Claude Code → GPT direct가 63.757초로 가장 짧았지만 Codex 두 행의 경과 시간은 제공되지 않아 전체 속도 순위를 만들 수 없다. usage는 caller가 제공한 필드만 위 표에 보존했다. + +최초 로컬 Chromium 14개 render는 모두 hang 또는 timeout이었고, 이후 사용자가 프로세스 강제 재시작과 동일 기준 재시도를 명시적으로 승인했다. 동일 opaque ID와 1440×900/390×844 viewport를 유지한 독립 Chrome 재수집으로 scorable 7개를 한 번 채점했다. E02·E03·E09가 85점, E01·E05·E07·E08이 83점이었으며, 7개 모두 desktop 완성도는 높았지만 390×844에서 horizontal overflow와 clipping이 공통으로 관찰됐다. 이는 단일 과제·단일 평가 결과이므로 모델 우위로 일반화하지 않는다. 실행 실패 E04, 응답 불완전 E06, 미제공 경과 시간은 0으로 치환하지 않았고 producer 호출은 재시도하지 않았다.